PDA

View Full Version : Swann's Way by Marcel Proust



Proust71
04-26-2008, 10:30 AM
Allow me to review Swann's Way by Marcel Proust. This was the first piece of modern literature I ever had the pleasure to peruse. Never before was I uplifted with such a psychological yet truly sensational feeling that whetted my palate for more by this great author.

The beginning of Swann's Way begins with the narrator (Marcel) having insomnia and reminiscing over the fragmented memories that seem to materialize in front of him between the realm of somnolence and consciousness. Of course, how can I go on without also commenting on the madeleine segment, so aesthetically written was this part that I shall never disremember it.

Combray is the title of the second part, enumerating the narrator's childhood experiences with a copious amount of description of objects (the most memorable being the steeple and the flowers). Here he sees the monotony of his aunt Leonie's life due to her bedridden disease. Other characters are revealed here at Combray, like Legrandin (the profound orator/engineer) and the amenable Francoise whose loyalties are quite remarkable. I do not wish to divulge any of the plot, or rather the philosophical undertones that the book is really apt towards. Anyway, Combray also goads Marcel's love for the young Gilberte Swann, a love further delineated in the last section of this magnificent story.

Swann in Love, my personal favorite, occurs before Marcel was born. Charles Swann can be seen as a foolish man who squandered his intelligence for social status and erudition for the arts. Gradually, he accrues a relation with Odette de Crecy without any sort of justification. Such love has perilous results, and Swann ends up as paranoid as a tyrant surrounded by a revolutionary populace. Music too has never been so idyllically manifested in any works I read. The music that Swann listens to produces a connection and foundation for his love for Odette, yet it also reveals to him the desperate and deplorable state he truckles to during the course of the story.

Finally, The Place-Name:The Name consummates such a gorgeous book. Here, the little boy Marcel continues his relation with Gilberte, whom he meets at the famous Champs-Elysee in Paris. Oh, how he longs for her in that same unjustifiable ardor once exhibited by Swann himself. Her very name brings forth hope for the morrow wherein Gilberte may profess her love to Marcel.

Albeit a very small recapitulation of Swann's Way, I would like to make note on Proust's prose, which soporifically compelled me to keep reading every divine page. Every paragraph, every sentence, and every punctuation in itself is comparative to an ending of a novel. Every line has that same emotional culmination one receives by reading the last lines of a great work; however, this recurs throughout the novel and not just at the ending. Furthermore, associative memory is a key factor in Swann's Way, a psychological standpoint whereby objects confess past experiences like a caged bird being released after decades of imprisonment. This book spoke to me in ways that were surreal. And I only can hope that it speaks to you as well.

Proust71
04-26-2008, 12:22 PM
Just added a poll.

papayahed
05-11-2008, 06:57 PM
***Please recast your votes, I've upated the poll ****

Lord Bas
08-11-2009, 01:04 AM
I must say this was quite the piece of literature. I found it interesting how throughout the story, art was a focus of both Swann and the narrator being Marcel.

The music that symbolized the love that Swann had for Odette, and the constant mentions of haute couture, composition combined with the sublime prose of Proust made this one of the best books I've ever read.

Not a page went by where I didn't want to copy down something in the book, truly an excellent read.

The Comedian
08-11-2009, 09:22 PM
I'm sold! I need to read this book as it sound like just like my kind of read. Thanks for the review.

kinkajou
09-26-2009, 10:22 AM
Not a page went by where I didn't want to copy down something in the book, truly an excellent read.

Totally agree. When I read it the first time I wasn't ready. But now that 1) I've finished it and 2) I've read How Proust Can Change Your Life, my highlighter and I are prepared. But I'm waiting to read it again until I can also read the rest of the book. That's a commitment I'm not quite ready for.

Night_Lamp
10-03-2009, 04:56 PM
I love the book, but those who aren't willing to take the time:

Places evoke memory.

I just saved you a few hundred pages...

Etienne
11-07-2009, 06:38 PM
Reading Proust is somewhat like spending an afternoon back in the womb.

wallflower5
06-07-2011, 03:51 AM
I found the book hard to understand and random. The stream of consciousness descriptions are too long and much for me.

Ayahuasca
07-06-2011, 04:13 AM
Marcel Proust is the man. Never have I ever seen a person wax so poetically about such banal things as asparagus and make it interesting beautiful, nor do I envision myself seeing another perform such a feat. As a person who has read the first three volumes of In Search Of Lost Time, I have to say that the following two volumes get even better. The fact that such talent is allowed to exist in this world intimidates and awes me. I have made it my life goal to be as eloquent as him, but if I am able even to accomplish half that, I should be satisfied with myself.

Intuition
08-05-2011, 10:59 AM
It is easily one of the greatest pieces of modernist literature, and even one of the greatest novels of all time. It still continues to be a controversial piece of literature-- as some do not even care to finish the first chapter-- whereas others rate it the to be the eighth greatest piece of literature ever written.

Charles Darnay
08-24-2011, 05:08 PM
Reading Proust is somewhat like spending an afternoon back in the womb.

I find it unsettling that I know exactly what you mean!