Although I agree with you that he didn't have a choice other than learning Latin at school, in later chapters, he seems to be using it in his daily life while at university. It feels as if he is almost happy to do so (intellctual snobbery?).
Printable View
Although I agree with you that he didn't have a choice other than learning Latin at school, in later chapters, he seems to be using it in his daily life while at university. It feels as if he is almost happy to do so (intellctual snobbery?).
Here is the text from the book:Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
"And if he had judged her harshly? If her life were a simple rosary of hours, her life simple and strange as a bird's life, gay in the morning, restless all day, tired at sundown? Her heart simple and wilful as a bird's heart?"
Although he seems to be distancing himself from religion, he is still trying to see the girl as pure as possible... So maybe he is not as free of religious teachings as he would like to believe?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Perhaps Scher, I mean schollar used to do this perhaps. Like the story of Jude the Obscure.
And for your 5th Q, well we should know first how's religion defined in the story.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Probably, during his formative years most of his upbringing and schooling were religious based, his whole thought process has to be affected by it in some way or another.
I agree with you there Papay, IMO it's a little hard for someone who was brought up in a strict religious tradition, to really "untie" him/her self from religious bonds.
i had a dream last night that i was only like twenty pages from the end and i woke up think that was true, but i haven't even gotten through chapter one... hmmmm
You know, that's totally a sign for you Liz. U must finish it soon, otherwise it'll keep haunting your sleep.
Jester> If you have the time and dedication, do read the Artist... It won't go into my favorites list but I think it is a good reading experience...
i read all this thread and finally found how silly i am. i thought i already read this one and if i read it one more time i could remember the whole story and join the discussion. sorry about my lame excuses. i'm reading it now but can't tell when i can finish it. hard to follow... :(
okay. stay warm.
Feel free to join in the discussions whenever you feel ready as the threads about book discussions are always open.Quote:
Originally Posted by hye young
What do you guys think, how much of this book was Joyce's personnel experience and how much was embellsihment?
I have done some reading about Joyce's life while reading the book, wondering the same thing as you do, Papaya. Looking at these sites
http://www.robotwisdom.com/jaj/#biog
http://www.kirjasto.sci.fi/jjoyce.htm
it seems like the general lines of the story is based on Joyce's own experiences and he did mean it kind of an autobiography.
I have found this quote very interesting, to say the least:
"The only demand I make of my reader," Joyce once told an interviewer, "is that he should devote his whole life to reading my works."
(from the latter site mentioned above)
hm.. finally i finished chapter 1 and i think chapter one is definetly his childhood experience at boarding school. i can say that the speaker is joyce himself describing what he'd felt as a little kid when the jesuit-run school is all world to him. i could feel his confusion among the grown-ups conversation at Christmas dinner table and his embarassment when Father Dolan pandied him. and at last he somehow speaks out his mind when he really went up to rector's room and tell how he broke his glasses and feared for he might get pandied again. i think that moment is his growing up a little bit. well... i have to go on and read next chapter and learn more.
i guess you guys were having holidays while there're no new posts. :)
Ok read few pages from chapter IV before bed last nite. Almost forgot the whole story. Ok, I think the first pages of this chapter described how Sthepen tried so hard to adapt to his "cage" of religious obidience. I call it cage because he found no spiritual satisfcation doing all those rules and he felt so dry inside. I know from the excerpt in the book that Sthepen evetually become a man without any religion, but don't know how and why. So suppose I should read further first.
I seem to be way behind everybody else but I'm glad to report that I have actually got as far as that little passage! You'll remember that the girl he had a crush on and almost ... but not quite kissed on the bus had also come to see the play. Perhaps he was angry at not seeing her there with his family and that's why he rushed off.
I'm not sure if I'm a member of the book club, since I'm reading it out of necessity rather than pleasure. How does one become a member in the first place?
Oh and thanks Schere for replying to my post ... since you were the first and so far only