View RSS Feed

Imported Poems

Unanswered Questions

Rate this Entry
Okay, here it goes.

1. I have noticed a trend in responses to my writing that disturbs me. When I post my work - either here or one of the sites I actually sort of detest - few people reply, and if they reply, their comments are "nice work" or something along those lines. However, when I read other people's work, the comments are usually more specific: ie: "You mean effect, not affect in paragraph 3". "In paragraph one you say John Smith is 40, but in paragraph twenty you have him in college."
The only suggestion I have received (it seems to be a recurring theme, even in life when I am accused of "using big words" when I speak) is "Your vocabulary is too large". So, I am wondering if my vocabulary is "so large" that no one can understand what I am saying, and I am also wondering if it is really necessary to reduce my vocabulary to be published. Wilde, Fitzgerald and Lovecraft all have lovely vocabularies and they are in print.

2. I am having a difficult time finding publishers that are ready to publish. So far every reply I've received has said "we aren't publishing novels at this time", which is better than "we aren't publishing YOUR novel at this time". It's a universal rejection rather than an individual one, which I can handle. However, a recent publisher (one I sent a sample chapter and the Jules interview to) indicated - while the company isn't currently accepting novels - I should enter the two contests they host per year. I'm wondering if this invitation is a universal invitation to all submissions, or if the editor read my work and actually thinks I stand a chance of winning.

3. I am still in a great deal of angst over my severed relationship. I would go into extensive detail about it, except I made a vow of silence, and besides, if I got the whole thing out it would only take one individual before the entire situation would make every gossip column in America, and being a private person that would absolutely humiliate me. Plus, I would sound completely insane if disbelieved, so there are so many good reasons to keep my mouth shut about specifics.
However, let us go into an analgous relationship, okay? We are traveling back in time to the 1800s, before the internet, before people could hop on planes or travel in cars to arrive at their destination within hours. A woman has a friend with a cousin overseas. Lets call the friend Maury and the cousin Anthony (in keeping with Fitzgerald's "The Beautiful and The Damned").
Now, the woman has seen a picture of Anthony, and being a romantic and subject to beauty's overwhelming argument, has fallen in love with the sight of him. So, she writes him. Now, she (let us call her "Gloria", in keeping with Fitzgerald) is not so callow that she loves beauty to the exclusion of all other things, so over time, she falls in love with his soul.
He is - to her at least - not just a vision of beauty, but beauty incarnate: a spirit spoiled by its precious possession, a wild steed born with a natural gentleness but subject to destructive impulses, a soul aching for self-mastery and heaven but unsure of itself. She adores watching him - beauty is best when it is innocent, entirely free from the constraints of man.
Now, our heroine, being a gentle spirit herself and wishing beauty to mature as it should - does not desire to master our young Anthony, for to do so would unnaturally alter his handsome expression, and dull his gorgeous self-display. So, rather than bridle him and break him, she befriends this loveliness, and shows him - through example and a great deal of love and encouragement - goodness and virtue.
Well, our young Anthony matures into a wonderful creature. And then one day, her letters go unanswered, and then the next month, they are returned as undeliverable. She knows in her conversations with Maury - at least to the point where her letters are returned - that Anthony has read them. She knows because Maury brings up topics contained in them in conversing with her (though he is unaware of it).
Our Gloria is not just heartbroken, she is mute. Her world - once colorful with the loving expressions of him - is grey and silent. She can no longer converse, not because she has nothing to converse upon (she is a deep soul) but because the very act of conversing itself was an inspiration from Anthony. She inquires after Anthony (to Maury) to discover if he hasn't met someone and she is told he is still alone and happy with his pets.
As she watches beauty incarnate disappear into the forest, she wonders if she hasn't hurt him in some way, and chastizes and torments herself at the thought that some insensitivity on her part might have led to his shyness.
She speaks to Maury, and is told Anthony will not talk about the subject.
She resolves to try and get over Anthony, but she can't because she loves him so much, and because every time she visits Maury, she is forced to look at Anthony's picture on the wall. In fact, Anthony is universally loved, and their mutual friends also have Anthony's picture hanging on the wall. Gloria decides not to visit Maury and their friends, but she can't help herself. Time and time again she is drawn back to that house, to gaze upon the picture, because in the end, the picture itself is all she has left of him, a ghost of unattained bliss, of a bittersweet happiness she knew for a short time.

And that, my friends, is where our story ends.

