Printable View
Yes, she was in the place where the music was being played live.Quote:
Originally Posted by papayahed
Therefore no, the music was not a recording.
No, she was not playing the music.
No, she was not shot, nor was she stabbed.
No, the music did not stop at a natural place.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scher
But no, neither did it stop because of a fault.
and Jay - hehe! - no, it wasn't joke music. It was really musical music.
Did an natural disaster occur to stop the music?
Lets mark the stopping of the music with A and her Death with B.
Now, was there any C that caused both A and B, or did A just cause B, or did B cause A?
.....was the music the rhythmic beat of her ventilator which someone unplugged.......???
*frustrated. 'Feels' the answer, but can't see it*
No.Quote:
Originally Posted by papayahed
Taliesin, you crack me up. I've never met anyone so left brained! :p But to answer your question as simply as I can: A caused B. The fact that the music stopped caused her death. There was no single cause behind both. Her death did not make the music stop. How's that?Quote:
Originally Posted by Taliesin
No. The music really was music, not metaphoric or symbolic music.Quote:
Originally Posted by baddad
Don't feel frustrated, baddad. :) This isn't a riddle - the answer is not the least bit obvious. When we reach the conclusion, no one will be able to look back and say "d'oh! should've seen that coming!" Rather, it is a story that you are unraveling backwards.
When the music stop, was it a signal for C to come out and gag her? (Thus technically A cause B's death.)
Summing up again:
In General
She is a person.
She was not a voice on a radio, tv, ect.
It doesn't matter how tall she is.
Her Death
She was murdered.
She was murdered on purpose.
She was not shot, nor was she stabbed.
She was not alone when she died.*
She did not know she was going to die.
She died because the music stopped.
The end of the music was not a signal for someone to come gag her.
The Music
She could hear the music when it was playing.
She was not playing the music.
She was in the place where the music was being played live.*
A natural disaster did not stop the music.
The music was, in fact, music in a literal sense.
*These facts are important and worth pursuing in greater detail! (So are some others, but first things first... ;))
When the music stopped she died.
Were there more than 3 people with her?
Was she related to any of the music players?
Was she eating something before she died?
(All of a sudden I'm hogging the questioning.)
Did someone intentionally stop the music so that she died at that particular moment?
Was she aware that if the music stopped, she would die?
Was she playing the music/singing?
Was she murdered by one person or more?
Did the band members know she was going to die when they stopped playing the music?
Did a band member kill her?
Was she at a concert? indoors? outdoors?
Was her death planned?
Is she the only one that died?
Hog away, ajoe! :)
Yes, there were more than three people.Quote:
Originally Posted by ajoe
No, she was not related to any of the musicians.
No, she was not eating anything before she died. (Y'know... nothing relevant. :p She might have had a bologna sandwhich for lunch, but it has no bearing on the story. ;))
Yes! Someone intentionally stopped the music so she'd die at that moment.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scher
No, she wasn't aware she would die when the music stopped.
No, she was not making the music herself.
Err... your last question isn't quite yes/no. Yes, she was murdered. :p
Your first question is very good and very tricky to answer. The answer could be yes but is probably no. You might have to come back to this later...Quote:
Originally Posted by papayahed
Your second question is even better, but also very tricky! Teeeeechnically, no... but that depends on how you define "band member." :D
She was not at a concert.
She was indoors.
She was not (therefore) outdoors.
Yes, her death was planned.
Yes, she is the only one who died.
Woo! Good questions!
Is the type of music played relevant?
Was she murdered by one person?
Was she murdered by a group of people?
Was the person who stopped the music making the music?
Is there a 'murder weapon'?
Was she stabbed?
Was her death result of an injury?
Did she bleed?
Mmm. Yes and no. Yes, because finding that out will further your understanding of the story, but No, because no matter what type of music they were playing, she still would have died when it stopped. How's that for an answer? :)Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Yes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Ummm... No.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Oh dear. See my answer to Papaya above about how you define "band member."Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
No.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
No.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Heh heh. You could say that, yes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Eeeyuck. I imagine so.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Did she have a fall?
Were there any instruments played to make the music?
Was an instrument used to murder her?
was there a choir? Like a church choir?
Is her age relevant?
OH yes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Yes.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Not unless you count the fact that it was making music and she died because of the music.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
No.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Nope.Quote:
Originally Posted by Scheherazade
Gah. Bed time bed time!