PDA

View Full Version : Just Me and You



Nikhar
01-06-2011, 10:37 AM
This is the short story I had submitted for the short story competition.
Each criticism helps me improve as a writer. So, I'd be really grateful if you could take the time to comment on it.

------------------------------------------------

Just me and you

Amidst the uproar of this storm, there is a pressing silence… a void, bereft of her voice. Voice of the only girl I ever loved and the only one who ever loved me. Her reticence is dispensing me to an eternal abyss of pain. Each silent moment that is passing is growing upon me, biting me into pieces, tearing me further and further apart.

I look out through the windows. There stands the magnificent tree, silhouetted against the black night, overshadowing everything in its vicinity. It had stood strong, just like our relationship, her and mine. But this recent storm challenged its subsistence. The demented winds mock at its defenses, savagely thrashing against it. The tree is bending under the force of the storm. It seems to collapse. But, surely, I couldn’t let it happen.

She is sitting there, in the corner, dry tears etched upon her ashen face, enveloped in a miasma of despondence. How much has she changed in less than a day! The lively blush has transformed into ghostly pallor. Her stooping self is in stark contrast to her spirited portrait on the wall. Her eyes, her beautiful watery eyes have turned so hollow. She is currently staring at me and yet she seems to stare past me.

I crawl my way to her and put my arms around her. But she pulls back violently. ‘Don’t….Don’t you touch me!’ she shrieks, her voice faltering with emotions. She wouldn’t talk to me; she wouldn’t let me comfort her. Never before has she behaved in such a manner.

‘But didi-’

‘Don’t - you – dare… don’t you dare call me your sister. It’s over… it’s all over!’

Over? The relation that we had wreathed with such care, with such affection, with such love… how could it be over? We had faced storms before. The tree had knocked back each adversity that dared to challenge it. When our parents died, she was the only person I had. She took care of me like no one could have. She for me was not only my sister, but my mother, my father, my complete family condensed into one. With each day that had passed, the tree had grown sturdier, stronger.

Obviously, there were stones thrown at it. Unwanted dark shadows often lurked around it. When I had fits or when I was partly asleep, I heard whispers… words from the devils. Those fiends murmured, ‘Oh, poor child, how she has wrecked her life because of her retard brother’…. ‘Asylum… the only thing that would do him and her world of good!’… ‘He is crazy…..talks of some tree outside that doesn’t even exist!’

The tree did not exist! How cruel, how inhuman of someone to say that! But it did not matter, my sister believed in the tree. She said that she believed in it if I believed in it. And that was enough for me. The tree stood stronger.

Everything ran perfectly… until…until he came in our lives like a torrent ruining everything. I remember the day when he came… but I don’t know why he came. Maybe that grumpy Aunt of ours sent him. I never liked that old woman…said all sorts of wicked things. She thought I was responsible for containing my sister’s life inside one house. She thought I deprived my sister of any love life. Argh… how much I hated her! Soon, though, the poor old hog was reported dead. She was found beaten to pulp by some rogues. Good that she’s dead now.

When my sister had let him in our house for the first time, there was a smile on her face…it was a weird one. For the first time, I did not like to see her smile. I think it was that smile which encouraged him to come again… and again…. and again. He was unusually friendly towards me (in the beginning)… and maybe that’s what drew my sister towards him.

Sometimes he came to our place, sometimes she went out with him. I hadn’t realized her absence for the first few days. Maybe, she chose her time carefully, when I was asleep.

I did not mind it so much initially. The tree remained practically unaltered in the beginning. But it slowly began to shed its leaves. She began to become more careless. She remained out for longer times of the day. She returned late. Our only-me-and-my-sister times disappeared somewhere.

And that guy didn’t make anything easier for me. That sweetness was as fake as Santa. Oh, he was so cruel, so evil! I remember how he used to give me those wicked satanic smiles when he took my sister out. How couldn’t my sister get it? I tried to explain her that he wasn’t the right guy. But I think she even stopped listening to me. He was in our house even when he wasn’t.

