PDA

View Full Version : Equals



aBIGsheep
12-20-2008, 07:32 PM
His neck is twisted to the side, looking off majestically into the dusty back corner of the living room. He must be thinking something wonderful -- something pristine, basic or innocent. From where his head is mounted, you could almost assume that he wasn‘t dead. But as the tall stalks of his antlers dance shadows against the wall, that sad, sick, stillness of his form remind me otherwise.

Grandfather and I are sitting at the edge of the hearth. Me on his lap, and his thoughts long gone. He’s a sorry ol’ coot. My dad would tell me these weary old adventure stories about how his father got lost in the wilds, trudging along in search of some lost civilization. When Grandfather crawled, partly frozen and half-starved into the local All-Day-Every-Day Diner, dad said Grandfather was much happier with a meal than a civilization.

The old man nudges at his glasses as the light from the flames bounce against the edge of his grin.

“You wanna hear a story, m’child?” Grandfather asks.

I nod my head.

“You see that big buck?” he makes a nod towards the deer head glaring away from us.
The laugh-lines stand against the edge of his cheeks.

“Bastard put up one helluva fight!” Grandfather laughs a full hearted laugh, letting it start all the way down in his gut and bellow right out his ears.

“I spen’ two weeks lookin‘ fer that one,” he says proudly before thrusting two wrinkly fingers into my face, “Count ‘em! One, two!” I chuckle at him and he grins, happy that I’m amused by him. What a sad joy it is, finding meaning in the smallest of moments.

“Dang Grandfather,” I say to him, my voice an echo compared to his, “was it worth it?”

“After two weeks you bet yer britches it was worth it!” He says, slapping his knee and laughing at himself.

But as he laughs, my eyes trail up to the silent figurine watching us from above. Such a magnificent thing. Hard to believe that such a powerful creature could be broken down into a mantle piece -- merely existing as a foot note to someone else’s legacy.

My grandfather notices, quieting himself before he joins my gaze. We sit there for a moment, enjoying our silence. The majesty, the regality, the unobserved wonder that could’ve been a king! The enormity of his antlers! They sit on his head like a crown as it sparkles against the firelight.

“You know,” Grandfather begins slowly, never pausing to look away from the Deer, “those two weeks were some of the loneliest, coldest, days of my life.”

I turn my head to look at him, but he doesn’t move. He sits there, smiling at his peer, letting the light of the dying fire slow-dance somberly against his skin. I finally take notice of how old he is. I feel sorry for how his skin sags against his grin -- how it once must’ve accommodated so much vigor in it’s youth! I look at his laugh-lines. They must’ve been memories of happier days -- and the giant furrows above his eye brows, reminders of the hard ones. But his eyes. . . You could almost see his thoughts play on his pupils like a television.

Good show ya’ ol’ hooligan! Damn you put up one helluva fight ya’ ol’ bastard!

“Harder than when you crawled into the diner Grandfather?” I ask.

“O’ nothin’ coulda rivaled that m‘child,” he chuckles softly before he turns back to me, “but those days came damn close.”

“It was just me and him out there, bravin’ the wilderness like nothing ever should,” he takes a deep breath and straightens his back, growing taller and more radiant with the firelight. He raises his chin, pointing it up at some unseen audience as he reminisces about his glory.

“Tha’ thing was as big as a coup but it moved so silently in the snow! It was a pleasure huntin’ him. Gave me mo’ trouble than a whole van full of gran’ children!” He laughed to himself and ruffled my hair.

“But that thin’ had m’beat. It’d just disappear into the snow, y’know? Like a spectre in the night. And just when I’d finally given up, just when I’d finally packed up everythin’ and decided to head it out . . .” I could see the scene in his pupils, “thar he was, grazing on some small patch of grass that’d somehow found it’s way through the snow. The sun was smilin’ on ‘im as if God had made a beacon for me to follow. It was almost like he was handin‘ ‘imself over to me, almost like he was sayin’ ‘you’ve worked hard enough, here you go.’”

Grandfather took a deep breath and sighed, letting the air escape his lungs before he bent his back over in defeat.

“I shouldn’t have shot him, m’child,” he whispered hauntingly to me, ”Tha’ thin’ was a king before I got to ‘im. Two fer two, pound fer pound, we were even matches. He’d eluded me for weeks, tha’ bastard, and jus’ when he thought it was safe, just when he was at the high light of his life, I took it all away from him . . .”

The fire was but a cradle of embers, flickering in and out. Grandfather sniffled in the dark. I felt a tear break apart as it dropped onto my skin.

“But look at ‘im now! He aint ever gonna get ol!” he was laughing a hushed laugh; a pained laugh that hurt somewhere deep down in his chest.

“Jus’ look at me! I’m jus’ this sorry ol’ sack of bones! He aint never gonna git tired or weak! He‘s jus‘ gonna stay so damn purdy up thar on m‘wall!”

