Originally Posted by
OrphanPip
One-year programs are pretty much the norm now, McGill is one of the last 2-year programs in the country as far as I know. McGill offers you the opportunity to do it in 1 or 2 years, keeping in mind that the 1 year programs are 3 semesters and the 2 just give you an extra semester for concentrating on thesis writing.
Some of the MA programs don't even have research paper options, UoT has gone to an entirely course based MA. I was also put off by UoT's large MA cohort size, and relatively high tuition in comparison to McGill.
From speaking with the graduate coordinator and a member of the admission committee, I've been told there is a lot of interest in doing away with MA theses, because they are increasingly viewed as redundant and less useful than a broader education at the MA level. The trend in the lit departments seems to be towards more rounded students and less specialization.
McGill's research paper option is relatively long at 50-60 pages, and involves a formal defence like a thesis. So, McGill remains slightly more demanding than some of the other MA programs in the country. It also has the benefit of smaller classes and good Graduate Student to faculty ratio. Although, UoT has fantastic faculty and the best library in the country, especially for Can. Lit.
The thesis option still being available at McGill is also an interesting attraction for those who want to really develop a complex argument at the MA level. McGill also offers a lot of support for conference submission and participation by MAs. I've heard McMaster is also very good about supporting their MAs. I chose not to attend McMaster, but the funding I was offered was very generous. Ottawa U also had surprisingly good fellowships and guaranteed TAship for applicants with 3.8/4.0 or higher GPAs. That was initially my fall-back application, but I was tempted by the money they offered me.
Edit: I haven't decided on whether I will do a RP or a full thesis yet, I want to secure a supervisor before I make that final decision.