PDA

View Full Version : The Azaan: comments please!



gothic
09-06-2007, 03:32 AM
First of all, I posted this story in general writing and was utterly dissapointed to see the lack of response,couldn't figure out whether it's just that the story doesn't deserve any comment or I put it in a wrong place. So, whatever you feel reading this story, say it any way you want- but DO say something, cause it's really important for me to know,as it is my very first short story in English and I need to know how did it go.

The Azaan

‘There he is’, I gasped, totally exhausted from running all this way from the science building of the school. I rushed at the boy in the corner, poring over some papers in his hand. “Saom”, I called out, may be it came out a bit louder than intended, cause he gave a jerk and looked at me, seemingly startled. “What?”. “What what? I hope I didn’t scare you to death?” I said a bit testily. “No actually…,”he gave me an awkward smile,” Every time I hear any loud voice or sound it comes being translated to me my father grumbling-“ why do people scream all the time? Our Mahanabi told us to always keep it quiet and calm. If they only listened…”
“Yeah, I know, your father’s a bit…whatever, are you coming or not?”
“Where?”
“You know, to the cultural program!”
“Oh, sure, I love listening to songs…I thought you’d start about that again…”
“I am starting it dear. Are you singing there or not?” He sort of blushed and replied in a meek voice-“I told you, I have never learned music in that sense. Not that I sing well too…”
“Well,” I said patiently,” I don’t need to hear that I-don’t –sing –good thing again. It sucks. And your voice rocks-is all that I know. Okay, lets prove that you are the worst singer we have ever seen. So, come with me and prove it.” I took him by the hand, he shook it off. “You are not getting it. It’s not only how I sing, it’s my father too. He is the Muazzin of the mosque and just despises this kind of things. He would never let me…he’ll kill me…”
“ For singing in the program?” I couldn’t suppress the disgust. ”Don’t you think you are over reacting? I mean…come on, what could he do if he knew? He could be mad at you, throw things at you in the extreme, what more?”
“ You don’t know him. He becomes murderous at times he’s angry.” He closed his eyes and it seemed as if he shuddered for a moment and sighed. “I am not going”. He looked stern.
* * *

“So, what do you say now?” I raised my eyebrows sarcastically.” How did it feel with whole of the hallroom screaming-ONCE MORE, eh?” He just smiled in answer. ”Didn’t I tell you, man, didn’t I? That you were going to rock it, but all you knew was saying- “I am not much of a singer…” I mimicked him in a tony voice. He laughed mirthfully, his face glowing like I’ve never seen before. “Tell me one thing”,I put a hand on his shoulder,” Where did you get this? This thirst for music? I mean, as you have always told about your family, so conservative and all…how did you grow this interest dwelling in that sort of environment?” He chuckled-“You really want to know?” I chuckled back at him and nodded.” It’s the azaan I got the aspirations from.” “Azaan?” I sounded confused, as I was. “Yes!” An unknown bliss swelled in his voice.” Have you ever heard it in the other way? It’s a song with an unearthly tune! It’s so gripping…no wonder people have been responding to this summon for ages…it totally grasps one…and it taught me the first lesson of music-when you do music, try to bring out your soul in your tune,your voice-to be heard!” He stopped abruptly.” May be you are thinking me nuts.” He mumbled. The same old Saom was back again. “No,no…” I shook my head in a confused manner.” You just put it right,” I tried to sound thoughtful,” I never thought in that way before…I wish your father saw it that way.” And I knew at once I had made the mistake. All the colors drained from his face.”Do you think he could know somehow?” “Of course not. How could he? He’s not going to come to the school,is he?” He didn’t answer.