I only suspected it initially, but then I became sure, he was a wizard… a bad, bad wizard. Enchanting my sister, he was slowly drawing her into a world which wasn’t made for her… a world which did not have me.

And then a week before, what happened had not happened before. She forgot to give me my medicines. Insane pain had seared through me, scorching my insides, turning me inside out. For a moment, I was in mid air, in a fog of darkness, all alone. I was drowning in that void, suffocating, unable to breathe. I threw my arms around wildly, hoping that a hand… her hand would get hold of me, and pull me out. But the hand never came for me. And I continued to writhe, leaping from oblivion to oblivion. Then, there was silence…

I heard the doctors say that I had nearly died. And I think they were true. As for the first time, I had experienced a fear which knew no bounds, a fear that engulfed me whole. Fear of losing her.

I think that incident really disturbed her. The first night she cried a lot. She said she was really sorry. She caressed my hair with those delicate hands of her and we traveled back in the past, to the wonderful times we had. She did not want to leave me but the doctor instructed so.

Her care and the doctor’s medicines worked wonders and I was out of the hospital in two days. Her guy had not come to meet her since the night I had my fit. But she did not seem to care. All she cared for was me. I had my sister back. The tree began blooming again.

The tree would have continued to grow stronger had it not been for this doomed storm which struck the tree so hard today. Two cops came at our place in the morning. With them they brought a huge stretcher covered by a white cloth. It smelled bad… really really bad. One of the cops pushed the cloth aside. I don’t think I have seen anything more horrible, more terrifying than what lay on that stretcher. It was a grotesque dead body, or rather what remained of a body, twisted at bizarre angles. The face was hardly human with patches of red all over; it was badly quashed. Yet, somehow, it was very easy to put a name to that face.

My sister screamed. Her legs joggled under the shock and she was on the floor on all fours. She began to cry hysterically. I think she had identified the dead body too. It was her guy’s body.

She seemed devastated. She lay on my lap and cried and cried. Obviously, I did not like to see her this way. I tried to reassure her in every possible manner. I took her to our buoyant memory lanes. I reminded her how she was my only source of strength and support. I reminded her that she still had me. I told her that she’d get much better guys. But she cried and cried. I talked of our parents. I talked of this. I talked of that. But she cried…and cried. And I think that was what frustrated me. I think that was what made me say what maybe I shouldn’t have.

‘Isn’t it good that he’s dead? He was so evil. How couldn’t you see it? With him out of our lives, it’s just you and me again.’

She raised her head and stared at me with an expressionless face. She backed off to the other corner and sat there…for a long, long time.


Whenever I tried to comfort her, put my arms around her, she pulled back. She wouldn’t let me touch her, let me come near her. And now, she even said that our relation was over!

‘Don’t - you – dare… don’t you dare call me your sister. It’s over… it’s all over!’

‘Over…?’ I falter.

‘Yes… OVER!’ There is a brief silence that seems to last an epoch. She continues, ‘Where did I go wrong? WHERE? From where did you gather all that hatred? From where did you gather all this malice, this enmity? Did I not teach you to love everyone? Did I not tell you that you and me were inseparable? Did I ever teach you to hate anyone? Did I ever teach you to… to kill anyone?’

Ah… so she knows. But then she must understand. She must understand all that I did was for her. She would have never been happy with him. She could not be happy without me. That old Aunt of ours and this devil of hers were drawing me away from her. They could not do anyone any good when they were alive. Surely, then, they should have died. I had a lot of fun smashing the brass spittoon onto her head. I banged it again and again. She had to pay for each thing she said and she was paying back indeed… with her blood. With him, it was even easier. Why, I already had practice.

I had much fun then but I don’t find it funny now. I did all that I did so that she and me would be together. But now I realize how wrong I had been. He had taken her away when he was alive; he has taken her even further away now that he’s dead. With his end was my beginning, I had thought, but how little had I known that with his beginning had commenced my end.

I chance a look outside the window. The gale has gone insane now. The tree is swaying wildly. It could fall any moment now. I have to stop it… I have to!

