Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Hesse: Narcissus & Goldmund

  1. #1

    Hesse: Narcissus & Goldmund

    http://www.*********.com/author-46/Hermann-Hesse

    For several years in the mid-1910s Hesse underwent
    psychoanalysis under Carl Jung's assistant J.B.
    Lang.

    After receiving the Nobel Prize Hesse published no
    major works. Between the years 1945 and 1962 he
    wrote some 50 poems and about 32 reviews mostly for
    Swiss newspapers. Hesse died of cerebral hemorrhage
    in his sleep on August 9, 1962 at the age of
    eighty-five.

    In 1969 the Californian rock group Sparrow changed
    their name to Steppenwolf after Hesse's classic,
    and released 'Born to be Wild'. Hesse's books have
    gained readers from the New Age movements and he is
    still one of the bestselling German-speaking
    writers throughout world.

    Narcissus and Goldmund

    Hesse's novel of two medieval men, one quietly
    content with his religion and monastic life, the
    other in fervent search of more worldly salvation.

    This conflict between flesh and spirit, between
    emotional and contemplative man, was a life study
    for Hesse. It is a theme that transcends all time.
    The Hesse Phenomenon "has turned into a vogue, the
    vogue into a torrent. . .He has appealed both to. .
    . an underground and to an establishment. . .and to
    the disenchanted young sharing his contempt for our
    industrial civilization

    Goldmund has no mother (presumably she died giving
    birth to him--or maybe she ran off. We can't be
    sure.) His distant and cold father leaves Goldmund
    at the monastery to be educated. Now in the Middle
    Ages, there was nothing unusual in that;
    monasteries were the schools, seats of learning,
    medical centers and scientific research institutes.
    Goldmund meets Narcissus, a handsome, ascetic young
    novice monk who is well suited for the monastic
    life and is an ideal monk and incredible scholar.
    Goldmund, who is the complete opposite from

    Narcissus (worldly, sexual, sensual) develops a
    strong friendship with Narcissus, who senses
    something is very wrong with Goldmund and tries to
    help him.

    Goldmund's subsequent wanderings take him on
    fantastic adventures and ultimately to finding
    himself. Narcissus, too, must discover himself, but
    not in the way he had expected.

    This is by far Hesse's most beautiful novel, and an
    exciting story, too. This is a very good
    translation; I've read the original German and this
    translation preserves some of the rhythm of the
    language that is naturally lost when brought into
    English.

    Hesse takes two young men - one devoted to the
    hermetic religious life and another more into the
    decadent artistic life - and follows them through
    adulthood. There are some amazing scenes here -
    scenes of great artistic creation, a journey
    through a plague ravaged world, the reunion of the
    two friends - that rank among the best things Hesse
    ever wrote.

    True the characters are more "types" than real
    three dimensional characters. It is obvious that
    Hesse wants to examine the spiritual/cerebral
    approach to existence versus the more
    artistic/physical approach to life, and to find
    them both wanting. This is less a slice of life
    novel than a modern parable. Taken on those terms,
    this novel is Hesse at the height of his powers and
    deserves to be better known and read than it
    currently is.

    This novel is a philosophical and allegorical story
    of the friendship between two exact opposites, one
    staying in the medieval monastery to pursue his
    career of deprivation, intellectualism, scholarship
    and logic, the other becoming a vagabond who
    wonders from landscape to landscape, trouble to
    trouble, love affair to love affair. The two are
    almost personifications of opposites, but this only
    strenthens their friendship built on differences
    and ensures that despite years of separation, they
    continually think of each other and enrich each
    other's life through a different worldview.


    This is one of Hesse's most famous novels, and yes,
    it does have flaws. I agree with some readers who
    found the whole thing to drag a bit too long. It's
    hard for a writer to keep up a philosophical work,
    especially an allegory without giving the
    impression that they are struggling to continually
    be profound and yet failing. This occasionally
    happens in the book. This is because the picaresque
    in the middle drags on without continuing the idea
    of the two characters' friendship as they are
    separated.

    Despite all this, I found the best thing about this
    was Hesse's style as it's magical, filled with
    mystic wonder and yet very penetrating. The
    problems faced by the characters about the way in
    which we should pursue meaning in our lives, about
    the balance of opposites (especially the "mind" and
    "soul") as well as the meaning of science and art,
    are so universal that their mere presence in this
    work gives it an atmosphere of grandness. But to
    me, this work is mainly an account of an amazing
    friendship.

    The edition I read was another translation which I
    couldn't find in the catalogue, so I'm not sure
    which aspects of the book might be better or worse
    because of this being a different translation.
    While many people may dislike this, and I don't
    consider it a masterpiece, it is moving and
    thoughtprovoking.

    This, above all other of his works, should be
    listed as Hesse's masterpiece. It is a novel so
    full of ideas, a story posing so many challenges to
    its heroes that it is impossible not to think about
    the choices each man makes for his life for days,
    weeks - or a lifetime after. Few books have
    affected me with the profundity and beauty as
    Narcissus and Goldmund.

