PDA

View Full Version : Posted in wrong forum, will someone tell me if my short story is good?



yorkoa
09-14-2014, 04:30 PM
A war exists within every artist, and every artist has to accept a war against the world. This is Martin's war.

Because of work and family, Martin could only spend an hour a day on his writing. It seemed like it went well for a while. He created characters, used his pen as a paintbrush to compose vivid imagery, and scribbled storylines that had potential. He endeavored to stick with one story but struggled to quiet his mind. In the midst of working on a story, a new idea would sneak into his head, and he would trash the idea he was working on and run with the new idea that crept into his head. He soon realized that he needed more than an hour a night to write. He assumed it would be much easier to formulate his thoughts completely if he had two hours to work on his stories.

To have two hours a day to work on his stories, he decided needed to discontinue eating dinner with his family. If he ate while he worked, it would give him a full hour more a night to write. He assumed his family would forgive him once they realized the success of his writing. At first, Margaret completely rejected the idea.

"You'd rather spend two hours a night in that smelly basement 'working' than have dinner with your family!?" she yelled.

"Margaret, please," Martin pleaded, "you have to trust me! I'll be happy once I get a few stories published! We will get a house on the coast for you and the kids!"

"I don't want a goddamn house on the coast!" she screamed. "I want to have dinner with my husband and my kids! Is that so much to ask? That is the only time we have to talk every night, and you want to take that away? We already go to bed at separate times! I can't even remember the last time we..."

"Margaret! The kids can hear us!" he yelled. "Just trust me, if I have one extra hour each night, I can get a lot more writing done. Once I get published, I can quit my job, and we can spend day after day together!"

"Damnit, Martin," she said. "Fine, but I'm not cooking your ****ing meals!"
"Margaret! The kids!" he screamed, but she walked away. He retreated to the basement, where he had a crisp stack of papers lying on his desk. He put his pen down. His soul possessed his hand. Like an instrument, he wrote effortlessly and melodically his deepest inhibitions. Finally, he was at complete peace. No nagging wife, no loud kids, just him and the basement. He set his timer for two hours, and wrote for two hours.

The next morning he went to work. A new idea for a story sauntered into his thoughts like a curious cat. The story he spent two hours on the night before seemed like complete rubbish compared to this new idea. He sat in his cubicle trying not to forget it, trying to work at the same time, and trying to look normal in front of his coworkers. Suddenly, a thought came to his head. He realized that he could spend an hour at work writing his stories, and nobody would ever notice. He already spent a lot of time lollygagging with other employees in the break room. He began devoting all of his extra time to his stories.

He still faced a major problem. He could not seem to stick to one story. Each time he stopped working on a story, a new idea would pop-up, and he would discard his work to pursue the new idea. He decided that his problem centered around spending time away from his stories. Without consulting his wife, Martin quit his job to write full time. He went home to tell his wife what he did.

"What the **** is wrong with you?" she said, too tired of his nonsense to muster up any other words.

"Margaret, try to understand!" he begged. "I will have more time to pursue my writing without this job! I can complete my stories, have them published, and I will make more money in the end doing just that!"

"Your stories!?" she yelled. "You haven't produced a single story in your entire life! You have been distancing yourself more-and-more from your family, your community, and reality! I don't even know you anymore! Have you ever even talked to a publisher before? Do you even know how that process works? Do you know how much a writer makes?"

"Listen, I'll work on my stories all throughout the day and when you get home from work we can spend more time together," he explained
.
"How will we pay the bills? We might make it a few months, but after that I don't think we will be able to keep up!" she screamed.

"In a few months I'll have stories published! I'll sign a contract and make money!" he replied.

"This is ridiculous. Do whatever you want to do," she said, and she went upstairs. Margaret's approval of his new full-time profession excited him. He ran to the basement and began writing. Thoughts flowed in and he poured them out onto paper. He wrote all through the night, and fell asleep at his desk. As soon as he awoke, he continued to write.

Martin began losing track of time. He spent all of his days in the basement, shielded from the world. He found an old mattress to sleep on so he wouldn't be away from his writing for too long. He only went upstairs occasionally to quickly find something to eat. He raced upstairs, grabbed something from the pantry, and then raced back downstairs to continue writing. One good idea led him to a better idea, and he felt his writing continued to improve. After an obscure period of time, he decided to take a short break from his writing to spend time with his family. Still, he had never completed a story, but he felt close.

When he emerged from the den, he realized how empty and dusty the house was.

"Margaret?!" he yelled. No one responded, and he realized that no one was home. He looked at the clock and it read 6:32 PM. Normally, his family ate dinner at this time. They should have been home. He went out to the mailbox, opened it, and found it packed full of unopened mail. He looked up and saw his driveway coated with unread newspapers. He looked at his lawn and the grass rose above his kneecaps.

Martin quickly ran inside and phoned his wife. She disconnected her cell phone. He tried to call her sister and parents, but they refused to talk to him or tell him where she had gone. He pounded his fists against the kitchen table and demanded to know where his family was, but nobody gave him any answers. He looked through the bills and saw that they were all overdue. This is when he sought out Dr. Chang.

"What seems to be troubling you, Martin?" asked the Doctor as Martin sat across the room frantically scratching at his beard.

"I can't finish a story," Martin quickly replied. His eyes darted around the room. Months of shielding himself from people made it difficult for him to speak.

"You can't finish a story? What do you mean?" he asked.

"I mean that I am a writer, but I just can't finish a story. Every time I get a good idea, I run with it, but when I start writing about that idea, a new, better idea pops into my head, and the story I am working on when I get the new idea just sounds like ****. I throw away the story that I'm working on and pursue the new idea, but then a better idea comes to mind, and I pursue that idea. It's an endless cycle, and I just can't seem to produce a single story. I just can't quiet my thinking."

"How long has this been going on?" inquired the Doctor.

"For as long as I can remember," he replied. "I've been writing stories all my life, but I've never finished a single one."

"That sounds frustrating. Do you have a family?" asked Doctor Chang. He looked up and hesitated before answering my question.

"No, not anymore," he said. The Doctor tried to pull some truth out of him, but he dodged each question and focused the conversation on his writing. He revealed bits and pieces of the truth. Wretchedness obscured most of his thoughts, and his writing clouded his judgment. "Doc, can you help me focus my thinking?"

"I can only try," he replied. Doctor Chang thought about how he could help him come up with a story. "Okay, Martin, I think can help you. Now, this might sound a little strange, but if you do what I tell you to do, you will be able to finish a story. I want you to go home, get a good night sleep. Start writing in the morning. Don't stop writing. Before you discard the story for a better one, give me a call. Whatever you do, call me before you throw away the story."

Martin left the office, frantic and skeptical about my tactic. He went home, got a good night sleep, and began writing in the morning. Sure enough, after two hours of writing, he phoned the Doctor. The Doctor encouraged him not to throw away the idea he was working on, and after twenty minutes of arguing, he agreed that he wouldn't throw it away. Doctor Chang got four more phone calls that day, and each of them consisted of him convincing Martin to continue working on the story that he started in the morning. The next day Martin called Dr. Chang very early.

"I did it!" yelled the voice from the other end.

"Martin? Is that you? It's five AM," the Doctor uttered, half asleep.

"I finished a story! I can't believe it! You've helped me finish a story!" he exclaimed.

"That's great Martin, I'm glad I could help," he replied.

"I'll come to your office at nine AM to show you what I've written," he said.

Dr. Chang arrived at my office and waited for Martin. Martin never showed up. The next day, the Doctor read in the newspaper that Martin died in a car accident. He suspected Martin was headed to his office since the crash occurred at 8:48 AM. Martin fell asleep at the wheel driving forty miles per hour over the speed limit. His car flew off the road, hit a ditch, and flipped. The car lit on fire and everything inside of it burned up, even the only story he had ever finished.

nicksherman9
09-16-2014, 10:53 AM
Not sure how I feel about the ending, but I still enjoyed the story quite a bit. I think all amateur writers feel like Martin, at times. The frustration of not being completely happy with what you've written and constantly chasing that new brilliant idea that's going to be "the one". It was almost hard to read because of that, but in a good way. Nice job.

