Log in

View Full Version : 'El acercamiento a Almotásim'



Kyriakos
09-28-2013, 04:32 PM
El acercamiento a Almotásim, which is mostly translated to English as "The Approach to Al-Mu'tasim", was the first short story that Borges created as part of his decision to move to prose from poetry, his original medium of expression. It was written in the early 1930s.

The story is interesting, and Borges himself noted in his self-biography that: "t now seems to me to foreshadow and even to set the pattern for those tales that were somehow awaiting me, and upon which my reputation as a storyteller was to be based".

A brief synopsis, which will not leave room to reveal the plotline in a crucial way, is that it is about a book whose main character decides to find a person he believes is called by the name of Al-Mutasim, the same name a noted chaliph of the 9th century muslim lands bordering the Byzantine Empire had. The actual name means "he who seeks refuge", and it seems to allude to god as the one the refuge will be given by.

Borges, in the final pages of the story (as is his usual style later on too) presents a more complicated explanation of the book he refers to. He speaks of a formation of the whole universe which might account for everyone seeking someone else, and in all the interconnected parts, thus (maybe) turning everyone to a god who grants refuge.

The story also has a minor allusion to the mathematic concept of infinite series, like some later works of Borges.

I wanted to ask a couple of things:

-Have you read this short story? What do you think of it if you have?

-Are you of the view that literature is a good medium for such ideas? In my view they are important, but in literature it possibly is more crucial to strike a balance between ideas and the actual iconic (mostly mean pictorial here) presentation of the work. However i always like Borges in his best stories, and i regard this one, which i read only four days ago, a notable creation of his as well :)

machokrap
10-03-2013, 09:59 AM
-Have you read this short story? What do you think of it if you have?

-Are you of the view that literature is a good medium for such ideas? In my view they are important, but in literature it possibly is more crucial to strike a balance between ideas and the actual iconic (mostly mean pictorial here) presentation of the work. However i always like Borges in his best stories, and i regard this one, which i read only four days ago, a notable creation of his as well :)

This is one of his essays on metaphysics masquerading as short stories, he has quite a few like this, doesn't he?
What I like about these type of stories is that he has a knack of making his fantasies so believable, that it's easy to immerse in them and when finished I am left with a sense of wonder, like a little kid that can still believe that there are parallel worlds and realities completely different to ours, but that are there for us to discover and reach.

I sense it tries to challenge traditional religion/spirituality in this story, that we need to move away from the concept of a higher being or god, even rejecting the validity of a "Jesus" type kind of person.

I think it's perfectly valid to explore these concepts in literature, but it's the way that he goes about it.
What I don't like about these types of stories is that he gets too carried away throwing scholarly, historical and factual references (both imaginary and real). It gets too erudite and arcane, which makes the stories hard to read and enjoy. I think it would have been best to keep things simpler.

As a said before, they are more like essays than stories.

JCamilo
10-03-2013, 12:46 PM
Almostasin is not his first short story, but the first where he discovers he can tell a story within a story using the blending of essay and narrative. Anyways, Borges claim this discovery happened after the accident in 1938, when he hurt his head and in the hospital panicked under a huge author block. After his mother calmed him, reading the novel, Out of Silence Space, he came with Pierre Menard. (Funes and Daneri both discover their memory and the alleph after a fall too). He often repeats this tale in interviews and biographies.

Almostasin proves he had it before the accident.