Yes, I think we'd all like to see a winner for this round so we can get to writing some more poems. Don't worry about responding to everyone, Tal. Just relieve us all from the suspense. :D
Printable View
Yes, I think we'd all like to see a winner for this round so we can get to writing some more poems. Don't worry about responding to everyone, Tal. Just relieve us all from the suspense. :D
I think there should be a time span or limit - maybe a month for each poetry contest. Two months is too long...some people may lose interest in the thread and depart forever.
It hasn't been two months, not even a month yet. He posted his picture on the 22knd. and Virg, if I'm not mistaken YOU are repeatedly asking for more time to write them, what's the big deal if he takes a few days to judge them?
Let's just wait for Tal for as long as it takes before we brainstorm big changes like this. Everyone goes through busy times.
Well, as I said, the picture left so many interpretations. Give Tal a break, it must be hard to chose. I agree there should be a time limit. However, if we say poems must be in by a certain date, then there should be no extension of writing time if one is not willing to wait on judging time. It would only be fair. Then the one judging would have "x" amount of time to review and judge. The day for the posting of the winner would be known to all from the start. Sound reasonable? :)
Sorry, I was thinking also from what others said it was two months. If it was just over one - understandable with the holidays and all and eveyone tired and sluggish afterwards. I agree with Pen, maybe some kind of loose structure would be good....some time limit and some guide lines.
Sounds good! Of course, like the contestants, I think under reasonable circumstances the judge should be able to request an extension for maybe a few days? But we can limit extensions too?
btw...where is tal? :lol:
It would certainly have to be guidelines everyone is involved in drafting, or someone is going to get their feelings hurt. So we should perhaps all be thinking about this, how much time limit is reasonable for writing of poems, how much extention is reasonable, how much time limit is reasonable for judging (always taking into mind the number of poems submitted!) and how much extention is reasonable before making a decision. But it must be a team effort, not crafted by any one of us. Virgil makes a good chairman, if no one (besides himself!), objects, we could pass the info on to him, or run a poll. What say you? :)
Let me say that when I've been a judge, it has taken me about two hours to read the poems and come to a decision. It's usually just a question of finding two straight hours available. And then perhaps a third hour to write up something which offers comments. I don't really understand what takes so long.
I think that this round is just the rare exception. Every contest before this one I felt was done in a timely manner.
We are sorry for being so late judging the poems. :blush: But anyway, here goes.
A good, eerie poem.Quote:
Originally Posted by Triskele
We especially liked these stanzas:
Quote:
Who dares the shrapnel of the heart?
What thought drives men to love
Darkened spires of desire, tipped with poison
***Quote:
As thoughts travel onward… past… present
Life’s love of action drives men to fly
Pushes women to deaths edge
So all can say they have gone
We like the short, rhyming stanzas. The rhythm of the poem feels punctured, almost broken. And these lines were fantastic:Quote:
Originally Posted by mir
Quote:
What meaning
Are worlds given
When each tenant
Never sees them
Trapped inside
Their own dimension
With wireless
To disease them?
If the sun,
The moon, the stars,
Should quietly
Implode
Wishing only
To be noticed
For their work -
A heavy load! -
No cell phone
Would ring a query,
No email
***
Interesting interpretation, Pensy. And you know, somehow, when we first read the poem, we missed the rhyme sceme and read it “Reality” and thought why you should censure it, but then we understood.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pensive
And
:thumbs_upQuote:
He can't guess what's happening around
Whoever is playing with him, he can't merely think
From a human being, he is made a machine
Who can't sing, who in front of his controllers, can't even blink
***
We liked the general tone of the poem, uncle Pen. It’s atmosphere is different from the others – lighter, more happier. The more classical form of the poem also stresses the point, in our opinion.Quote:
Originally Posted by Pendragon
***
We liked the last stanza, and that the form of the poem was a cell phone call. Starting it with “Doooooooooooooooo, dooooooooooooo” made us smile.Quote:
Originally Posted by Orionsbelt
And we miss sun too.
***
Wow! This poem has a nightmarish, dark tone that we enjoyed very much. Especially these lines:Quote:
Originally Posted by Petrarch's love
Quote:
The roots of heaven descend in a balled up mass,
And below in the dingy light
The message is lost in a bad connection,
and the last lines really have impact:Quote:
Some end in the sign of the cross
Some finish in an offering of smog incense
***Quote:
How can they hope for grace when this
Is the earth the roots of heaven grow in?
We found these lines especially amusing:Quote:
Originally Posted by Arania
Quote:
Miss Earth? Who is she?
Quote:
The real world? Who's he?
We like the a bit archaic style (‘twas, ‘tis) but we think that your poem was inspired by some other picture - you mentioned in your comment that somehow you saw two of them.Quote:
Originally Posted by Matsiah
But a good poem anyhow, serene and full of greenery.
***
A very good poem.Quote:
Originally Posted by dramasnot6
We like the rhyming and the touches of irony:
Quote:
Hello, it’s me, I’m calling
Sorry, but I’m terrible with names
Just thought I’d be remembered
An exception in midnight games
Quote:
Oh, I’m terribly sorry
Will your mother be okay?
You used my favorite story
Lies are great fillers of the day
And the last line stands out because it is out of stanzas and therefore one notices it better and it has more effect to end the poem.Quote:
Do tell me when we meet again
Preferably when you are coldest to touch
Don’t bother with a note this time
Easier when there is emptiness to clutch
***
We like the freeform lines, it gives the whole poem an interesting rhytm.Quote:
Originally Posted by Riesa
And these lines we especially liked.
Quote:
obscuring
day’s shimmering
nucleus
in an obsidian nest
a million mill-stoned
voices rise
above the bones of a church
to the hovering
technical God engorged to
starry magnitude
by the city’s
electric impulses
The decision was difficult but the honour of posting the next picture belongs to Petrarch's love.