108 fountains
09-19-2014, 10:41 AM
It's an interesting concept and it held my interest, but I was disappointed with the endiong. It just seemed like a lazy way out. I'll bet if you set your mind to it, you could think of a way to resolve the story in a more interesting way.

Hawkman
09-19-2014, 12:23 PM
Here's a tip: a great wall of text with no breaks, especially in the standard font on the forum, is not an inviting sight and will put many readers off. When you post, i.e. copying what you've written from word, or whatever program you're using, and past it into the post window, all the formatting, assuming you've bothered to put any in, is destroyed. If, however, you insert an extra linefeed between paragraphs, and between lines of dialogue with the change of speaker, it is carried over into the post, and consequently, becomes much more readable. Please do this in future.

You can cut all the preamble. The story doesn't actually start until, "It seemed like the writing went well for a while." The first use of the proper name Martin is fine, but you don't need to tell us his name again in the next sentence. "He" is quite sufficient. You tell us his name 4 times in this paragraph alone. This over use of names is continued throughout the piece.

I'm inclined to agree that the story doesn't really go anywhere. The key to character development is change. Ok so he finished his story, but wiping him and it out leaves nothing. It just becomes a flat story about a loser, losing.

The switch from third person to first person narration is jarring. Who is the narrator? How can he possibly be privy to all that has gone before that dangling "I" after "he sought me out." These are the kinds of things you need to look out for. We don't need the guy's bio laid out for us like his CV before the story actually starts. We don't need to be repeatedly told his name. Be consistent in the narrative voice and give the story somewhere to go.

I will watch future posts with interest, providing you break up the text a bit. ;)

Live and be well - H

yorkoa
09-20-2014, 12:06 AM
Thank you very much for all the feedback. I am really happy people actually read my story. Hawkman, I will try to figure out how I can break it up, but I'm not really good with computers so I just copied and pasted. I will use his first name less, I guess I didn't realize it.

I guess the ending does seem lazy, but I didn't intend for that. I guess the point was to show that Martin threw away everything and had nothing to show for it. He could have been a great writer if he believed in himself, but he always felt his ideas weren't good enough, so he threw them away.

yorkoa
09-20-2014, 12:07 AM
Also, I felt there was no need to explain that Martin talked to a psychiatrist/social worker at the end. Maybe I should mention that, but I feel it's unnecessary.

Hawkman
09-20-2014, 03:51 AM
I think you're missing my point about the change of narrative voice from an omniscient 3rd person to 1st person, three quarters of the way through. Ok, so the 1st person narrator is a psychiatrist, but the change in voice at this point of the tale doesn't work. You can still have Martin go and see a doctor, but keep it consistent with the rest of the tale. Describe the interaction from the same perspective you've been using up to this point, i.e. the third person omniscient.

What I said about the preamble still stands. All the background is completely irrelevant. We don't need to know what school he went to, or how he met his wife etc. What is the story about? It's about a guy trying to write a story. None of the other stuff has any bearing on this. Start the tale in medias res. that is, get straight into the action. That's why I told you in my earlier post that the story didn't actually start until, "it seemed like the writing went well for a while."

Ok that's enough lecturing. The bit I really enjoyed in this was the way he discovered that his wife had left him and he hadn't noticed. This was both humorous and nicely illustrative of his obsessional alienation.

Live and be well - H

yorkoa
09-20-2014, 10:26 AM
Okay, I understand, and I made the changes. I could probably figure out a better way to start it that isn't so lengthy. I really like the first line, so I left it in there. I took out all of the first person voice. I guess if enough people tell me to change the ending I will do that. Thank you Hawkman for all the feedback! I really appreciate it!