‘Di…DI! The tree… it’s about to fall! Would you do nothing?’ I look at her with pleading eyes, with one last request.

‘Tree…THERE’S NO SUCH TREE! YOU UNDERSTAND, NO - SUCH - TREE!’ She stands and runs out of the room.

Suddenly, outside, there’s a huge crash. I look out. On the ground, lies the tree, dead… if it ever lived.

Nikhar
01-06-2011, 10:49 AM
I'd like to add a few things. I wrote this story back in March. I watched Psycho later in the year in August. And I realized that the motives of my narrator and the guy in the movie were so similar. WTH!

Anyways, after I read the story again, I came across a few errors.

This for examplke:-

I look out through the windows. There stands the magnificent tree, silhouetted against the black night, overshadowing everything in its vicinity.

I guess, if its pitch black, there's no sense of overshadowing something.

As I've already said, I'd be really grateful if you could take time to comment on it.

Another thing, I used the title in a hurry. Couldn't think of anything. Do suggest me one.

hillwalker
01-06-2011, 12:12 PM
Do you really want to know what’s wrong with this story?

Well, as it stands this has a promising plot but you have handled it rather badly and your writing does not do your readers justice.

There are numerous typos that will go against you when entering a piece into competition. One would expect the writer to present something fit for publication but this has all the appearance of a hastily written first-draft.

I should also point out that 50% of your piece could be trimmed away without changing much in the way of the plot. The pace could certainly do with a prod as it grinds to a halt far too often – either with tiresome internalised dialogue or with sloppy overwriting.

And there is far too much repetition – of statements and of certain phrases. I’m guessing some of this in intentional. But it spoils the overall nature of the piece and makes it look as if you haven’t taken any trouble to edit it at all.


I did not mind it so much initially….
I only suspected it initially…..

These are two paragraph openings in the space of three paragraphs – if you had edited it you would presumably have noticed.

And can you not see for yourself what a mess this following sentence is?


And then a week before, what happened had not happened before.

In a nutshell there’s far too much here that needs putting right for me to go through it paragraph by paragraph, but just to give you a few more pointers –

para 1:

Right from the opening line you are presenting your reader with conflicting images.


Amidst the uproar of this storm, there is a pressing silence…

‘amidst the uproar’ suggests the ‘pressing silence’ is actually part of the uproar. If instead you wrote ‘At the heart of the storm there is a pressing silence’ it would make more sense and make the reader become more curious.

The rest of this paragraph is horribly over-written, filled with such melodramaa that it’s not going to appeal to anyone other than perhaps some 13-year-old teenage girls desperate for a slushy romance. And you’re likely to alienate even these readers with sentences like


Her reticence is dispensing me to an eternal abyss of pain.

Yeugh.

And you continue to overwrite even though the story does improve slightly…..


enveloped in a miasma of despondence…… Her stooping self….. The relation that we had wreathed with such care, with such affection, with such love…

Every time you write stuff like this all the tension and pace is taken away from the story. It’s like reading a text book not a work of fiction. You should practice writing in plain English - keep things short and simple is always best.


I took her to our buoyant memory lanes.

what are ‘buoyant memory lanes’?? It just makes no sense,
and the 'cops' would be unlikely to bring a dead body on a stretcher into someone’s house for it to be identified so again you lost me there.

You need to read a lot more. You need to concentrate on expressing things more clearly. And after writing a story, lay it aside for a few weeks then go back to read it again and use a red pen to scratch out anything that looks wrong or doesn't help the story move forwards.

H

Nikhar
01-06-2011, 08:30 PM
Heya hill, firstly thanks a lot for your comments.

And i have to say that i do agree with a lot of what you've said. When i first thought of the plot, i thought it could be outstanding. When i actually began writing it, i realized that it had not come as good as i had wanted to it at all. By the time i finished it, i became extremely tired with it and just couldn't bring myself to go through it once more. And march was nearing to a close, i decided to submit it for April elimination as it was. To my utmost surprise, i won that particular elimination. When there were just about 2 days remaining for the poll to close and my story leading, i asked Scher if i could withdraw the story, she thought it would not be good sportsman spirit and i agreed. So i decided to let it be.