    On each page Hesse captures the spirits of these
    two friends - as different as night and day - yet
    united in the bond of friendship that is as strong
    as filial or romantic love. Goldmund's global
    wandering and Narcissus's remaining leads each man
    to view the world uniquely and when again together,
    to share those opinions in a manner that is, to the
    reader, almost voyeuristic.


    A beautiful tale, beautifully told.
    The novel is basically a beautiful well written
    long parable. The setting is 14th century Germany
    during the plague years of the Black Death. A young
    man, Goldmund, is taken to a monestary by his
    merchant father after the death of Goldmund's
    beautiful mother. Here he is treated with kindness
    by Brother Daniel even though he gets into
    conflicts with the other students. He meets a
    fellow student, Narcissus, who is a contemplative
    seeker of God, enlightenment,and spiritual
    contentment. Through this friendship Goldmund calms
    down and is eventually recognized by Father Anselm
    as having potential.

    However, after having intercourse with a young
    married woman outside the monastary, Goldmund must
    go into the world to seek truth, beauty, adventure,
    sex, and eventually the discipline of the arts. He
    becomes an appretice with a master artist, Master
    Niklaus, and creates a sculpture of the Madonna
    that allows Goldmund to fully express the loss of
    his mother and capture the beauty and grace of the
    feminine.

    As is the case with most good parables, the book
    can be understood in a wide range of
    interpretations. The classic Apollo/Dionysius
    duality from classical studies is definitely
    present. Narcissus takes the path of Apollo, toward
    light, God, reason, contemplation, reflection,
    insight, enlightenment. Goldmund takes the path of
    Dionysius toward the truth and call of the body,
    the lessons of earthly pleasure and pain, the
    sacrifice of the body in work and sexuality, the
    search for truth and the creation of beauty.

    There is another interesting way to view this
    parable. I thought that the life of Goldmund
    demonstrated the role of the son, lover, and
    sacrificial victim in relationship to the mother,
    consort, layer-out White Goddess archtype. The role
    of the male is defined in relationship to the
    various relationships a male has with females in
    his life. Thus the contrast is not between
    Narcissus and Goldmund but between Goldmund and the
    eternal feminine. He dreams and grieves over his
    lost beutiful mother and wishes to regain her
    presence and love. He becomes a lover of many women
    in many different relationships. He creates the
    single work of sculpture that allows him to build in
    real matter the archtype he has followed. He
    finally returns to the monastary and dies with
    visions of returning to the feminine manifestation
    of God.

    If I could control public school education, I would
    have every child between ages 12-14 read Mark
    Twain's "Huckelberry Finn", every young teen
    between 14-16 read Harper Lee's "To Kill A
    Mockingbird", every teen between 17-21 read J. D.
    Salinger's "Catcher in the Rye" and every young
    adult 22-26 to read Hesse's "Narcissus and
    Goldmund".

    I say this because the duality between the
    characters of Narcissus and Goldmund is a duality
    that young people feel in the depths of their soul.
    they ask: Do I seek God? Do I seek beauty? Do I
    find myself in sexual experience? Do I find myself
    in contemplation? Do I create and what do I create?
    Narcissus and Goldmund shows these paths, the
    rewards and costs of following each, and the final
    resolution of these paths.


    ============

    The happiest is the one who never asks the question
    "who is the happiest?" - Sitaram
    Last edited by Sitaram; 03-02-2005 at 05:52 PM.

  2. #2
    i happened to get a copy of Narcissus and Goldmund in a box of old Steven King novels (one of those- please take these, you can have them all for $2 type deals), read it, and it was one of those life changing books, i felt that these were the same ideas that i had been struggling with as vague, barely graspable concepts elucidated with eloquence and poetry. it was from there that i was introduced to the world of literature and incidently, therefor why i am here now. Its still one of my favorite novels, ive read it again at various points. While it has a special place in my heart, though, Steppenwolf is my favorite of his novels- it won me over with its bizarre, bitter phantasmagoria, and I think the same duality that is perhaps more overtly, even obviously, explored in Narcissus and Goldmund, is in the heart of harry haller, and is brought from the more 'universal', (or was it timeless, however it was that you put it) setting and explored in its relationship with the bourgeois and an individuals place in contemporary society ( the contemporary society of then, which i would say is closer to where i am than medieval monastary.) i would suggest reading both.

Similar Threads

  1. Hermann Hesse
    By vladoman in forum Book & Author Requests
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 06-03-2006, 09:45 AM
  2. siddhartha, Hesse.
    By Nachiketa (Pen name) in forum Siddhartha
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 05-24-2005, 06:07 PM
  3. glass bead game by hermann hesse
    By Monica in forum Book & Author Requests
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 06-27-2004, 02:39 PM
  4. Glass Bead Game by Hesse
    By fionnmaccuhal in forum Book & Author Requests
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 01-15-2004, 12:07 PM
  5. Nietzsche, Dante, or at least more Hesse
    By Anonymouse in forum Book & Author Requests
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 03-20-2003, 01:57 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •