Tiny Dancer, I saw the film, "Jane Austen Book Club" a few weeks back; after I did review it. Antiquarian and I disagreed somewhat on this film; mostly, I think due to the fact that she read the book and had a higher expectation of the film; whereas I did not read the book. I figured the film was going to be light and just entertaining, and it appeared to be low budget and simplistic, so that is all I really expected; just a funny film with a bunch of crazy characters - 'ensemble' I guess, but not really major stars and a major plot.
Hey, Antiquarian, I think you and I could be like the old Siskel and Ebert - didn't sometimes or most times disagree? My son and I used to watch them on TV all the time, when he was growing up; my son was quite the movie buff, still does love films.
Tiny Dancer, I guess I am not quite as tough a critic as Antiquarian; actually I am a bit soft that way; I have a wide range of films I will watch and some are not as great as others, but I still feel things about them I can enjoy. I usually just pick out what appeals to me and getting them free at my library I don't have to be too choosy and often just try something that looks interesting.
I liked this film well enough, probably to see it again sometime, since my library owns it. Yeah, it is predictable, and loose ends are all tied up neatly at the end. However, I still did enjoy the characters and especially I enjoyed Hugh Dancy, he is incredible cute. Kathy Baker is getting frumpy - she's getting old. I like her anyway. A lot of actresses are getting old and some frumpy, I guess. I may be frumpy at times myself. I'm not real familar with Emily Blunt (don't watch TV), but I thought she was funny, because she was so obnoxious. I thought the woman and husband breakup, could have used more work, that was a weak part to me; it is probably better in the book. Did you read the book, TD? I should probably read the book, right? The film was enjoyable, but it also was not deep or profound, it was just entertaining, I suppose.


"It's so mysterious, the land of tears."
Reply With Quote


