Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12
Results 16 to 23 of 23

Thread: The start of a story. Feel free to critique.

  1. #16
    Plus Ultra
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    chimera
    Posts
    19
    I have to say, I liked the first approach to the theme as a short-story, when it gave a total different impression of the situation. It was a perfect short-story, except for the few grammar and spelling problems, I'd say.

    And when the extension of the story adopted a completely different turn, I said to myself-'I liked the first one better. The first part brought a kind of sympathy for the protagonist, and the passive continuation of the story was what satisfied my expectation of it. But by the time I finished 'Part-two', I felt none-the-less than I did while the first piece of the story.

    A story isn't a story until at least one of its lines or dialogue hits the reader. This story had some much striking lines, I'd like to quote one of them, cause this one I will remember for a long time-

    'Heaven is only heaven if you can look down at the world below.'

    Thank you for sharing this writing with us. Great job.

  2. #17
    Wild is the Wind Silas Thorne's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Location
    New Zealand (Mostly)
    Posts
    2,788
    Blog Entries
    94
    Quote Originally Posted by firewrathed View Post
    And when the extension of the story adopted a completely different turn, I said to myself-'I liked the first one better. The first part brought a kind of sympathy for the protagonist, and the passive continuation of the story was what satisfied my expectation of it. But by the time I finished 'Part-two', I felt none-the-less than I did while the first piece of the story.
    We don't see what his younger sister is really like until the second piece though. I think the style needs to be different because one part's about the brother, the other about the sister. Their perspectives are different.

  3. #18
    A FLEECED MONSTROSITY aBIGsheep's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Under your Bed
    Posts
    485
    Thanks. Those pretty hefty compliments you got there. Part Two needs A LOT of work.
    Knowing me, I'm going to hack part two apart and try and make it ten times better, which probably wouldn't be all that hard. I've already had some compliments about part two and how they liked part one more. The edits will be up soon.
    AND I GOTTA CHANGE THE NAMES NOW!!!! F!
    Charlie and Renee are the names of the parents in Twilight. Now I need to change them. Ugh.

    I really appreciate your comments Silas, you always have something to say. We need more people like you in the world.
    The worst feeling in the world isn't loneliness, it's being forgotten by someone you can't forget.

  4. #19
    Plus Ultra
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    chimera
    Posts
    19
    Thank you silas for noting my remarks about the story. Yes, I understand that the story is still left nowhere, needs a lot of re-thinking by the writer, but what I meant by saying 'I felt none-the-less than I felt while reading the first piece...' was that the captivity and the style of the writer seized my interest none-the-less it did in the first piece.

    And to the writer now,don't you think you should shape the theme a bit in your mind and then start writing it? I know that inconsistency can be a good thing for a writer, but I think, if you straightened up the ideas about what you'd really like the story to come off as, it would be easier for you to accomplish it. I'll be eagerly waiting for the update of the story.

    And to silas again- I really liked your critical comments about the story. It would be very nice of you if you read my upcoming story and put a few comments for it.

  5. #20
    A FLEECED MONSTROSITY aBIGsheep's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Under your Bed
    Posts
    485
    You know, I have a name.

    Quote Originally Posted by firewrathed View Post
    And to the writer now,don't you think you should shape the theme a bit in your mind and then start writing it? I know that inconsistency can be a good thing for a writer, but I think, if you straightened up the ideas about what you'd really like the story to come off as, it would be easier for you to accomplish it. I'll be eagerly waiting for the update of the story.
    You think I haven't? I'd be a fool not too.
    The worst feeling in the world isn't loneliness, it's being forgotten by someone you can't forget.

  6. #21
    Plus Ultra
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    chimera
    Posts
    19
    Of course I know, bigsheep.

    It's good that you have, cause your earlier updates suggested that you didn't really make any outline for the story. waiting for the second part. it has taken a quite interesting turn.
    He who asks questions, can not avoid the answers.
    - proverb from Ashanti

  7. #22
    Registered User burntpunk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Posts
    51
    There's a body below me. And no, I didn't kill him, though I felt like I did. Good hook; doesn't feel like you're trying to hook me even though you are. The fact that you use 'no' indicates a conversational feel, always good to make a instant connection with the reader quick. (y)

    Some of the dirt started to fall from between my fingers and onto my $700 designer Mezlans. I didn't care though. A few months ago, I'd probably would've decided to throw such an inexpensive pair away for so much as a spec. But, something in the back of my neck told me to do something special today. Looks like we have a materialistic ****. Awesome.
    Something special often revolved around picking up an 'escort' or dropping a few grand on a new luxury Lexus. Something special often meant going out and completely obliterating myself on ancient, Chteau Margaux wine with a woman who didn't love me. Prose has continued well in this second paragraph, if you are to repeat a word, special feels seedy to me. Is that the intention?

    But as a mound of dirt started to pile up on my foot, I finally got the good mind to throw the clump of Earth in my hand. The wind blew most of it away, letting the dirt drift uselessly in the wind. This must be the final '**** you' from father. Mustering all his ghostly powers to reject me, to say that, No, I don't accept your apalogy. Thanks for coming, but you're just a dead man too late. You seem to use a lot of blunt words here. 'mound', 'pile' 'clump' 'drift' 'mustering' I know they're all relevant and appropriate, and yes you've accomplished a level of competence, but if you want to take your prose up a notch, strive for the words that stretch it further. Dynamic. Vivid. Sharp words.

    "Rest in peace, Dad," I said to the shoddy wooden coffin 6 feet below me. The grave digger leaning on his shovel beside me, my only witness, groaned.

    "You done, sir?" but before I could respond he had already started to shovel dirt onto the grave.

