Discussing Important Aspects of Chapters 12-16
We see on page 238 Margaret Kochamma's haunting decision to go to India with Sophie Mol. "Margaret Kochamma never forgave herself for taking Sophie Mol to Ayemenem" (Roy 238). We also see how she deals with her grief. She takes it out on the twins because they were the last ones to see Sophie Mol alive, and had she not been with them she would have lived. She takes great violence out on Estha especially previously in the he book, now we know why. But she does apologize in a letter that Rahel receives.
I noticed all the water references that led up to the moment when we learn how exactly Sophie Mol has died of drowning. "Baby Kochamma and Mammachi thought that they might have gone for a swim, which was worrying because it had rained heavily the previous day and a good part of the night. They knew that the river could be dangerous" (Roy 239). This passage shows how even though Baby Kochamma and Mammachi are worried about the kids they are not necessarily a priority. They are too caught up in punishing Ammu for her the terrible "thing" she did with Velutha to actually put two and two together that the kids might be in the river and might have been gone all night.
"Then the Terror took hold of him and shook the words out of him" (Roy 242). This passage is where Velutha's dad goes to tell Mammachi before someone else does about their children's unlawful midnight rendezvous. Then Baby Kochamma has to go and blot the whole story out of proportion to save the family’s good name.
The time sequence in these chapters fit. I was neat how Roy gave just enough information to leave us hanging from one chapter to the next until she goes back to give the rest of the story. We find out that the twins are running away because they are not wanted anymore by Ammu. This goes back to what we were discussing about how a mother's words, to a child especially, go straight to their hearts. We saw how Ammu's words damaged Rahel, and how she now believes her mother loves her a little less. Now we see that she takes her situation out on them, and they feel so unwanted that they run away and take their cousin with them. When the boat tips how are the twins to know that Sophie Mol couldn't swim? They are not old enough to realize the effect that the death will have on the family, and they honestly think that they will have to go to jail. The poor kids, their family has pushed them away. Then they go up to the History House to "make camp" not knowing that Velutha is under their nose. This is the build up we have been waiting for. We know something big and life changing is going to happen in the History House.
Question is this "The Terror" finally?
Estha and Rahel's connection
I wonder if their connection is actually broken because of the Terror. I know they are physically separated, but does the Terror separate them on a deeper level too? I think the connection is still there, but it manifests itself as Estha's quietness and Rahel's emptiness. They are like parts of a whole so they are not complete unless they are together. Rahel is not comfortable with writing to Estha because "There are things you can't do--like writing letters to a part of yourself. To your feet or hair. Or heart" (156). Also, Rahel experiences eating the tomato sandwiches with Estha on the bus, which happens after the Terror.
BUT! If this postulation is correct, and the connection is never broken, then why do Estha Alone and Rahel Alone exist? And why does Rahel say that "Their lives have a size and a shape now. Estha has his and Rahel hers. Edges, Borders, Boundaries, Brinks and Limits have appeared like a team of trolls on their separate horizons" (5)? Is the connection broken and reformed or is it constant? Is it broken because of distance or because of the Terror?
A Neo93 Shaped Hole In The Universe
(taking a test all day tommorow)
Anyway, is it just me or is Arundhati Roy just plain amazing? I'm goin to go out on a limb here and say that God of Small Things is easily the best book I've ever read in an English class, and possibly one of my favorite overall reads.
First of all, I agree with Eilonwy18 about Estha and Rahel's connection. I really think that the Cochin Harbor terminus scene is the turning point in this connection. Thier seperation profoundly affects thier connection, but it doesn't destroy it. In a way, they are two different entities and one at the same time. This is why Estha Alone and Rahel Alone exist. Roy is trying to show that sometimes, no matter how strong a connection we share with people, there are some things we simply can't share with anyone else. Although everyone's story affects everyone else, no one has the exact same perspective as anyone else. Because of this, there were things that Estha experienced and couldn't share with Rahel, and vice versa. Despite this, thier connection remains intact when they are 31. They just realize that they are 2different people and one person at the same time.
The train station scene just about killed me when I read it, because Ammu, Estha, and Rahel are all so innocent. All they are trying to do is break the terrible cycle the family is caught in, an what do they get? sorrow. Also, this scene pretty much caps Estha's learning of how dangerous words can be. His internal analysis of how his comments to Ammu about how she would never come for him was his final realization that speaking has too many dangerous consequences--"It was his fault that the faraway man in Ammu's chest stopped shouting...Because he was the one who said it." (Roy 308).
"He left his voice behind" (Roy 309).
One last comment on the final chapter. I really liked how it seemed to tie up loose ends for the entire family, while focusing exclusively on Velutha and Ammu. This just goes to show how thier story affected the story of the entire cast of characters. Everyone from Baby Kochamma to Comrade Pillai to Thomas Mathews was affected. There is no way to seperate any of thier stories. all of the seemingly loosely connected characters become so linked by thier converging stories that they can't deny how Ammu and Velutha affected them.
"Never again will a single story be told as though it's the only one."
--John Berger