Originally Posted by crisaor
One book per month remains, but the nominations for the next months are new, that is a change, wether it is a "rule" or not, and that's my main concern. As you say, the threads are still there, they don't go away, but you'll agree with me, that after 2 or 3 pages of discussion (assuming this is the case), people won't be much interested in that topic anymore. And even if there is no discussion, when there are nominations open for the next months, people tend to dedicate more interest to the latter, or to give less attention to the past books. Anyway, I'm not saying 'hey, change all the rules to suit my tastes', I'm just expressing my opinion. I can't help but feel that the book worked much better when everyone had to contribute in order to get it going. Now, it's not an issue. If there are only 2 nominations, it continues as if there's nothing wrong. If new members post a nomination and then vanish, nobody cares. If there are no discussions, nothing happens.