View RSS Feed

title

The Firing

Rate this Entry
In my last entry I was going to cover some odds and ends but jon1jt expressed honest concerns regarding my mention of getting a tow driver fired. For this he is to be commended and his concerns I hope to put at rest.

Old time readers will know I often do a newspaper style of an attention grabber sentence that is technically true but ultimately means something quite different. Yes I took an action that resulted in a man losing his job. Now lets review the situation as best we can:

Now some AAA clubs have their own fleet of trucks and drivers that work directly for them. The club I toil for 'rents' a fleet from a contractor and we can use and abuse the four assigned drivers as we please--translation--the police won't up and grab them for accident calls at the drop of a dime. Otherwise AAA has contracts with local towing companies agreeing to run AAA calls for so much a call (average is about $15 a call but they can make some money on tow miiles for instance or in many cases talk the member into bringing the malfunctioning vehicle to their place of repair.)

Now the drivers we dispatch in theory are accountable to us at AAA when we run a call but their ultimate loyalty and responsibility is to their station owner. He/She pays their salary afterall. About 95% of the drivers are hard working professionals; charming in customer service relations and actually enjoy the challenge and the day to day madness that goes with the territory.

But the 5% are constantly switching stations (looking for better pay/hours/conditions) with the view that what benefits THEM is more important then doing the job. I have one station for instance (two actually) where Junior works for dad but if Junior doesn't feel like it he'll turn down a call without a qualm of conscience for the fiscal health of the business. Some stations do not LIKE to do long distance tows (usual in fear of missing the more lucrative police calls).

Last Sunday I had the 2-10 pm shift and I was guarding the Dayton area primarily and partner Bob was overseeing Greene county and nw area of Dayton. There is a company that runs Englewood and Brookville and they usually have only one driver on call for weekends. Said driver, Jeff, had had only one call that day and he had fussed at day shift about going on it.

We hear grumbling all the time. I can let it in one ear and out the other--sometimes doing the AWWWW poor baby routine or Gee life sucks do it anyway and get by. Today was going to be different. Now Jeff used to work for a station in Moraine that is one of our busiest contractors--Sta 0010 is NOT satisfied is he doesn't get 90 calls a day. You would amazed how close he gets. Jeff had made no major impression on me while working there but when he moved to the Englewood company #0159 I noticed a tendency to whine and question each call. One time he flat out said he didn't want to do one because a mere tire change just wasn't bringing in the money. My answer to that was my patented something is better then nothing. My other partners in dispatch definitely did not like him and not afrraid to say so. I like to feel I can take an awful lot before I react. And have. Both ways.

Around 6:30 pm a tire change on the interstate came in and Jeff was paged by Bob and the paged time noted in the computer. Usually the station answers back in 5 minutes. Sometimes though 0159 needs a second page but it took Jeff 20 minutes to respond. In the meantime a short tow also came in. Bob was busy on the phone so when Jeff decided to check in I pounded the phone over and the conversation went something along the lines of:

Driver: This is Jeff, you paged?

Me: Yes, I had a tire change but now we have two calls holding for you. (I worded it this way as a dig at the poor page response time.)

What I expected next was along the lines the lines of Let me have the info.

What I got was:

Driver: I don't have time for this stuff.. I have a lot of s*** to do. I can't be out there doing all this I have stuff to do.

There was a bit more to it then that but the tone is what got me. This was not the fine I'll turn off my Brady Bunch rerun I was watching and go help the helpless change a tire -- darn one of the rare Jan episodes too. No this was heated excitement bordering on mild hysteria.

I attempt to remind him that: "Ah but this is the profession you have chosen." The use of the word profession was deliberate to bring him to proper decorum.

Response: Man I'm not doing weekends anymore. I have stuff I have to do. (Broken record by now and the grizzley is starting to awaken.) His manner was like a person who has an overflowing toliet and can't figure out how to turn the water off.

I decide then and there I don't want him touching a tire and maybe he just needs a time out. I start to mention this when out of the blue he goes;

"Who's Bob???"

Well Bob is my partner and what has he got to do with any of this. I'm the dispatcher he is dealing with. This put the nail in his coffin. I don't want him in his truck right now going anywhere soon.

I quietly but firmly say--"I'm covering the calls we're done." and hang up.
Again quietly. Been awhile since I have slammed a phone. Always fun when Tonya does it.

A minute later Jeff calls Bob and says he was just going for a pencil and why did I hang up like that?! When Bob starts to go over the fallow ground Jeff abruptly hangs up on him.

Bob and I chat a bit and he suggests that Jeff's boss, Ron, be informed of a 'situation' to which I in my heart of hearts agree with but dislike going to that level. Bob makes the call.

Five minutes later Ron calls and says Jeff is history and apologizes for his behavior. I can honestly say I did not take it personal. I hope never to be smug about another man's fall.

I called his old station and talked to Liz and was discovered he was not liked at all there and his integrity was in question. We'll leave it at that.