    I watched him for a moment. Where had he gotten his pants? Wal-mart? Look at that morning shadow and unruly hair! I understand what you're doing with the character, but the way you've worded it comes off as corny. Throw $15 away and go to Super-cuts at least. How much money was he getting paid for doing this? $10, maybe $15 dollars? I get paid the same amount for just standing here. This guy pissed me off. He was rude and poor, something ugly straight from the bottom of the pit hole.

    But what bothered me the most, more than his acne scars and his nose hair, was that he was given the privilege. He was the last person to say goodbye to him. The last person to finally shut the door on his life and bury him into the Earth. My father didn't deserve this man, and this man didn't deserve to finally extinguish my father's connection to the world.
    But as he worked, letting his sweat pour into his grave, he dropped more than few sorry specs of dirt onto my father's coffin.

    The gravedigger stopped working, finally aware that he had an audience.
    "**** man, I'm trying to work here. It's bad enough I gotta work in a grave yard. Don't need no spooky relatives trying to pry with me their eyes."

    Who gave this man the privilege?
    "Do you have another shovel?"

    "It's back at the shed, but damn, you sure you want to ruin that spiffy suit of yours?"

    "Wears the shed?"

    He pointed out into the distance and I set off.
    As soon as I returned the grave digger looked up at me.
    "Christ, you're not kidding," and he went back to work.

    Wordlessly, I started shoveling.
    "Where's everyone else?" he asked.

    Of all my siblings, I was the only one who bothered to show up.
    "Gone."
    He didn't say anything after that.
    With reference to the certain bluntness in your lexis, I challenge you to use a noun in the role of a verb, at least once, shake things up. Think of odd word connotations, let the words take on the role of the story.

    Perhaps it was the intention, but given that this was a burial scene, I didn't feel particularly stimulated emotionally, perhaps you wanted a mellow feel, I understand trying to perpetrate raw emotion at the start of a story, is one of the most common mistakes young writers make, so I tackling a funeral scene isn't going to be easy. But like I said, you've reached a level of competence, and that is impressive, I understand the story, every component functions. But I still feel that you could take things up a notch.
    “Ho, ho, ho! Well, if it isn’t fat stinking billy goat Billy Boy in poison! How art thou, thou globby bottle of cheap, stinking chip oil? Come and get one in the yarbles, if ya have any yarbles, you eunuch jelly thou!”

    Alex deLarge, A Clockwork Orange

  8. #23
    A FLEECED MONSTROSITY aBIGsheep's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    Under your Bed
    Posts
    485
    Part 3

    My brain says go to sleep. But my alarm clock says no, no, no. The digital-red numbers are flashing beside my face.

    7 o’ clock it says. 7 hours I’ve been up.

    But I can’t sleep. Ryan Thomas doesn’t need any rest -- he’s better than that. Most people would start groping for the snooze button. Not Ryan Thomas -- Ryan Thomas looks up into the cosmos of his ceiling -- empty pace and nothingness are one in the same. People are so infatuated with what’s up above them. They’re infatuated with things millions upon millions of miles away. They ask questions upon questions about **** that they’re never going to see or touch. They go out and make fancy diploma-deserving deductions about what’s there and what isn’t.

    I’m right here mother****er. Touch my suit, smell my over-priced cologne. Taste the liquor on my breath.

    Go ahead! Feel free to ask me a question and I’ll answer. I can see it now. They’d look skeptically at me in part disbelief and part astonishment. They’d ask me some all-hassle, all-encompassing question like what is the meaning to life? Why do we exist? Is it all an illusion? They’d keep asking the same question expecting a different answer. They beg and beg and then I’d try and roll over and reach for the snooze button but there’s nothing there.

    The point of life is to keep on living, I’d say. Don’t you understand? All of us are wandering aimlessly through this ****ing little mud ball of a planet and you’re too busy looking at the ****ing sky. Don’t you feel small? Don’t you realize what little role you play in the universe?

    So make the best of it, I say.

    I roll out off my silk sheets and walk naked into my bath room. I turn the faucet and like a good God, 7 hours of sleep deprivation gets washed away from a flash-flood of cold water.

    Someone’s breathing too loudly. Not the poor bastard on the lab-table at least. My scalpel is 2 centimeters from his liver and if he was breathing any faster then I might actually be worried. It might be the master surgeon standing over my shoulder. I’m going to beat his record time today. And I’m not going to barley skim over his time -- I’m going to absolutely demolish it. If it were some faceless scrub masked-surgeon he might be happy for them. He might look at them and pat them on the back for besting him. He’d know that he can perform another surgery and successfully reform the score board. But I‘m not them. I’m going to wipe his disgrace all over the stopwatch. He’s hoping I might mess up -- hoping against hope that I might puncture a kidney or run my blade a little too deep against an artery or something.

    Not me. There isn’t a maybe about the matter. I’m going to do beat him and I’m going to enjoy it in a silent revelry that’ll hurt worse than tattooing the numbers into his forehead.
    The worst feeling in the world isn't loneliness, it's being forgotten by someone you can't forget.

Page 2 of 2 FirstFirst 12

Similar Threads

  1. "Sensei, let me give you your soul back"
    By greedyduck in forum Short Story Sharing
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 08-02-2011, 02:48 AM
  2. A Few Statements: Feel Free to Pick Apart
    By Pendragon in forum Religious Texts
    Replies: 27
    Last Post: 09-10-2008, 09:32 PM
  3. Revels before Lent
    By SleepyWitch in forum Short Story Sharing
    Replies: 90
    Last Post: 08-24-2007, 03:11 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •