PDA

View Full Version : The Life and Death of a Coward



Nikhar
07-02-2012, 10:29 AM
The Life and Death of a Coward


She stood at the entrance of the general ward for a few moments, hesitant to enter because of the blood, the crowd and the chaos. Around almost each bed were women, just like her, with dark and weathered skin clothed in discolored cotton sarees, wailing over their husband’s injured and dead bodies. The doctors shuffled in a businesslike manner from bed to bed treating those who could still be saved. Young nurses strutted nervously around the room with medicines and syringes, probably wondering if the job was for them. The ward boys carried the dead bodies to the morgue to make room for other injured patients.

She gathered her strength and moved forward through the maze of beds and corpses looking from bed to bed, searching for her husband, carefully holding the ghoonghat over her face in one hand and a small battered cloth purse in the other.

At the other end of the room, she finally saw her husband laid upon a bed, very still. The site of his body gave her quite a scare. His face was very pale. She put her hands over his nostrils. He was breathing but only barely. His body was heavily bandaged except his legs which was weird because it was his legs that looked the funniest. The legs were heavily scarred and there was a grisly purple blotch beneath the knee on one of the legs. But what probably terrified her most was the blood stain that was slowly spreading on the bed sheet and the fact that all the doctors were busy attending other patients.

She became really anxious…why was nobody treating him? She looked around, sweating profusely now, worried that she might have to return into the crowd to search for a free doctor. But to her relief she found one only two beds away. ‘Doctor Sahib! ‘, her voice sounded like that of a sparrow at a dhobi ghaat, out of place and barely audible. She called for the doctor again, louder this time. Instantly she flinched; she never raised her voice near her husband. But when her husband did not react, she felt something entirely different. It had felt so alien to her that she could not quite place it at the time.

It was only later on, when she had pulled the oxygen mask off his face, that she had realized what it was…freedom.

***
She thanked her neighbors for taking care of her daughter and entered one of the many huts on the roadside, each of which was walled and roofed by thin corrugated iron sheets, undistinguishable from the others except for the advertisement poster of a local toothpaste brand taped onto the metal. After the hospital, her small hut made her pretty comfortable. She quietly laid her daughter in the wooden cradle and smiled for the first time in the day. She gently began rocking it.

‘I hope Ravi is able to manage everything in the hospital. It’s a pity he does not like his father. I wish he did. But can I blame him? He hasn’t really had the best of childhood. At 16, he is already so much more mature. Maybe I shouldn’t have left him at the hospital alone. Not that I don’t trust him. He’s a wonderful son. But maybe, it’s too much for him? Well, I didn’t exactly have a choice, did I? Had to feed Lali too…she’s so frail anyways. I did not come back from the hospital because I wanted to. No, obviously not. I would have stayed there whole night if I could have. Yes, of course. But I did not have a choice really. Because obviously, I do want my husband to be okay. To even think otherwise would be evil. But really, I had to take care of Lali. Ah, my daughter…she’s so pretty and so innocent and so quiet…not like those who wail all day and night. Oh, I really wish that my husband liked her.’

She kissed Lali’s cheek as Lali lay in the cradle, peacefully sleeping, sucking her thumb.

‘Ma?’ Her son had returned. He looked tired, much older than 16, his shoulders were stooped and the face drained of all color.

‘How’s your dad?’ She asked handing his son water in a dented aluminum glass.

Ravi sat down on the charpai, drinking down all of the water in one gulp. ‘They had to cut his leg off… said it was crushed beyond repair.
But he’ll live.’ He said that as if he was announcing the time, without a hint of emotions.

‘Oh…’ That is all she could say…taken aback and at a loss of words. She felt ashamed that she wasn’t crying and grieving already. ‘Don’t worry…everything’s going to be fine. With our love and care, he’ll be fine.’ She thought it was the appropriate thing to say.

Ravi sharply turned his head to look at her, wearing an expression of utter incredulity. ‘Love? For him? Right!’ He scoffed.

For a minute, the hut was graveyard silent. Ravi sat there rubbing his eyes with his palm. She wondered if he was just sleepy or if he was fighting back tears. He then looked at her and said, ‘I don’t think you understand what this means? The government is only paying 50,000 rupees for the injured as compared to a lakh for those who died in the building collapse.’ He said the last sentence real slow.

‘How do you think are we going to pay for his medical expenses?’ His voice quivered with emotions now. ‘You’re already working. I am already working. We’re done… for ever.’

She could see his eyes definitely brimming with tears this time. He didn’t look sad however, but his face was red with rage.