I ask manager Debbie about it Monday and she assures me my actions were justified. Again--complaining about work--getting incoherent about it--two different things. She felt (and I agree) Ron would not have let him go on the basis of one bad afternoon. If that were so I wouldn't have a job at AAA--many afternoons worth. It was probably the final straw to a lackluster work performance.

I left the parking lot that evening carefully looking around reminding myself that I may be a military retiree but I was never a really brave man.

So Jon1jt--hope this puts your fears to rest. I took no pleasure in his downfall. No glory this day.
Categories

Comments

  1. Niamh's Avatar
    Well its understandable. If your guys had been havin problems with him for a while and then something like this happens its only right to inform the guys manager. You guys had a job to do and were relying on him and he wouldnt co opperate, and acted like a prat. You did the right thing. And dont feel guilty about it.
  2. B-Mental's Avatar
    LoL...I love it. Catch ya later, and thanks for the therapy session...
  3. motherhubbard's Avatar
    I sympathize with your situation and also think that you did the right thing. I was afraid at first it was going to be your firing that this was about. I'm behind in the blogs.
  4. Virgil's Avatar
    People like Jeff are a cancer to everyone else. Life and work are hard enough, but people like Jeff bring cynacism and lack of professionalism. His attitude if allowed to flourish will spread to everyone else. And then what? Look at places like government offices where it's almost impossible to get rid of bad apples. The whole office takes the mentality of the lowest common denominator. Good riddence.
  5. andave_ya's Avatar
    Yipe, my sympathies. That was tough. Goodness, I'd have blown off my top yammering on about ethics and integrity and all that sort of thing. EDIT: by the way I like the new blog name.
  6. 's Avatar
    This problem in towing is widespread. My cousin works as a dispatcher for a private service, and according to him his company doesn't make much on AAA calls. They do them, but they're low priority. Their top priority is the state Turnpike. The private drivers don't feel that sense of accountability in this arrangement. Who is to blame? Certainly the drivers like that bum Jeff who gave you a tough time. That's unprofessional and you shouldn't have had to deal with that nonsense. Unfortunately, that's the strange arrangement AAA is part of, and they're just as complicit as the private services. They've created a system and like you said the drivers are loyal to the parent company which is counter to AAA's premium service. The money is just not there for the contracted drivers, and I realize that's no excuse. You do your job. I hate to say it but that's wishful thinking these days. As far as your dealings with Jeff, you shouldn't have hung up on him. I realize he was obnoxious, but you did have two calls on hold, and a non-compliant driver. You hung up assuming that he's going to do those calls. Why? I wouldn't have assumed that, if you did. What if those calls involved our cars that needed a tow, and we were broken down on the shoulder of some dangerous single lane road? We'd want help to arrive ASAP. In fairness, AAA's response time is usually very good, at least the times I've called them (yes, I'm a card-carrying member) But I have also been in situations where I needed a tow in snow and was placed on hold forever. Or if I did get through the response time was god awful. SOLUTION: AAA cuts out the middle guy and offers a real premium service wherein drivers are loyal, responsive, cooperative, and customer gets quality service that they deserve. I'd be willing to pay extra membership fees for that kind of service, most people would.
  7. mtpspur's Avatar
    To jon1lt: I believe you misunderstand one small thing. I made a conscious decision that the driver was in no 'condiiton' to do a job with the professionalism we expect from our tow companies. Also I told him we are done and then hung up in response to his totally inane question of who's Bob. Remember he never asked the location of the calls but was focused on his interupted weekend when I had every right to expect him to get out the door and do his job. He had already wasted 20 minutes of our time. I did not consider him dispatched. I got coverage on the two calls and drivers on the way within three minutes. Had I slammed the phone--then I would feel a bit out of it. Yes AAA pays poorly but the stations ride on our reputation, I don't even mind a company doing a cash call before us but the contracts AS WRITTEN put us first if push comes to shove. The stations I object to are the ones that put all other calls of theirs ahead of us and still expect gravy. The premium service is great for the clubs that have their own fleet of trucks to use but I belong to a small one--six counties and rely heavily on outside contractors who know what they signed up for before they drive for us. Should be no surprise to you that some companies won't touch us with a ten foot pole and I can live with that. My personal opinion is by the time I retire AAA will finally wake up and realize the 'other' programs out there are starting to provide real competition.
  8. kiz_paws's Avatar
    Rich, Jeff dug his own grave, and the chips fell where they were supposed to. You handled yourself professionally and kept your temper in check (just think if you had let the guy know exactly what you were REALLY thinking), you know? I would not give this any guilt pangs whatsoever. As you mentioned in your well told words, his boss Ron would not have let him go on just one infraction. There must have been plenty that led up to it. The line
    I left the parking lot that evening carefully looking around reminding myself that I may be a military retiree but I was never a really brave man.
    made me feel bad for you. You are a very good person, Rich, an example to all of us. And our bonus is that you have an amazing blog with all kinds of gems for our ponderings, amusement, and lessons of all sorts. Thank you Rich. K♥z
  9. applepie's Avatar
    Sounds like you did the right thing my friend, but it is still hard to be part of things like that. I always feel guilty, no matter how justified my own actions are. Much Love, Meg