PDA

View Full Version : Please critique this opening page.



miyako73
08-17-2010, 12:28 PM
This is the first page of my autobiographical fiction. Please critique it. Any criticism will help. I learn from it. I am a newbie in writing.


Does the sun in the east drench the foliage, the stone path, the persimmon clay roof or burn like hell? Does the wind coming from the northwest blow gusts or puffs or does it chill? I have been wondering about the season of spring. I am in Beijing. In Daxing County. In the women’s prison. I have heard April is the month when fruit trees in the northern capital bloom. I wish I could see what an Asian spring looks like. I have seen peach and pear blossoms but not the blossoms of plums and apricots.

Of all, I love cherry blossoms the most. I used to sweep them in my grandparents' backyard when they started to fall at the end of March, the beginning of Manila summer. My grandfather’s horse, Galup, loved them more than grass after a whole morning of travel. My grandmother squeezed them with a bamboo press for their scent she used to infuse coconut oil. My friends and I would string them into leis and offer them to the priest, the nuns, and the wooden icons. Nowadays, only memories have kept me going. I miss the sun, the wind, the blossoms.

I have been in China for eight months now, but I have yet to see the grandeur of the Forbidden City I read in travel magazines; the Great Wall I wished to visit when I was a child; the Buddhist temples on top of limestone mountains sparsely covered with pine trees; the water gardens where pink lotuses and white lilies float like miniatures of pagodas on green paper boats; and the old ancestral orchards still visited by sparrows with ivory feathers on their necks, blue-gray pigeons, and Mandarin ducks. I want to see what I have only seen in postcards and calendars and on films and photographs, but it is no longer possible now.

Even the orange koi in the pond by the yard where most of the prisoners take a break, I am not allowed to see. I just imagine how they jump from the water to the air to bask in the sunlight and dive back with the breeze. My eyes have not seen much since my incarceration. Day by day, they are losing their sense of sight. Behind rusting bars locked up all the time, seeing is irrelevant.

hillwalker
08-17-2010, 01:36 PM
For an opening page this is brilliant – it sets the background to the story without giving too much away. Instead of informing the reader why you are in prison, what crime you committed, or perhaps how long you will spend there, you give us a heart-rending picture of what it is like to be denied the freedom that so many take for granted. We will continue to read – ‘basking’ in the scene you have drawn, but also holding out our hands for more titbits of information.

Your strengths are your intelligent use of language, the way you control the pace of the narrative and your ability to capture the reader’s imagination.

I would suggest 2 very minor adjustments :

'Does the sun in the east drench the foliage, the stone path, the persimmon clay roof or burn like hell?’

might read better as ‘or does it burn like hell?’

and

‘but I still have to see the grandeur of the Forbidden City’

might read better as ‘but I have yet to see…..’

I feel ungenerous in ‘finding fault’ in what is an otherwise flawless piece of writing. My advice, for what it’s worth, keep writing this and start looking for a publisher.

H

miyako73
08-17-2010, 02:04 PM
thanks, Hill, and forgive me for my lack of confidence. That's why I love it here. People in the forum understand more than my sister, a newspaper writer. hehehehe

hillwalker
08-17-2010, 03:47 PM
And perhaps your sister would always say 'very nice' or 'very good' without being really honest with you if your writing was rubbish (which it MOST DEFINITELY isn't).....

glad to be of some help.

H

Alexander III
08-17-2010, 06:26 PM
Have to agree with hill, your prose is very beautiful, as an opening I think its great.

stleonard
08-17-2010, 07:22 PM
This is the first page of my autobiographical fiction. Please critique it. Any criticism will help. I learn from it. I am a newbie in writing.


Does the sun in the east drench the foliage, the stone path, the persimmon clay roof or burn like hell? Does the wind coming from the northwest blow gusts or puffs or does it chill? I have been wondering about the season of spring. I am in Beijing. In Daxing County. In the women’s prison. I have heard April is the month when fruit trees in the northern capital bloom. I wish I could see what an Asian spring looks like. I have seen peach and pear blossoms but not the blossoms of plums and apricots.

Of all, I love cherry blossoms the most. I used to sweep them in my grandparents' backyard when they started to fall at the end of March, the beginning of Manila summer. My grandfather’s horse, Galup, loved them more than grass after a whole morning of travel. My grandmother squeezed them with a bamboo press for their scent she used to infuse coconut oil. My friends and I would string them into leis and offer them to the priest, the nuns, and the wooden icons. Nowadays, only memories have kept me going. I miss the sun, the wind, the blossoms.

I have been in China for eight months now, but I have yet to see the grandeur of the Forbidden City I read in travel magazines; the Great Wall I wished to visit when I was a child; the Buddhist temples on top of limestone mountains sparsely covered with pine trees; the water gardens where pink lotuses and white lilies float like miniatures of pagodas on green paper boats; and the old ancestral orchards still visited by sparrows with ivory feathers on their necks, blue-gray pigeons, and Mandarin ducks. I want to see what I have only seen in postcards and calendars and on films and photographs, but it is no longer possible now.

Even the orange koi in the pond by the yard where most of the prisoners take a break, I am not allowed to see. I just imagine how they jump from the water to the air to bask in the sunlight and dive back with the breeze. My eyes have not seen much since my incarceration. Day by day, they are losing their sense of sight. Behind rusting bars locked up all the time, seeing is irrelevant.

Very good, enjoyed it, classical, descriptive... can you critique mine, let me know, leonard

Delta40
08-17-2010, 08:28 PM
you have said so much in so little time and my senses are dizzy from all that you have written. personally, this is a brilliant opening as you scale from the broad location to the specifics of your situation.