‘I wish he was just DEAD!’He said that with such hatred that she thought those words alone would kill. ’Then maybe…I could go back to studying again.’ He stormed out of the hut crying as she stood stunned.

***

The skies resounded with thunder and the clouds poured water in plenty. She went to the doorway to slide the iron sheet shut. That is when she saw him, her husband with a malicious gnarled smile on his face, in the flash of the lightening against the backdrop of the dark of night. Her heart skipped a beat; she backed off as her husband dragged himself into the hut with a crutch in one hand and his wooden leg leaving an impression on the wet earth.

‘Give me the money, sweetness!’ he said, his stretched smile further distorting his scarred face.

‘Wh– what?’, she stammered, her eyes wide with fear.

‘Your money…today is 1st, isn’t it? Give it to me.’ The smile had completely vanished.

‘Wh–why?’ She had begun to shiver.

‘You very well know why!” He wiped his hand over his lips.

‘N-no its for-’

‘Give it to me right now, you sl***** wh***!’ He bellowed, his face was livid with anger.

‘Please…it’s for her medicine!’

‘Her? You dare defy me for her!’ He quickly dragged himself towards her daughters cradle and grabbed her in his free hand like she was a lifeless doll. ‘This-little-piece–of-SH**!’

Her daughter began crying, the wails muffled in the mayhem of the storm and her husband’s heavy panting.

‘Stop it! She’s our daughter for god’s sake!’ She had begun sobbing herself, feeling helpless and tiny.

‘I’ll have nothing to do with this useless piece of junk, you understand?’ He growled, his soaked body shook with rage. He lifted her daughter over his head. ‘Now give me the money- or I drop her!’

‘N-no pleaseee…’ she could taste her salty tears as she began crying profusely now.

‘Before the count of three. One…’

‘Don’t do it, I beg you!’

‘TWO…THR-’

‘WAIT!’ she shrieked. She took the purse out of her blouse with trembling hands and handed over the money to him.

‘Good girl!’ He placed her daughter in the cradle. ‘And now…’ the nasty smile returned, ‘…it’s time for some punishment so you don’t dare defy me again.’ He held the crutch high in the air and gave it a mighty swing.

The air hissed around the crutch as it rushed towards her skull. Just as it was about to make contact, she woke up.

She was sitting on the charpai, sweating and shivering. She looked around. Her son hadn’t returned yet. She began crying. She wasn’t merely crying because of the dream, she was crying because that is what she always did, pitying herself and wishing she wasn’t such a coward that she was.

***

Today, the ward was silent. The crying was elsewhere now. She was sitting besides her husband as he lay there sleeping, with an oxygen mask on his mouth and a bunch of tubes wrapped around his skin.

She liked it when the ward was noisy. The noise kept her distracted; kept all those bad thoughts at bay. But today they were unrelenting, stubborn.

She thought about the nightmares. How her husband beat her for money and sometimes, just because he felt like it.

She thought about how her husband drank off the money she earned, forcing Ravi to work at a tea stall, ruining his childhood. She thought about those tears as Ravi had stormed out of the hut.

She thought about how this man on the bed forced her for another boy. How that man went mad with rage when it was a girl and how he nearly killed her.

She finally saw that man on the bed for what he was, a beast in human flesh. In that moment of clarity, she knew what had to be done.

She looked around and then drew the curtains around the bed. She took a deep breath and pulled the oxygen mask off his face.

He woke up with a start. The machines on the bedside started beeping loudly. His breathing quickened. For a moment, as he looked at her, his eyes had malice and hate. Then they travelled from her hands, which had the mask to her face, which was calm. The eyes grew wide and for the first time she saw fear in them.

He twitched in his bed and coughed. The beeps from the machine were getting quicker. She saw him struggle as he beat his hands on the bed. Then, after a couple of minutes of struggle, his eyes closed and his breathing almost slowed to a halt.

When she had taken the mask off, for a moment she had sensed freedom. But as soon as she had seen him thrashing about his bed, that clarity had subsided. No, she could not take someone’s life. But after all he did, he did NOT deserve to live. She was not the one to decide. No, don’t panic…in a minute or two, it’ll all be over. Stay calm. No…no, she could not do it. God would never forgive her. Think about your son and daughter…they deserve a better life.

She thought about them and somehow stood there, shaking pretty badly. And then his eyes had closed and the breathing almost stopped. That was the moment when she completely panicked. She realized that she could not do it. She quickly placed the mask back on him. Anxiously, she waited…finally letting out a sigh as the beeps slowed down and the breathing became normal again.

***

After the incident, every day she would come to the hospital and sit besides her husband and weave a sweater for Lali. As she would sit there, an image would keep coming back to her. That of his wide terrified eyes.

She often looked at her husband to see if he was watching. He frequently did but never said anything.

On the day of his discharge, she handed over the sweater to him at the doors of the hospital and said, ‘I would really like it if you would put this on Lali.’ He looked at her for a moment and then silently nodded, taking the sweater in his hands.

She smiled as she pushed the wheelchair into the bright sunny morning.

Jack of Hearts
07-02-2012, 04:06 PM
Perfectly willing to engage with this piece. What kind of feedback are you looking for, Nikhar?







J

Pendragon
07-02-2012, 05:07 PM
The setup for the final paragraph is fairly good, actually. A man who is used to terrorizing his family comes to a point where he himself knows terror. I'm wondering if by "Death of a Coward" you are expressing a representation of the old saying "Cowards die every day, a man of courage only once."

I think the story has potential, but polish is needed, I think.

God bless

Pen

Sancho
07-02-2012, 10:08 PM
Hi, Nikhar. I loved your story. In fact I agonized over the decision about whether to vote for yours or for the Shanti story in the competition. I suppose, at the time, I was just more in the mood for the dragon tale. That is little consolation, I know, and also gets to the heart of the problem in rank ordering art – it’s not linear.

At any rate, I liked the main idea, and I particularly liked the vividness of the first scene.

The cool thing about being eliminated in an elimination round is that you get to write another story. I’ll look forward to reading it.

Nikhar
07-03-2012, 12:21 AM
Perfectly willing to engage with this piece. What kind of feedback are you looking for, Nikhar?

J

An honest one. :)
And a detailed one :P (Haha, i know I'm greedy :D)
I love criticisms about my piece as long as they are constructive and I can't stress enough about how insanely helpful critiques here on litnet have been for me. :)






The setup for the final paragraph is fairly good, actually. A man who is used to terrorizing his family comes to a point where he himself knows terror. I'm wondering if by "Death of a Coward" you are expressing a representation of the old saying "Cowards die every day, a man of courage only once."

I think the story has potential, but polish is needed, I think.

God bless

Pen

Firstly thanks a lot Pen for your opinion. :)
The saying most definitely came to my mind and I was going to keep that as a title then I went against it since I thought it might become too long. 'Death of a Coward' was more symbolic than physical. It meant how the coward within the women died.


Hi, Nikhar. I loved your story. In fact I agonized over the decision about whether to vote for yours or for the Shanti story in the competition. I suppose, at the time, I was just more in the mood for the dragon tale. That is little consolation, I know, and also gets to the heart of the problem in rank ordering art – it’s not linear.

At any rate, I liked the main idea, and I particularly liked the vividness of the first scene.

The cool thing about being eliminated in an elimination round is that you get to write another story. I’ll look forward to reading it.

Thanks a lot for your opinion Sancho. I'm really glad that you liked it. :)
And yeah, that is the best thing about being eliminated. I just hope though that I can write another story before August. I am too lazy. :P

Another good thing about getting eliminated is that I get the opinions on my story much earlier. :D

---
P.S.- I expect there to be a lot of grammatical errors in the story, particularly punctuations. I was never good at grammar.

Snowqueen
07-04-2012, 07:46 AM
Nikhar, I liked your story because I found the element of realism in it. The way you described the sufferings and the hardships of a poor family living in sub- continent is quite remarkable. Unfortunately it’s mostly women who have to go through a lot while living in this part of this world. I also liked your narrative style. it’s simple and easy to grasp.
Experts have already expressed their opinions in the above posts and I hope it will help you in the future.

I wish you best of luck. Keep on writing and thanks for the updates.

Nikhar
07-04-2012, 10:24 AM
Nikhar, I liked your story because I found the element of realism in it. The way you described the sufferings and the hardships of a poor family living in sub- continent is quite remarkable. Unfortunately it’s mostly women who have to go through a lot while living in this part of this world. I also liked your narrative style. it’s simple and easy to grasp.
Experts have already expressed their opinions in the above posts and I hope it will help you in the future.

I wish you best of luck. Keep on writing and thanks for the updates.

Thanks Snowqueen. :) I'm glad that you liked it.
And yeah, the situation is pretty bad. But slowly maybe, but we are taking steps in the right direction. One T.V. show is already making a great impact. :)

aliengirl
07-06-2012, 03:30 AM
Hi Nikhar, :)
I’m very sorry, I’m a bit late in my response. There were some relatives visiting us and in their presence it was not possible to give your well-written story a fair critique. Please note that whatever I’m going to say is my personal opinion and my opinions may not have great literary merit. I often judge any story or poem by how I respond to it, if it holds not only my attention but can sway my imagination too. Of late I’ve come to appreciate the flow and rhythm of the words too; the beauty of a well-crafted sentence or metaphor can make me like a story even if the plot is loosely knit or the theme is as old as the Ganges itself. So please keep in mind my own method of criticism from which you are quite free to differ.
When I read your story for the first time, I smiled because the theme is so familiar. But as I read on it was a pleasant surprise to see that you’ve not fallen in the usual ranks of pessimists. You have inserted some interesting twists and turns and to top it all the story ends on a positive note. Redemption from hatred and fear; of the man as well as the woman. So my friend, it is a good story, with a few surprises in its pocket. But there were places where I felt a lack of some important details. (I’m aware of the word constraint in the competition. Let’s ignore it for a while.) Here we go.


She stood at the entrance of the general ward for a few moments, hesitant to enter because of the blood, the crowd and the chaos.

[ Don’t you think something is missing here? Yes, the familiar smell of a hospital ward. Think of a hospital or a dispensary and then you can almost smell it.]


She became really anxious…why was nobody treating him? She looked around, sweating profusely now, worried that she might have to return into the crowd to search for a free doctor.

[You may like to elaborate this. Basically you want to say that she feels anxious because nobody is treating her husband and goes in search of a doctor. Just deliver it slowly; it gets over so quickly that I failed to sympathize with her in her distress.]

...her voice sounded like that of a sparrow at a dhobi ghaat, out of place and barely audible.

[Funny choice of imagery, yet not so funny when I recalled Dhobi Ghat directed by Kiran Rao. This memory triggered a chain reaction. What was the relationship between the female protagonist and her husband who never appears on-screen? Whatever it was, it was marked with FEAR. A very subtle and ingenious allusion, Nikhar. And yes, how can anyone miss that the theme of the story relates so much with the T.V. show brought to us by Rao's husband?]


She thanked her neighbors for taking care of her daughter and entered one of the many huts on the roadside, each of which was walled and roofed by thin corrugated iron sheets, undistinguishable from the others except for the advertisement poster of a local toothpaste brand taped onto the metal. After the hospital, her small hut made her pretty comfortable.

[After the solid and detailed opening section this paragraph seems a bit hurried. ( I know, you’ve to count the words.) I think breaking it in smaller sentences and rearranging would be better.]


She quietly laid her daughter in the wooden cradle and smiled for the first time in the day. She gently began rocking it.
‘I hope Ravi is able to manage everything in the hospital. It’s a pity he does not like his father. ... Ah, my daughter…she’s so pretty and so innocent and so quiet…not like those who wail all day and night. Oh, I really wish that my husband liked her.’
She kissed Lali’s cheek as Lali lay in the cradle, peacefully sleeping, sucking her thumb.

[ I like the way you brought out conflicting thoughts flitting through her mind. Just a small point. Have you ever seen real babies asleep? They don’t suck thumbs in sleep, at least not those I’ve seen. As you’re writing a realistic story, it’d be better to avoid these minor slips.]


The skies resounded with thunder and the clouds poured water in plenty. She went to the doorway to slide the iron sheet shut. That is when she saw him, her husband with a malicious gnarled smile on his face, in the flash of the lightening against the backdrop of the dark of night.
...
She was sitting on the charpai, sweating and shivering. She looked around. Her son hadn’t returned yet. She began crying. She wasn’t merely crying because of the dream, she was crying because that is what she always did, pitying herself and wishing she wasn’t such a coward that she was.

[A nightmare is a better device than flashbacks IMO. Much more powerful and motivating for further developments. I liked this part of the story very much.]


Today, the ward was silent. The crying was elsewhere now. She was sitting besides her husband...


[A little grammatical error. Besides means-
1. Making an additional point; anyway (adverb)
2. In addition to; as well as (preposition)

I assume you didn’t use 'Besides' in the above two senses. Beside is the correct word here which means-
1. Next to, at the side of (preposition)]

Well, this is my take so far. Right now, I hear someone calling me. I'll get back to you with the second half soon. Hope whatever I've offered helps. :)

Steven Hunley
07-07-2012, 04:22 PM
So yes, there were some minor things I'd change and re-wording, but I'm not going to sweat the small stuff. The tone of this is fantastic, and the realism is gut-level realism, and that's what I like. These are hard issues to deal with and I think you've dealt with them, shall I say it? REALISTICALLY!!!

