Oh la la! What a scrumptious idea!
I voted Othello.

I'm taking an intro to Shakespeare class right now (the professor has dubbed it "baby Shakespeare"), and we were placed into groups, and each group was assigned a play to do a presentation on. What did my group get? Othello.
And I was put with some awesome people; one of the more unique things we'll be featuring in our presentation is our very own sock puppet production of Othello.
Ultimately, if Othello wins, I'm in. Romeo & Juliet is good for me too. And I'd be more inclined to do a more comedic representation of the play, rather than a serious one.