"Dystopia?"

I've seen this word, dystopia, apparently used to mean the opposite of utopia. I'm confused and troubled by this usage, which I believe is due to a misunderstanding of the etymology of utopia.

The etymology is Greek. topos refers to "a place." The problem is the meaning of the modifier, "u-" or "ou-". This modifier should mean "no." as in no place or nowhere ("erehwon" in backwards English). I think the folk who use dystopia confuse the "ou" with "eu" (meaning "good). The opposite of "good" is "bad," which is where we get the "dys-" prefix.

So you say utopia means no place when directly translated. Seems spot on to me.

I can't say I've looked into the etymology before, but the modern definition of "dystopia" given by Merriam-webster is "An imaginary place where people lead dehumanized and often fearful lives."

Utopia :"a place for ideal perfection, especially in laws, government and social conditions."

So by modern English, they are arguably opposites.

And the definition quoted by Shaman above is actually the second one M-W gives; the first is "an imaginary and indefinitely remote place," which fits the etymology perfectly.

I'd also point out that words in one language can be derived from another, but that doesn't mean the definition in the new language will exactly match the pieces in the original language. Derivation isn't cloning.

Which leads to dystopia. According to M-W, the "dys" prefix itself can mean abnormal, difficult, impaired, or bad. Again, the word fits the roots. Effectively, the words have come to mean opposite things, but just because the roots themselves aren't direct opposites, that doesn't mean that there was an error in the creation of the word(s). Again, not cloning, just inspiration, if you like.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Calidore

...According to M-W, the "dys" prefix itself can mean abnormal, difficult, impaired, or bad. Again, the word fits the roots. Effectively, the words have come to mean opposite things, but just because the roots themselves aren't direct opposites, that doesn't mean that there was an error in the creation of the word(s). Again, not cloning, just inspiration, if you like.

---

I was just being pedantic (I hope in a good way) by calling attention to this commonly used word, "dystopia" to mean "a bad/dysfunctional place," and the opposite of "utopia." There is no question that "utopia" was coined to mean "no place," i.e. an imaginary place that does not exist. As it happens, this was also some sort of blissful "good place." However if that were the primary meaning, the place would have been called (in English) "eutopia," but it wasn't... If that were what it was called, then the opposite would indeed be "dystopia."

So my point is that "dystopia" (which has become a popular term for any dysfunctional society) is indeed a term based on what could be called "false etymology," or at least based on ignorance of the etymology of "utopia." It seems "dystopia" is here to stay in common English usage. It is what it is. It is neither good or bad usage. I just wanted to call attention to it.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nick Capozzoli

I've seen this word, dystopia, apparently used to mean the opposite of utopia. I'm confused and troubled by this usage, which I believe is due to a misunderstanding of the etymology of utopia.

The etymology is Greek. topos refers to "a place." The problem is the meaning of the modifier, "u-" or "ou-". This modifier should mean "no." as in no place or nowhere ("erehwon" in backwards English). I think the folk who use dystopia confuse the "ou" with "eu" (meaning "good). The opposite of "good" is "bad," which is where we get the "dys-" prefix.

---

The etymology of "utopia" is what you found; it means "no place". "Dystopia" is a horrible word that is meant as the opposite of the kind of place that the book Utopia by Thomas described.

"Dystopia" is a not quite suitable antonym for Utopia. It was devised by J. S. Mill to mean bad imaginary place, anmd the Greek is appropriate. I don't like the word, because it is used to mean something other than "bad place,"

Isn't dystopia really another form of utopia then, except a dysfunctional one?