It's the kind of a piece makes me glad I'm a member here. The last reconciliation is my favorite part, of all the various ways you could have ended the piece you've chosen this one, and it's full of humanity and resolve. Good stuff!

Nikhar
07-08-2012, 12:57 AM
Hi aliengirl, first of all, thanks a lot for your response. :)




Please note that whatever I’m going to say is my personal opinion and my opinions may not have great literary merit. I often judge any story or poem by how I respond to it, if it holds not only my attention but can sway my imagination too. Of late I’ve come to appreciate the flow and rhythm of the words too; the beauty of a well-crafted sentence or metaphor can make me like a story even if the plot is loosely knit or the theme is as old as the Ganges itself. So please keep in mind my own method of criticism from which you are quite free to differ.


All kinds of opinions are helpful to me and I'm really thankful that you took time to comment on it. :)




She stood at the entrance of the general ward for a few moments, hesitant to enter because of the blood, the crowd and the chaos.

[ Don’t you think something is missing here? Yes, the familiar smell of a hospital ward. Think of a hospital or a dispensary and then you can almost smell it.]

Yeah, I know the smell you're talking about. I have always thought that half of the times its the smell that makes those people sick and not the disease. :p
But it wasn't the smell that made her anxious. It was the blood and the crowd.


She became really anxious…why was nobody treating him? She looked around, sweating profusely now, worried that she might have to return into the crowd to search for a free doctor.

[You may like to elaborate this. Basically you want to say that she feels anxious because nobody is treating her husband and goes in search of a doctor. Just deliver it slowly; it gets over so quickly that I failed to sympathize with her in her distress.]

Yeah, I see your point. But there was the word limit. :(


...her voice sounded like that of a sparrow at a dhobi ghaat, out of place and barely audible.

[Funny choice of imagery, yet not so funny when I recalled Dhobi Ghat directed by Kiran Rao. This memory triggered a chain reaction. What was the relationship between the female protagonist and her husband who never appears on-screen? Whatever it was, it was marked with FEAR. A very subtle and ingenious allusion, Nikhar. And yes, how can anyone miss that the theme of the story relates so much with the T.V. show brought to us by Rao's husband?]


Haha....you make me look so intelligent. Maybe it was a funny choice of imagery afterall 'coz as it turns out, I haven't seen Dhobi Ghaat, just a wild wild coincidence that there should be a relation.





She quietly laid her daughter in the wooden cradle and smiled for the first time in the day. She gently began rocking it.
‘I hope Ravi is able to manage everything in the hospital. It’s a pity he does not like his father. ... Ah, my daughter…she’s so pretty and so innocent and so quiet…not like those who wail all day and night. Oh, I really wish that my husband liked her.’
She kissed Lali’s cheek as Lali lay in the cradle, peacefully sleeping, sucking her thumb.

[ I like the way you brought out conflicting thoughts flitting through her mind. Just a small point. Have you ever seen real babies asleep? They don’t suck thumbs in sleep, at least not those I’ve seen. As you’re writing a realistic story, it’d be better to avoid these minor slips.]

Oh, I always assumed that they sucked thumb whenever they could, after all thats all they can do on their own. :P



The skies resounded with thunder and the clouds poured water in plenty. She went to the doorway to slide the iron sheet shut. That is when she saw him, her husband with a malicious gnarled smile on his face, in the flash of the lightening against the backdrop of the dark of night.
...
She was sitting on the charpai, sweating and shivering. She looked around. Her son hadn’t returned yet. She began crying. She wasn’t merely crying because of the dream, she was crying because that is what she always did, pitying herself and wishing she wasn’t such a coward that she was.

[A nightmare is a better device than flashbacks IMO. Much more powerful and motivating for further developments. I liked this part of the story very much.]

Thanks. :)



Today, the ward was silent. The crying was elsewhere now. She was sitting besides her husband...


[A little grammatical error. Besides means-
1. Making an additional point; anyway (adverb)
2. In addition to; as well as (preposition)

I assume you didn’t use 'Besides' in the above two senses. Beside is the correct word here which means-
1. Next to, at the side of (preposition)]

Well, this is my take so far. Right now, I hear someone calling me. I'll get back to you with the second half soon. Hope whatever I've offered helps. :)

Thanks for pointing out the grammar mistake. I make a lot of errors. :(

Waiting for the second half. :)


So yes, there were some minor things I'd change and re-wording, but I'm not going to sweat the small stuff. The tone of this is fantastic, and the realism is gut-level realism, and that's what I like. These are hard issues to deal with and I think you've dealt with them, shall I say it? REALISTICALLY!!!

Firstly, thanks a lot Steven for taking the time to read it and comment upon it. :) I'm really glad that you liked it.


It's the kind of a piece makes me glad I'm a member here.
You made my day Steven! That's like the greatest compliment I've ever got. :D



The last reconciliation is my favorite part, of all the various ways you could have ended the piece you've chosen this one, and it's full of humanity and resolve. Good stuff!

When I had first thought of the story, I had thought about killing the husband off. But then, I realized that the current ending would be much more in character and powerful.

aliengirl
07-08-2012, 02:53 PM
Hi aliengirl, first of all, thanks a lot for your response. :)



You're most welcome Nikhar. :) I was somewhat afraid that I'd sound like a pedant pointing out minor slips in your powerful story. But then you were looking for an honest opinion. I just tried to tell you what I liked and what can be re-touched. Thankfully I didn't invite your wrath. :D



Haha....you make me look so intelligent. Maybe it was a funny choice of imagery afterall 'coz as it turns out, I haven't seen Dhobi Ghaat, just a wild wild coincidence that there should be a relation.

Hmmm...which means that someone else is also intelligent...no? :p BTW, this was a little attempt at finding intertextuality. I love that concept and often try to find a connection between different works of fiction where there are apparently none. Sometimes I find links where the author did not put it knowingly. That's part of the game. :)


Oh, I always assumed that they sucked thumb whenever they could, after all thats all they can do on their own. :P


I would not have noticed it but recently I spent much time with a little baby. The memory of my three month old nephew is quite fresh in my mind. That's why I took notice and despite the serious theme I laughed. :D


Thanks for pointing out the grammar mistake. I make a lot of errors. :(

Welcome again! You are an excellent writer and you'll get over these errors very soon. :nod:



When I had first thought of the story, I had thought about killing the husband off. But then, I realized that the current ending would be much more in character and powerful.

That's where the power of a writer lies. You chose the best possible option.


I promised to tell you more about your story later. Actually I've dealt with more than half of it. The second last part where she tries to kill her husband is well-crafted and so is the last one. Just a small pedantic detail -

After the incident, every day she would come to the hospital and sit besides her husband and weave a sweater for Lali.

I always thought that one knits a sweater. Is 'weave' used in this context?

That's all Nikhar. I'd be happy to be of any help in future. :)

Nikhar
07-09-2012, 07:46 AM
You're most welcome Nikhar. :) I was somewhat afraid that I'd sound like a pedant pointing out minor slips in your powerful story. But then you were looking for an honest opinion. I just tried to tell you what I liked and what can be re-touched. Thankfully I didn't invite your wrath. :D

Look at this baby face...do you think it is capable of showing wrath? :p :D




I promised to tell you more about your story later. Actually I've dealt with more than half of it. The second last part where she tries to kill her husband is well-crafted and so is the last one. Just a small pedantic detail -

After the incident, every day she would come to the hospital and sit besides her husband and weave a sweater for Lali.

I always thought that one knits a sweater. Is 'weave' used in this context?

That's all Nikhar. I'd be happy to be of any help in future. :)

Thanks again for your time aliengirl. :) And now that you've said it, I will trouble you in future. :p :D

aliengirl
07-10-2012, 12:52 PM
Look at this baby face...do you think it is capable of showing wrath? :p :D

Awww...No, certainly not. That's a lovely face, so cute. :)

You're welcome Nikhar. I like friends who trouble me often. At least they remember me in that way. :p :D

cafolini
07-10-2012, 06:59 PM
This conveys your purpose. Obviously, he's the coward. But there is a difficult problem that doesn't get resolved. You are capable of sacrificing your baby, your son and yoursef and you want to sell the idea that it is all in the name of not taking anyone's life. And on top of it, you want to be the coward? Is it not so?

DocHeart
07-12-2012, 03:06 PM
Dear Nikhar,

Thanks for sharing this, and for inviting me to comment.

I think what you have here is a strong story. The theme of domestic violence (be it physical or otherwise) is always relevant and interesting, independently of geographical or cultural considerations. The discrimination against female children by some parents, too, which often leads to injustice and cruelty, lends itself to powerful narratives. And the mother's struggle with the idea of killing her tyrant of a husband can generate plenty of discussion regarding the nature of what is right and what is wrong.

