I thought I would hate it, I was prepared to hate it, I went to the movie prepared to whine and pick the entire time.I'm so attached to Kirk, I really didn't think I could handle anyone else portraying him or messing with classic Trek cannon but I was surprisingly ok with it. There were aspects I didn't love but as a whole, I rather enjoyed it. I thought Karl Urban was going to be an utter failure as McCoy, nothing against the man, I just thought it was odd casting again, Shatner is Kirk, no one else should even try but both actors did respectable jobs. They will never eclipse the original actors for me but I was able to live with them.





I'm so attached to Kirk, I really didn't think I could handle anyone else portraying him or messing with classic Trek cannon but I was surprisingly ok with it. There were aspects I didn't love but as a whole, I rather enjoyed it. I thought Karl Urban was going to be an utter failure as McCoy, nothing against the man, I just thought it was odd casting again, Shatner is Kirk, no one else should even try but both actors did respectable jobs. They will never eclipse the original actors for me but I was able to live with them.
Reply With Quote
