Quote:
Originally Posted by
JBI
On the topic of belief in sin, anyone who doesn't believe in god doesn't really believe in sin, as, according to my OED, sin is defined as:
An act which is regarded as a transgression of the divine law and an offence against God; a violation (esp. wilful or deliberate) of some religious or moral principle.
With variants for figurative use of course accepted, such as "to live in sin" meaning something quite different, though having the same root.
In the sense, sin perhaps doesn't exist, and it becomes a question of ones own personal beliefs.
I believe in neither god or sin so I suppose that would exclude me.
Quote:
I agree with you that no particular mode of thinking is going to directly and actively change anything.
Nods.
Quote:
Sitting about being an idealist can be just as unproductive as sitting about being a nihilist.
Definately.
Quote:
Being so optimistic that you're in a state of denial and figure everything's going to take care of itself isn't any more helpful than being so much of a pessimist that you figure everythings going to self destruct.
Spot on.
Quote:
Thinking can, however, act as a prompt to action, and contribute to our decisions about how to act.
Even then however there is the futility of determinism where things are determined in a way where even thinking becomes useless.
Quote:
A person's mindset makes a great deal of difference in terms of how he or she reacts to circumstances, what actions he or she takes to help alleviate the wrongs and injustices that exist to whatever extent a single, flawed individual is able to.
I believe that the universe exists around aimless relativity and indifference so in my view it doesn't really matter what mindset you have.
Quote:
I don't know what you want to call it, but your posts certainly seem to indicate that you believe in something like sin. Your judgments of others because of their complicity in the injustice of the social/economic system, because of their failures to fully address or redress certain realities, certainly comes across like someone who is condemning the sins of others.
On the contrary. I don't believe in sins,morals, ethics or golden rules of any kind.
I merely get upset at watching the hypocrisy of others in their constant denial of reality. I merely get upset that there is a majority of people who refuse to acknowledge real events and motions that surround them.
It has nothing to do with a moral judgement on my part in that I don't believe in such things.
It has more to do with a judgement of preference in that I judge others through my own subjective perspectives.
( Perspectives that are void of moral sentiments and golden rules.)
Quote:
You can call it sin, wrong doing/thinking, succumbing to beastial instincts...whatever.
On the contrary again. I embrace primitive instinct.
I merely criticize others who are in denial of what they themselves are.
I merely criticize those who are hypocrites in denial who deny that they themselves have any part in the inequality, chaos, and suffering of their world on a daily basis. Am I making any sense to you?
Quote:
You certainly are pointing to flaws in human behavior, and I was simply agreeing with you that such flaws are present in all of us.
That's just it. I don't see them as flaws. I see them as natural tendencies.
I merely criticize those who like to pretend that they are different somehow from such tendencies.
Quote:
I was not sufficiently clear in my former post, and perhaps took too much for granted. When I spoke of an illusory ideal I was referring specifically to the concept of the entire world in perfect peace which is certainly, at the very least, a reality so far removed from the world as it has always been as to exist only as an ideal. However, I did not mean to, and never will, suggest that peace itself is impossible, or that it is any way illusory.
I support the notion that peace is impossible.
If you believe that peace is possible please indulge me by telling me how.
Quote:
Little fragments and oases of peace are just as great a reality as suffering is.
Peace is fragmented? Explain.
Quote:
The better instincts of the human spirit are just as real as the grasping, selfish instincts are.
What is better?
Quote:
Your concept of peace outlined briefly above is that it only exists as a sort of imaginary security blanket, something I strongly disagree with.
Indeed I do believe it to be a delusional security blanket to calm the emotions.
Quote:
In my previous post I spoke of the importance of having an ideal belief in the comfort of a larger world peace, not because it is a nice convenient way to forget that bad things happen and to slip into a happy denial, but because the striving toward that ideal helps people to connect to the very real peace that does exist in this world.
What is this very real peace you are talking about?
To me it is a impossibility the word peace and there is simply no reason to strive for somthing that is out of reach.
Quote:
There's an old saying that I like, which goes something like this: "Peace does not mean to be in a place where there is noise, trouble, strife or hard work; it means to be in the midst of all these things and still be calm in your heart."
So it's a subjective expirience then?
Quote:
The extremes of either denial or despair are equally easy ways out of dealing with the struggles of the world, and ultimately equally likely to make it difficult for a person to confront hardship. Either way is also simply saying that you don't care.
What's wrong with not caring?
Also just because one doesn't care doesn't mean that they confront hardship any less effective than another.
Quote:
It can be just as difficult, in some ways more difficult, to recognize the reality of peace in the world as it can be to recognize the reality of violence and suffering.
Are you saying peace exists objectively?
Quote:
Fine, acknowledge those realities of violence and suffering, but also acknowledge those realities of peace, enjoyment, and contentment.
I can only acknowledge things that happen amongst myself.
Things out of the realm of my own control I cannot acknowledge that well in that they are outside of myself.
Quote:
The fact that you don't let your life become spoiled by the darker realities indicates that in some small way you are aware that better realities exist as well.
In some regards. Of course what I look to be better realities I'm sure is much different from how others perceive it amongst themselves.