But I think the story in itself lacks polish. It reads as though you put it together in haste, always rushing to jump to the next scene. One result of this is that the flow is often abruptly interrupted, and the reader has to go back and re-read in order to grasp the passing of time:




‘I hope Ravi is able to manage everything in the hospital. It’s a pity he does not like his father. I wish he did. But can I blame him? He hasn’t really had the best of childhood. At 16, he is already so much more mature. Maybe I shouldn’t have left him at the hospital alone. Not that I don’t trust him. He’s a wonderful son. But maybe, it’s too much for him? Well, I didn’t exactly have a choice, did I? Had to feed Lali too…she’s so frail anyways. I did not come back from the hospital because I wanted to. No, obviously not. I would have stayed there whole night if I could have. Yes, of course. But I did not have a choice really. Because obviously, I do want my husband to be okay. To even think otherwise would be evil. But really, I had to take care of Lali. Ah, my daughter…she’s so pretty and so innocent and so quiet…not like those who wail all day and night. Oh, I really wish that my husband liked her.’

She kissed Lali’s cheek as Lali lay in the cradle, peacefully sleeping, sucking her thumb.

‘Ma?’ Her son had returned. He looked tired, much older than 16, his shoulders were stooped and the face drained of all color.


We learn that the son is at his father's bedside in hospital, and then suddenly he comes in. How long has it been? The mother starts her monologue by wishing that the son "manages everything in the hospital" (what is it that he has to manage exactly?), giving the impression that we won't see him for a while. And then, in the next paragraph, he appears. How long does the mother's monologue last? It feels to me as though a whole paragraph is missing here, one to take me from one scene to the next, making me aware of the passage of time. It doesn't need to be a long paragraph, either. Words are magical. A few of them can make the reader feel many hours have elapsed. Something along the lines of "Such were the thoughts that accompanied her gentle rocking of Lali's crib. They persisted through the early evening, as she watched her daughter sleep calmly."

There is another thing that bugs me about this monologue. When it starts, I'm imagining the mother talking quietly as she cares for her daughter. When she refers to the daughter in the third person ("I had to feed Lali, too"), I'm completely thrown. Who is she talking to? This would have been much smoother had she said "I had to feed you, too" instead. As it is, it's another thing that makes me go hey wait, what's going on here?

There are also a couple of points where sentences sound clumsy, written in a hurry without ever being revisited for a quick edit. I found this the most jarring:





He was breathing but only barely. His body was heavily bandaged except his legs which was weird because it was his legs that looked the funniest. The legs were heavily scarred and there was a grisly purple blotch beneath the knee on one of the legs.



Too many legs, man! :) Think how much more pleasant this would have been to read if you had gone back and edited some limbs out:

He was breathing, but only barely. His body was heavily bandaged except his legs. Funnily enough, though, they looked the worst. They were badly scarred, and there was a grisly purple blotch beneath the knee on one of them.

And in the end, I don't quite understand the happy ending. She tries to kill him but can't go through with it. Fine so far. And then, in the next paragraph, she wheels him out of the hospital with a smile on her face. What did I miss? Did he become aware of her attempt to murder him? Did this make him fear what she's capable of? I would have thought that such a bully would be doubly angered after such a challenge to his reign and come back worse than ever. What is it that happens to change him? And why won't you tell us? :)

In all, I think this has the potential to become much, much better. You have the makings of a very decent story here. Just going over it again once and making a few edits would improve it. I hope you do it, and share the result with us.

Thank you again for sharing, Nikhar. And please, don't misunderstand my criticism -- I did enjoy your story, and hope to read more from you soon.

Best regards,
DH

Nikhar
07-13-2012, 04:47 AM
This conveys your purpose. Obviously, he's the coward. But there is a difficult problem that doesn't get resolved. You are capable of sacrificing your baby, your son and yoursef and you want to sell the idea that it is all in the name of not taking anyone's life. And on top of it, you want to be the coward? Is it not so?

Hi, first of all thanks for reading the story. :)
As I thought more and more about the plot, I wanted it to be character driven. She was inherently a coward. That's why she endured her husband for this long. She wanted to kill him then at the hospital but her courage once again deserted her. The reason that she could even make an attempt at taking his life was because of her children. Only she couldn't go through with it.


