Incidentally, I'm very interested in the answer to number 4, as that's a pretty accurate summary of what my writing increasingly attempts to achieve.
Printable View
Incidentally, I'm very interested in the answer to number 4, as that's a pretty accurate summary of what my writing increasingly attempts to achieve.
I'm really hoping someone will figure out #3. It helps if you realize the speaker is using the terms "bad review" and "advance" rather ironically.
4. Faulkner?
I'm now resorting to listing the usual suspects, and see if any quote fits.
Herman Melville, possible no. 5
Henry James,
Joseph Heller
james joyce
J D Salinger
John Stienbeck
Stephen King, possible no. 3
7. Ahh, is that Don Quixote? - Cervantes
Nope.
It is indeed Cervantes. Just like I said--the very beginning and the very end of that quote are key. :p
Unfortunately, none of the other names you produced are present on the list. Here's a hint: a few of the names that match up with some of these last unanswered clues have been said already, but they were offered for the wrong quote.
Thanks for the clue, so a bit of reshuffling is in order.
4. Tolstoy.
12 Mark Twain.
My mother (who just knows these things) says Faulkner is number 6.
Seems like #3 could be about Mark Twain. Doubt that is correct though.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1YoOFIPvj40
That's why in retrospect this was a lousy clue to use--it could only be solved by someone "who just knows these things"; it wasn't figure outable.
Number 3 is not Mark Twain.
I'll post hints for the remaining three quotes later tonight if they remain unsolved. I am mildly surprised that our British members are unfamiliar with #5.
Um, no.
The quote comes from a poem written by a Romantic with a fondness for sprinkling references to other poets of his day throughout his poetry. The poet being referenced had largely stopped writing poems at that time and had instead turned to expounding on literary criticism and metaphysical principles, including one particularly dense and lengthy volume that many readers of the time found impenetrable.
Most 'reviews' don't come with advances, do they? So what you have to ask yourself is...who gets the 'advance'? And what is it for (especially in the context of the 'bad review')?Quote:
3. "About eight years or so ago, Valentine's Day, I seem to remember, you received an extremely bad review…and this review, unlike most bad reviews, came accompanied with a very large advance."
I thought raising the possibility that someone other than the author would be receiving the 'advance' expanded on the original clue rather significantly.
There is a series of children's books featuring a kid detective named Encyclopedia Brown and his antagonist, the villainous Bugs Meany. The stories are solvable, with the solution usually hinging on the reader's knowledge of facts such as dolphins are mammals, not fish; or that hard-boiled eggs spin faster than uncooked eggs. I wish I could provide you with a key that would unlock this clue in a similar fashion, but sadly I can't think of one.
'Find the Tyrant King' is the central clue in a book I read as a kid, in which the young sleuths had to go to all sorts of London landmarks to solve the mystery. The Tyrant King turned out to be the fossil Tyrannosaurus Rex in the Natural History Museum.
I loved that book, and I seem to remember buying a Red Rover one-day pass to go by bus to a lot of the places they'd gone to. I don't know what prompted me to do that. I remember that London Transport had some sponsorship thing going on with the book, and it was suggested in the story that the young sleuths managed to visit all these places around London because they had a Red Rover one-day pass to go by...
...HANG ON A MINUTE!
4. Dostoevsky??
Wild guess on #5 John Donne.
By clutching-at-straws-process-of-elimination methodology (ie. we've got Shelly and Keats,) and Byron was a sardonic sod, so Byron for number 5
I mean the Quote was Byronic, about Wordsworth?
#3 has a whiff of Dorothy Parker talking to some dude, maybe.
Just when I was about to hammer the final nail in this coffin, the corpse has suddenly shifted to the right. What else to do but continue beating him until we know for sure that he's dead?
That is correct; Mick also correctly judged the quote to be Byronic.
So that just leaves us this quote, from a 1997 interview, between two Brits:
Quote:
"About eight years or so ago, Valentine's Day, I seem to remember, you received an extremely bad review…and this review, unlike most bad reviews, came accompanied with a very large advance."
As the renowned carpet bomber of this thead, (as opposed to jajdude the sniper) I shall have yet another wild guess
JK Rowling.
Martin Amis? (Sometime around The Information?)
Philip Roth? -his ex wife Claire Bloom gave him the bad review.
^ sorry not British.
Sir Alan Ackbourne? He became a Knight Batchelor on 11 feb 1997
Oh 'eck, wrong date we're looking for a literary figure who was knighted on 14th Feb 1989, are we?
Ahh unless the bad review was a fatwah against Salman Rushdie.
I'm carpet bombing again
By dint of lots of guessing I got the most right - I also got the most wrong but never mind .
Here's something we haven't tried before.
Imagine a room with ten people in it. Most are sat in, or on the arms of, comfy chairs and sofas that have been arranged in a half circle around the fire place. The focus of their attention is a young woman stood in front of the fireplace. She is gesticulating wildly, and all the others are shouting at her.
First, she holds her hands out in front of her, thumbs uppermost and palms together, she turns them outwards.
2. She holds up 5 fingers.
3. She holds up 1 finger.
4. She holds up one hand vertically and the other horizontally across the top of it.
5. She holds up 2 fingers
6. She cups one hand to her ear and gesticulates with the other, making the shape of little waves heading towards her ear.
7. She holds up 3 fingers.
8. She tugs the lobe of her ear
9. She points to her hand
10. She holds up 4 fingers.
11. She holds up one hand vertically and the other horizontally across the top of it again.
12. She holds up 5 fingers
13. She stamps about on the carpet, she shakes her fists aggressively, she draws back her lips to show her teeth are clenched, her brow is furrowed.
She repeats actions number 6 and 13 over and over, finally she points to one of the others and nods.
Then everyone applauds and she sits down. The person she pointed at takes her place.
So, what's going on and what's the answer?
One hand vertically and the other horizontally across the top of it... like this?:
http://us.123rf.com/400wm/400/400/ge...le-making-.jpg