He twisted his neck and looked at the corner of the living room, averting his gaze away from his old adversary, thinking that somehow it’d hide his fossil shame and envy.

aBIGsheep
12-21-2008, 08:28 PM
Hopefully it's easier on the eyes.

shortstoryfan
12-21-2008, 09:13 PM
I think this is a really good start. Very nice. You have a beginning and a good ending, but the middle needs to be expanded. I think it would be interesting if you elaborated into the Grandfather's hunt, and maybe developed a kind of relationship between him in the deer as he tries to hunt him down. It will bring more emotion to the story and you will probably have the chance to do more with it...give it even more depth.

One section that is trouble is this series of paragraphs:

“You see that big buck?” he makes a nod towards the deer head glaring away from us.
The laugh-lines stand against the edge of his cheeks.

“Bastard put up one helluva fight!” Grandfather laughs a full hearted laugh, letting it start all the way down in his gut and bellow right out his ears.

“I spen’ two weeks lookin‘ fer that one,” he says proudly before thrusting two wrinkly fingers into my face, “Count ‘em! One, two!” I chuckle at him and he grins, happy that I’m amused by him. What a sad joy it is, finding meaning in the smallest of moments.

The Grandfather is the only one speaking here. I really like what you have written in between his speech, but maybe you could consolidate it somehow. The three paragraphs for his speech alone seems kind of unneccessary. Maybe just switching some of the sentences so it doesn't seem so broken up and needless.

Also, you may want to review some of your tenses in certain sections. The mistakes are so noticeable that they are jarring, but I think if the tense was more consistent it would make a stronger story. Only at the end of the story does it become a problem, glancing over it quickly. If you want, I'll cite certain places, but you will probably reread it yourself and figure them out.

Another concern I have is that this story seems familiar. Maybe if you expand the middle you can make something more interesting and innovative. I think the story you have chosen is a very good story to pick because it doesn't really involve too many literary feats of genius to execute. You can kind of just...tell the story and write it well. It was probably a good idea to make it like this, a very simple retelling of a story, to not lose yourself.

shortstoryfan
12-21-2008, 09:22 PM
Oh, I must simply add this: I don't want you to feel like I'm marginalizing your story. It is very good, but I think you now need to make it something special. "The Hunt" is kind of one of those archetypal old stories, pitting man against nature and such, so I think you are going to have to work hard against the story you have chosen to tell to make it something spectacular. I really would be scared to write this story, because I don't know how I would make it more original. We have even seen before in this kind of story the man putting himself in the place of the animal and feeling empathy, so I don't know. Good luck is all I can say.

shortstoryfan
12-21-2008, 09:25 PM
Also, sorry...I keep thinking of more things. I was kind of confused at first at to whether this "crawling to the diner" story was the same as the "deer" story. You shouldn't put things in stories that aren't significant to the story at that time. If this deer had such an impact on the grandfather, shouldn't that have been his hardest fight. By adding reference to this other story, it kind of diminishes significance of the deer story.

aBIGsheep
12-21-2008, 09:26 PM
Thanks man!

Looking at it, I could see where you coming from on the technical stuff. Nice eye.

But considering content, I think you're missing the point. The story is about the Grandfather, not completely about the deer.

It's about the Grandfather's ruminations of how the Deer was able to stay young and strong hung up as an ornament, whereas the Grandfather gets to grow old and weak.

And I'm sorry that I don't have enough literary feats of genius to impress you. I'm just not that much of weathered writer to be able to scale such erudite heights.

shortstoryfan
12-21-2008, 09:31 PM
I was impressed. I just was glad that you didn't try to do something and then fumble it up. Actually, I prefer that you picked this...I wasn't trying to downplay your ability, but to praise it, because you have the literary sense not to try to attempt something and it go horribly wrong and read like garbage. Aren't you rather young? No, I wasn't trying to downplay this, I was just impressed that you were trying to express rather than impress. Many writers would have tried to do something grandiose, and ended up with a horrible story. You had the good sense to write something good.

aBIGsheep
12-21-2008, 09:50 PM
What are you trying to say? That I'm good, but not that good? That I can write a story, but I'm not a literary genius? That I'm just growing and experimenting?
Just say it man, I can take it.

This story isn't about a man's relation to a deer. If you don't understand that, you're missing out on the point of the story.

shortstoryfan
12-21-2008, 10:03 PM
I'm sorry. I've missed the entire point of this story.

aBIGsheep
12-22-2008, 12:58 AM
Your loss.
Thanks for the criticism.

prendrelemick
12-28-2008, 08:57 AM
Good stuff again Bigsheep, I hesitate to offer advice, but if you ever edit or polish this one, then look to simplify rather than add.

I particularly like the touch, where the circumstances of the kill left a hollow victory for the man. But the " age shall not wither" him theme, introduced at the end, seems scant comfort for the stag! Would Grandfather have changed places?

Delta40
12-29-2008, 01:20 AM
I knew as soon as I was reading this tale it was about Grandfather. This story is not so much about victory as in aftermath and perspective. Survival of the fittest frozen in time, which he has learnt in his grey wisdom. Very poignant and perfectly related. I'm a crap critic however, I did not encounter difficulties with your narrative flow and the story had a powerful, authentic ring to it and I love how it was ultimately about the ongoing movement of life.

Thank you BigSheep