Dear Nikhar,
We learn that the son is at his father's bedside in hospital, and then suddenly he comes in. How long has it been? The mother starts her monologue by wishing that the son "manages everything in the hospital" (what is it that he has to manage exactly?), giving the impression that we won't see him for a while. And then, in the next paragraph, he appears. How long does the mother's monologue last? It feels to me as though a whole paragraph is missing here, one to take me from one scene to the next, making me aware of the passage of time. It doesn't need to be a long paragraph, either. Words are magical. A few of them can make the reader feel many hours have elapsed. Something along the lines of "Such were the thoughts that accompanied her gentle rocking of Lali's crib. They persisted through the early evening, as she watched her daughter sleep calmly."


Hi DocHeart, firstly thanks a lot for reading the story and taking the time to comment on it. :)
Yes, I see what you mean and I agree that its a completely valid point. In fact, when I was writing it I thought that this might be a problem but I just couldn't come up with the right words at the time. Thanks for pointing it out.


There is another thing that bugs me about this monologue. When it starts, I'm imagining the mother talking quietly as she cares for her daughter. When she refers to the daughter in the third person ("I had to feed Lali, too"), I'm completely thrown. Who is she talking to? This would have been much smoother had she said "I had to feed you, too" instead. As it is, it's another thing that makes me go hey wait, what's going on here?

Actually she was thinking and not actually speaking. Maybe I should've put it without quotes and italicized it.


There are also a couple of points where sentences sound clumsy, written in a hurry without ever being revisited for a quick edit. I found this the most jarring:




Too many legs, man! :) Think how much more pleasant this would have been to read if you had gone back and edited some limbs out:

He was breathing, but only barely. His body was heavily bandaged except his legs. Funnily enough, though, they looked the worst. They were badly scarred, and there was a grisly purple blotch beneath the knee on one of them.


Yes, your sentence indeed sounds much better. :)



And in the end, I don't quite understand the happy ending. She tries to kill him but can't go through with it. Fine so far. And then, in the next paragraph, she wheels him out of the hospital with a smile on her face. What did I miss? Did he become aware of her attempt to murder him? Did this make him fear what she's capable of? I would have thought that such a bully would be doubly angered after such a challenge to his reign and come back worse than ever. What is it that happens to change him? And why won't you tell us? :)

Yes, he did become aware of her attempt. I thought the following lines in the story made that clear.


For a moment, as he looked at her, his eyes had malice and hate. Then they travelled from her hands, which had the mask to her face, which was calm. The eyes grew wide and for the first time she saw fear in them.

Why did he improve and not become worse than before? He did not have legs anymore. He was crippled for life and dependent on others.



She smiled as she pushed the wheelchair into the bright sunny morning.

I had meant this last line to convey a lot indirectly. I don't know the term for it (metaphor? allegory?). 'She pushed the wheelchair' had meant to imply how she now had a hold over her husband and how she now controlled him and how her husband was now dependent on her. 'Into the bright sunny morning' was a maybe cliched reference to her new bright life.
But I guess maybe it was too vague.






In all, I think this has the potential to become much, much better. You have the makings of a very decent story here. Just going over it again once and making a few edits would improve it. I hope you do it, and share the result with us.

Thank you again for sharing, Nikhar. And please, don't misunderstand my criticism -- I did enjoy your story, and hope to read more from you soon.

Best regards,
DH

I'll sure revise it and then bug you once again for your comments. :p

And thanks a lot again for your response.:)

Jack of Hearts
07-14-2012, 03:03 AM
Nikhar,

Having come at this piece no less than four times now, this reader has decided he will not freelance you a critique. But, if you'd like, he will discuss this piece with you and/or attempt to answer any questions you pose about it- either here in the thread or through PM.






J

mona amon
07-21-2012, 11:52 PM
Hi Nihar!

I liked your story the best, and voted for it. I think it's really good, especially the optimistic ending (as optimistic as it can be for a woman in her circumstances). However, I don't have any idea how to do a 'criticism' so I won't try that.

Keep writing, Good Luck!

Nikhar
07-25-2012, 08:29 AM
Nikhar,

Having come at this piece no less than four times now, this reader has decided he will not freelance you a critique. But, if you'd like, he will discuss this piece with you and/or attempt to answer any questions you pose about it- either here in the thread or through PM.






J

Thanks for reading the story Jack. :)


Hi Nihar!

I liked your story the best, and voted for it. I think it's really good, especially the optimistic ending (as optimistic as it can be for a woman in her circumstances). However, I don't have any idea how to do a 'criticism' so I won't try that.

Keep writing, Good Luck!

Thanks a lot for reading the story mona. :) I'm glad you liked it. :D