Thank you all who entered. This was a tough one and there were some that were really close but here are the results:
Pendragon: I really loved the first couple of lines, and though they captured a beautiful image. And kudos for teaching me a new word. I had to look up what a combine was. I thought in these few lines you created a perfect portrait of life on the farm.
YesNo: I loved the line "Some plants bring gifts without a sound." I also really liked the sentiment behind the last line. It captures the idea of the cycle of nature, and the bounty which the earth gives. It speaks of the old traditions in which it was believed the animals and plants gave themselves as a gift to man knowing his need to eat.
blanklverse: I really liked your creative approach to the subject and how you took it in a very different and original direction.. The first line did grab my attention right away and made me want to read more but because I am not familiar with the record which is being referred to in the poem I feel like I do not quite grasp the full meaning of it.
MystyrMystyry: I loved your take on the subject. You can rarely go wrong with the Grim Reaper for me, he is a favorite of mine. I enjoyed the darker imagery, and the very October/Halloween feeling of your poem.
DieterM: Loved your opening lines and thought you created a nice image with your poem. You created a since of nostalgic with mention of the swing under the tree. But I think that you used one too many and's and the repetition of the word at the start of each line broke up some of the natural flow of the poem.
cacian: I thought your poem had some beautiful imagery and I loved your use of language. There were some wonderful lines here and originality. I really enjoyed the atmosphere which your poem created but I think it would have benefited from the use of some more punctuation. I did find it could be a bit difficult to read.
And the winner goes to.......
moonbird: You created some wonderful imagery and your words had such an elegant flow to them. I also really enjoy the way in which your poem really invokes the sense. Each verse was beautifully written and I particularly loved the compassion of the moon to an eye, and describing the eating of the apples as being like music. T



Reply With Quote