Question: Why did Anthony leave Gloria?
Categories

Comments

  1. andave_ya's Avatar
    ok. In response to point number one, I don't look for that sort of thing because honestly, the idea makes me cringe. When I read, I usually read for pleasure, enjoyment, and edification. I don't proofread unless specifically asked to. If you want me to try it, I'd be happy to, but I didn't know that's what you expected. Re the large vocabulary, were i in your shoes I wouldn't care less. The people who don't like my language don't have to read my book, and it's their loss, not mine. But then again, I've never been in the position to worry about that, so I really don't know what to say. In general, the story is your story, and you are free to accept or ignore advice given. So basically, follow your heart and hang people's ideas. Writing is first and foremost for the author.

    I don't know anything about point two, so that's all I'll say on this point.

    Point three. I've never been in a romantic attatchment so I don't know what it's like. But I will say this. Keep going! It may not be over but do not let it keep you down. If I read the story aright, he didn't say anything. Unless you know incontrovertibly that any chance of a renewed relationship is over, don't lose hope, my friend.

    I've been praying for you Countess, and hope you're doing better. I'm here if you want to talk. Andave.
  2. Sindhu's Avatar
    I totally agree with your idea of specific criticism. That is what is referred to as constructive criticism and even though you may cringe for a bit initially, in the end it helps; while comments like nice work etc, serve no real purpose whatsoever. The only precondition should be that the critic's attitude should be a desire to help, not a malicious wish to demoralise.

    As for the big words bit, the more words I can learn, the more my vocabulary is enhanced and so I'm extremely thankful to the writers who use so called big words- (I have had to face that criticism several times myself). Again, the only proviso would be that thestyle should be natural and not merely affected to impress.
  3. Sindhu's Avatar
    When was Anthony ever Gloria's in the first place to leave her? My answer would be that not Anthony, but her ideas/ imagination left Gloria and so she has to feed upon the only thing left to her- memories of her creativity.

    (Ok, I probably am so far off the mark,that I sound crazy!) Anyway, I really enjoyed reading the story.
  4. Countess's Avatar
    Andave, you are a romantic, so I will pray for you. Romantics have a hard time in life. Just be careful with your own, young heart.
    Sindhu, Anthony was never "hers" (she never wanted to own him - remember he hadn't any master? She liked him best unmastered) , but one can leave a friend, a family member or a lover (or even an institution). They had a relationship of some sort, evidentally one that pervaded his consciousness/subconsciousness because his conversation to others/Maury is comprised of the subject matter in her letters: ie: she's reading Ovid's Metamorphosis and has recommended it to Anthony, and Maury mentions Anthony is reading Ovid's "Metamorphosis" and loves it. She has jested to Anthony that he probably squalks when he sings and in talking to her Maury mentions that he has heard Anthony sing, and he does not squalk, but actually has a respectable voice.

    AND I SHOULD ADD this poem was never about horses: it was always about Anthony (I need to work the rhythm out but it's almost there):

    http://www.online-literature.com/for...642#post382642
  5. mtpspur's Avatar
    Constructive criticism is dificult at best. I have noticed your vocabulary range but was giving you points for creativity and intelligence being used. Now I'm no good at critiquing because my reading range is up and down the charts, Spurgeon's sermons (one a day), comic books, pulp reprints. The only literature I've read recently was The Sea Wolf here on Litnet (it dragged as a kid--made much more sense as an adult).

    I noticed you are working on a vampire story from reading your blog page--why not polish that up and submit around. Weird Tales I believe is still on quarterly basis and I think antas and SF is too. This might help get your foot in the door. Novels are tricky for publishers (I believe) especially the first timers being such an unknown quanity. Admitedly the number of fiction magazines has dwindled over the decades yet I could see you making the cut.

    Not sure what to make of Anthony. Sounds a bit wrapped up in himself (from a guy point of view we tend to take relationships that aren't VESTED for granted. He might just pop back in when least expected or just wants his space to himself. Not sure--in my life its the ladies who have the power it always seemed to me. Even the long suffering spouse has been displaying much independent spirit lately since going back to school which is amusing and alarming and precious all at once.

    As always--all the best. Rich
  6. Captain Pike's Avatar
    Maybe they're afraid you'll stock them if they say the wrong thing about your writing.
  7. kathycf's Avatar
    Do you want corrections or do you want to know that people are reading your work? I haven't noticed anything in your writing that needed correction, frankly...no obvious grammatical mistakes or misspelled words. I am not sure what to say to people sometimes about anything, so I'm afraid I am not often specific in my comments. ------------------------

    Regarding Anthony and Gloria...their relationship seems nebulous to me. It consisted soley of letter writing? There isn't enough information about Anthony as a person (for me anyway) to speculate on his motivation for cutting off contact with Gloria
  8. Countess's Avatar
    I guess for me I need to know if what I'm writing is speaking to the heart of others and making them think. I need to know if what I write produces internal change in others; ultimately I want to affect people in some way. I don't want to simply write a "cute story" or a "Davinci Code", etc.
    Make sense?