Log in

View Full Version : Kindred



mrtiddles
06-11-2013, 03:15 PM
I would love to get some feedback after the first few drafts of my short story. I'm attempting to get back into this as I've not written since high school and miss it quite a bit. I would love some criticism on this piece and appreciate your time. Thanks.

-------

She walked into her room bear-hugging the latest load of laundry, still warm from the dryer. The blinds were still open and from her second-floor apartment she could see the lone street lamp below illuminating the light rain as it fell. The clothes made a soft creak in the bed as she tossed them intentionally yet carefully down, then walked to the window. She took a moment to enjoy the view of the street corner as it soaked in the evening’s storm before she pulled the string which closed the blinds.

As she turned to retrieve the stack of clothes, mentally preparing herself for another night of white wine, laundry and Netflix, she glanced in the closet to ensure there was enough space to hang this particularly formidable load of laundry.

Surely she’d noticed that small knob on the back wall of the closet before. Surely she’d noticed it and just forgotten. She moved in nearly a year ago, excited to be near the heart of the city, and yet she had somehow missed this detail. The wood floors creaked as she moved to inspect the knob.

The storm that had been startling her with thunder an hour before had apparently settled and was only raining steady yet oddly quiet. This unsettled her.

Leaning down, the crack in the wood which outlined a door became visible. Surely this wasn’t anything more than a cupboard oddly placed in a small closet. She reached out to grab the knob, hesitating before pulling.

The crack expanded and the size of the door which opened at her insistence was startling. It was maybe four feet high, wide enough for a person to walk through and completely black inside. It wasn’t a shelf. There was depth. A musty smell fell out of the doorway.

How could she have missed this? Perhaps her clothes had always been in the way. Perhaps she’d never gone two weeks without doing laundry before, leaving only portions of the closet empty at a time. For a moment she regretted her vacation, but the memory of beaches and margaritas slipped through and briefly she let her thoughts wander.

Somehow the pure dark of the void made itself known again and pulled her back from her daydream and she shook as chills enveloped her. She laughed a nervous laugh, attempting to cope, and then stood to find a light.

She reached for the emergency flashlight that was always on the top shelf of the closet, looked at the bulb as she pressed the button and smiled as it burned to life and lit her face, casting shadows on her face that would have frightened her had she seen them.

Hesitation. There was a moment where the thought of shutting the door and forgetting about it without looking crossed her mind, but she realized there was little chance of her ever sleeping again in this room if she let her imagination fill her thoughts with what-ifs.

She pointed the beam into the black.

Shadows hid and played about, teasing the beam of light visible through dust which was shaken loose as she opened the door. There were stairs, maybe six of them and a room.

Summoning all of her inner strength, she knelt down and took the first step. The top stair creaked under new stress. She breathed in the stale air as she proceeded down the steps, one by one, moving very slowly while she shined the flashlight at her feet. As she reached the bottom, she took a shallow breath and looked up, pointing the light into the room.

Light played on the brown wall and reflected ever so little, bathing the room in barely-visible warmth as her eyes adjusted. After a few quick sweeps of the light, her anxiety had faded mildly. The room seemed to barely be large enough to contain the few things present, none of which were as terrifying as she had feared.

A small desk rested in the center of the room, garnished with a candlestick, wax overflowing and no candle left, and a small book covered in dust. A fountain pen lay beside the book. A single photo in a small frame sat upright in the corner. She lifted the photo and inspected it closely. Easily turn-of-the-century, the brown tones through cracked glass revealed a couple. They were happy, smiling at each other. As she stared at the photo, the feeling it invoked was overwhelming. She’d not felt this in years and it startled her enough that she put the photo down quickly, shaking off the sudden rush of emotion.

She reached for the book, opened the cover and as the dust fell from the binding, she read the first entry.


I am in love. We met at the fair. His name is John. He was sitting with his friends as I walked by and he stood and said “ma’am, can you settle a bet?”. I obliged and asked what I could do, trying not to be obvious as I smiled. He asked me what the last seven letters of the alphabet were, so I told him they were obviously T, U, V, W, X, Y, and Z. He said “that’s what the boys keep telling me, but I keep telling them that U and I should be together.”

He had me flustered. I agreed to let him buy me a soda, so we sat near the entrance for hours, talking. He was so sweet. Nothing like papa. I’m scared to talk to him again because I know papa won’t like it but I have to see John again. Maybe we can keep it a secret.

There was no name on the journal. No dates either. The entries even seemed to have sections where the text was written at different times, some sentences being smaller than others, some seemed more patiently-written while others were difficult to read due to the haste with which they were scrawled. She turned a few pages and read again.


John wants to come around but I keep telling him I can’t talk to papa. I’m afraid to tell him how angry he can get. John is so sweet and caring but I can’t let him know the truth about my bruises. I keep letting on that I'm jut clumsy. Anyway, he’d want to talk to papa and I'm scared of what he would do to John.

