You certainly have a point; there does need to be a standard. However, I think many people (myself included) are just tired of people making posts in a thread for the sole purpose of correcting grammar.Quote:
We need more linguistic policemen (not in terms of censorship, of course; don't misinterpret me) like him to uphold certain standards and prevent students from unwittingly perpetuating mistakes or falling into "anything goes" mindset
It's kind of like when you're telling someone a story, and you say "the other day me and my friend" and they suddenly interrupt and say "my friend and I". It's just sort of rude, especially if they correct little mistakes like that all of the time (people majoring in english tend to do this, and it's bloody annoying).
The internet, particularly message boardlike these, tend to gather a lot of intellectuals, and many of these intellectuals seem to love showing off, oftentimes making posts posts in threads that they don't care about just to correct someone's grammar. If tabac had corrected the grammar and then actually provided his/her thoughts on the subject, it would have been fine (in my opinion, anyway). But when you see people posting under threads just to correct a grammatical error all of the time, it's kind of annoying. It just gives off that whole image of a snide pseudo-intellectual who tries to look smart and witty by bringing others down.
To use your police metaphor... There's a difference between an honest policeman trying to do his duty, and the policemen who use their power as a means of compensation ;)
