Aye or Nay?

Aye

Carrots with peas ?

Aye.

Chicken pie?

Aye

Have you ever locked yourself out of your home ?

Several times. I used to live in an apartment that could be opened only with a key on the outside, so you can imagine.

Ever fell from a ladder?

Nay... close though

Ever trip on a sidewalk curb ?

sidewalk curbs, cracks in the sidewalk, tree roots...you name it aye!

an oldie but a goodie:

pineapple on pizza?

Nay

Salt on watermelon ?

Náaaay!
Californian pizza( canned pineapples, peaches and figs, fresh cherries and mozzarella).
Easy choice: Paul Newman.