Mother won’t talk to us anymore, she seems so distant and stares out the window for hours before papa takes her into their room and locks the door, she comes out with tears but never cries.

She thought back to her own childhood for a moment. In the years that separated her and this mystery girl, some things refuse to change. Her own father had been physically abusive when she was young and now that she’d moved to the city, the few times a year they spoke he seemed content to pretend it never happened.

As she flipped pages forward in the book, the text stopped. Half the book had been left empty. She flipped back two pages and found an entry.


I can’t take it, I love John so much. He knows about papa now. Most of town seems to know. I think I’m going to leave. I’m going to tell papa tonight about John and tell him I’m leaving to be with him. John says we can get married and move to the city and start a family, oh how I want that. How I want to watch the glittery street lights at night as we sit by a fire.

Pray for me, I'm still scared of papa but John gives me strength.

There was no more writing in the book.

She stared at the final entry in disbelief as tears crept through her eyes and began to fall down her cheeks as she began to weep more severely than she had since she was a child.

cafolini
06-11-2013, 05:56 PM
I got fed up in the first paragraph because of the timing disorder and the redundancy. Will wait for Hillwalker for further analysis. I edited the first paragraph as I think it should go.

She returned to her room bear-hugging the latest load of warm laundry. From her second-floor apartment she could see the lone street lamp illuminating the light rain. She took a moment to enjoy the view of the street corner and closed the blinds. The clothes made a soft creak as she tossed them down on the bed.

Cioran
06-11-2013, 06:18 PM
Will wait for Hillwalker for further analysis.

LOL, of course you'll wait for Hillwalker!

Hillwalker! Hillwalker! What should I think? Tell me what to think!

:biggrin5:

cafolini
06-11-2013, 07:00 PM
No. I'll wait for you and more vodka pood.

Cioran
06-11-2013, 07:38 PM
mrtiddles, it's way too wordy. Ignore the people who will attack you and your work, because attacking the work of others is what turns them on. What you want is to get it down to the core. You are using WAY too many words to describe ordinary stuff. Here is my proposed edit, so far:



Kindred
By mrtiddles


She bear-hugged her laundry, warm from the dryer. The blinds were open. From her second-floor apartment, she could see the lone streetlamp below. It lighted the misting rain.

She closed the blinds.

She set the laundry on the floor, and then collapsed on her couch and exhaled. She steeled herself for another night of white wine and Netflix.

She appraised the open closet, wondering if the clean clothes would fit in in it.

She saw a knob on the back wall of the closet.

She had never seen it before.

She had moved into this apartment nearly a year ago, rapturous to be here. Yet somehow, she had missed this little ditty in the big city.

A knob. A simple knob.

The hardwood floor creaked under her footfalls as she approached the closet.

The rain ticked on the roof. An hour earlier, she had been startled by the forks of lightning and the cracks of thunder. Yet now, as a steady rain pattered down, she felt more unsettled than before, when flashes of lightning lit up her room and thunder shook it.

She leaned toward the knob, and saw that it was a doorknob.

It rattled in her hand.

She pulled. The door opened with a creak of rusty hinges.

How could she have missed a door in the back of her closet?

Beaches and margaritas. Her recent vacation. In her mind's eyes, she saw the sun of the south.

Behind the door, there was only blackness.

She patted around on a shelf in the closet, and found the flashlight that she kept there. She turned it on, and pointed the beam into the black.

The light cut through dust motes, illumining a set of stairs angling downward.

Her breath hitched, and she froze. But then curiosity thawed her out, and she stepped forward.

The top step creaked loudly under her first tentative footfall, and this sound made her freeze again. She pointed the light into the night.

TO BE CONTINUED

hillwalker
06-12-2013, 03:52 AM
I'll pass since my feedback is not worth the screen space it's written on.

H

Calidore
06-12-2013, 08:17 AM
I'll pass since my feedback is not worth the screen space it's written on.

H

Only to one person.

mrtiddles
06-12-2013, 01:10 PM
Thanks for the bits of advice, folks. I'll be working on a rewrite soon and taking most of this into consideration. I agree I was too wordy, though Cioran, I think your edit is a bit too short-winded for my writing style so I'll find a happy medium. I also noticed several issues with timing and order that Cafolini pointed out and will be reviewing the story with that in mind.

Cioran, thanks for the tips about ignoring people who like to attack work. I realize plenty of people have their own ideas about stories and lots of "opinions" can be shrugged off while picking the valuable bits out and improving my writing.

Thanks again for reading, folks.

Delta40
06-12-2013, 06:22 PM
It is too wordy. Readers don't want a creative write on the mundane so put your energy into the nitty gritty!