Anyways, when i reread the story, i realized that it was not just 'not good enough' , it was actually bad. And when i read your comment now, i actually understand how terrible it is.

Even i realized that i had over dramatized the things a lot. The other stories that i wrote were rather simple and i guess thats the reason they got the bit of acclaim that they did.

And thanks for pointing out the structural errors. I dont think i'd have spotted them.

I think I would want to write this story again because i still think that the plot has a lot of potential (neglecting the facts that the motives are scarily similar to the ones used in 'psycho'). I'll do that when i get time which unfortunately doesnt happen until june this year.

hillwalker
01-06-2011, 08:33 PM
As I said - it's a good plot, but you've admitted yourself that it rather ran away with you.

best of luck when (and if) you ever do get around to revising it.

H

arrytus
01-06-2011, 11:45 PM
Hillwalker gives unnerving critiques I've realized. I'm scared to show him anything but as it stands his opinion is the one I'd want cuz I know he's blunt.

But where I disagree is 'overwriting' as applied to 'big' words or fanciful expression. People are not so accepting of 'exceptional' styles and I for one have no problem with you trying out phrases like 'buoyant memory lanes' or trying to be perhaps more poetic than the conception can handle. It's better to fail by your own standards. I for one have phases where I will only write with sesquipedalian words, reader be damned if they don't comprehend them. But editing is almost a harder skill than writing, as it can be difficult to read something we wrote and not simply be contented in some way by the fact that it was our own creation. And often poetics don't hold up overtime as we lose the purpose or influence we had intended and in trying to amend it's delicate structure we simply crush it.

And I actually liked your story 2nd best among the proffered.

hillwalker
01-07-2011, 12:22 PM
Hillwalker gives unnerving critiques I've realized. I'm scared to show him anything but as it stands his opinion is the one I'd want cuz I know he's blunt.

A hammer encased in velvet, I assure you. So please - feel free to post.

I do agree with what you say about 'over-writing' - a little originality of expression is welcome. But sometimes writers insist on saying the same thing two, three or four times in as many different ways as possible - as if the reader is too dim to get the message first time round.

And as for editing - one has to be ruthless with one's creations. Better to take the knife into your own hands than have some less-caring individual do it for you.

Best wishes

H

Steven Hunley
01-07-2011, 02:20 PM
"And as for editing - one has to be ruthless with one's creations. Better to take the knife into your own hands than have some less-caring individual do it for you."

Could this have been put any better? I think not.


Are you sure Frankenstein didn't say this?

Nikhar
01-08-2011, 10:57 PM
@arrytus

I'm really glad that you liked the story and flattered that you thought it was the second best because all the other stories were really cool.:-)

maybe when i write it again you'll like it even better.:-D

Also, can you guys please suggest me a title to the story. I was at my wit's end when i had to do that and chose the present one out of hurry.

hillwalker
01-09-2011, 06:49 AM
Title? Well, since the tree is a central feature you should mention it in your title maybe.

'The Tree' or 'Under the Tree' - there are a number of arboreal variations you can probably come up with on your own.

H

arrytus
01-09-2011, 05:53 PM
i agree with hill but think you should call it "A Tree Falls..." to emphasize the implicit ending [and nobody's around to see/hear it...]

Pendragon
01-23-2011, 10:56 AM
I voted for your story simply because I thought it the best of the four. But don't feel bad about only getting two votes, many a time I haven't gotten any! The story is simply wonderful, don't change a thing!

Nikhar
01-26-2011, 06:44 PM
I voted for your story simply because I thought it the best of the four. But don't feel bad about only getting two votes, many a time I haven't gotten any! The story is simply wonderful, don't change a thing!

thanks a lot pen. :-)
though, i do feel that i can make it better....thats the way i had felt when i first wrote it...but yeah, thanks again 4 the vote.:-D