Originally Posted by
Janine
manolia, I just saw this film, but not in the theater. Still it looked terrific on my new HD TV, even though I don't have the newer DVD player connected yet. The special effects were well done and most times not overdone. I really loved that tree and the reflection. The film had some very interesting and artistic imagery. I will have to see it again, when I do have the new player connected, which should be soon. I also, had such mixed feelings about it, but I think it is the type of film, in which one has to sit back and just go with, almost subliminally. I heard a reviewer compare it to the film "2001: A Space Odyssey"...I thought that an interesting comparison.
I liked some of this film better than other parts. I liked the 'present' and I liked the 'future', but I was not sure at all about some sections of the 'past'...some of that seemed a little too 'way out' to me or corny, the way it was presented. This is so curious, manolia; I had just completed the novel by D.H.L. -"The Plumed Serpent" when I viewed this film, and some of that history and myth in the 'past' segments reminded me of the same elements in "TPS". I wondered if the screen writer happened to read the L book.
One thing I did find totally odd, and annoying about this film, was the fact that this man's wife is dying and he never has any time to spend with her. I guess that speaks for men, right? The way they all get caught up in something, usually a hobby or work and obsess; well hey, in all fairness, I guess, we woman can do that, also, at times. Granted he wanted to cure her, but still I would have thought, he would cherish his possible 'limited' time with his beloved wife. This part of trying to save her with this limited short timespan, seemed to me to be a bit unrealistic, as well. It takes years to test me drugs and research, etc. to see if they are truly safe or effective long term. These might be the reasons, I could not give it a 10/10, in my opinion, although I do think it was a very 'bold' film, as vheissu stated above, and I think very worthy of viewing; probably one of the best in the last year.