Saom felt happier than ever. He felt so contented with himself that he even winked at a pretty girl while walking on the pavement; the girl gave him a scowl in turn. He was so happy. He whistled all the way home, the tunes of the songs he had sang in the program .His eyes still dreamy from the old vision- a great mob before the stage, all applauding together after each if his songs. Oh God, did that all really happen? He still couldn’t believe it…
Her mother was at the front door, standing with a pale face that he didn’t remember seeing a less pale since his birth. Or was it a bit paler than usual? Before he could figure out or his mother could speak, his father’s chilly voice came- ‘Saom, come in…’ Saom could feel the blood draining from his face. His mother seemed as if she had frozen. He quietly shoved her aside and entered. His father sat on a chair in the dining room, looking totally blank and stiff. “So, you sang today, huh? What was the song, the first one- “I have bound my soul with yours..” wasn’t it? ‘What a lovely song and you wouldn’t believe how beautifully your son sang,’ Maruf’s father said. Shouldn’t I be proud of my son! And what was the second-“I give you this blue-necklace, love…”,he stopped abruptly and looked him into the eyes. They were small and black, but now somehow they looked red. “Didn’t I tell you to always abide by the rules of the holy Quran and the Hadis? Didn’t I?” his voice shivered in anguish.” And you, despite all the forbidding, you sang and danced before all those mediocre people…” “Father, I didn’t dance…” “Don’t! Don’t you argue with me once, you, you…” the man lost words and to fill the lacking took out the hand that he held behind his back all through. It was holding a chopper, sharp and shining in the dim yellow light. At the sight of that thing, Saom suddenly felt a strong urge to vomit. His head was spinning and eyes denied to focus on anything and the last thing he heard before losing consciousness was his mother’s shrill voice-“ No! Oh Allah, save my child…”

The doorbell shrieked and annoyed as ever I opened the door. Saom was standing at the door, barely supporting himself by the help of the wall. His face and hands looked all bruised and he wore a weird smile on his face, an eerily sick smile. “Could I stay at your house tonight?” He croaked. I was petrified.

* * *

I met him outside the mosque one day. The same old Saom, but somehow he looked fresher. I called out- Hey Saom! It didn’t startle him and he yelled back at me- Oh, Kabir! Can’t believe it man! You are really here!” I took his hands in mine and stared silently. He stared back. “Such a long time has passed…” he said almost inaudibly. Both silent, all the memories welling up inside. “So, I heard you were teaching English in a college…” at last I found words. “ Oh yes, yes, you heard right. And as I heard you are…” “just holding the old business of my dad, not feeling bad.” He smiled. “You certainly came for…” He cut in-“ To give the azaan.” I didn’t say anything, actually did not know what to say. “Father’s still alive and he still is working for the mosque. He gets sick sometimes and then I give the azaan in place of him.” He said in a firm voice. His face was passive and calm. “ That’s good, I’d say, that’s good. So you haven’t missed your prayer, right? I have. And won’t deny that it happens everyday, can’t help it pal…”
“No, you have forgotten. I don’t pray anymore.”
I gazed at him for a while.
“Oh,yes, I remember now. Since that day?”
“Since that day.”

symphony
09-07-2007, 08:43 AM
Hello gothic. :) See? I told u I can find u here! I'm not THAT stupid yet! ;)

Well, I am by no means a good critic. But I often cant resist commenting on people's posts. To this one, I'll say only this- It brought out a weird sensation in me(positively speaking), somehow inexplicable. I cant really tell whether this affected me the way it did just because I'm familiar to the sentiments mentioned(or rather, hinted) in this story, but I'd say I like it. Quite much.

Nice start.

CdnReader
09-08-2007, 01:44 PM
It's a good story, Gothic, but there are numerous spelling and grammatical errors that would need shaping up to make it a really fine piece of work. For instance "pouring" should be "poring", "loosing" should be "losing", etc. Watch your sentence structure, and ensure sentences end where they should. Several times you've used commas, and should have used a period and started a new sentence. Also, I would use new paragraphs for each speaker in your conversation. I found it difficult in some spots to understand who was talking.

I hope this helps! The story is very good! :)

gothic
09-08-2007, 02:14 PM
Thank you very much for your kind suggestions,cdn! I'll try to keep them in mind.

Wmason
09-15-2007, 09:02 AM
You need to work on your formatting. Some of your paragraphs are too long, and your dialogue is all over the place (you should seperate them into lines).

Naya Cos
11-05-2007, 11:32 PM
It is quite possible that many viewers did not linger long enough to read it carefully. People do tend to read faster on the internet, since there is all that 'other stuff ' also to read or look up etc.
It is also true, as someone else said, that this post was very difficult to read and follow. The sentences were not parsed well. The paragraphs were not clear. The quotes were not quite structured as dialog.
As for the content, some ideas were not made clear enough for a universal audience. The notion of giving azan, a uniquely islamic practice, the conflict between musicality versus austerity involved, etc., have n't been clarified either through exposition, dialog, or any other device. Add to it the element of coming of age, growing up to responsibilities in the real world, you have quite a tough story to tell. But it IS a great story.
You can do a good job with this story: format it properly with generous paragraphing. Describe peoples faces, clothes, lightings, voices etc., as needed. Don't comment, just narrate. Take a deep breath, close your eyes and tell a total stranger what exactly happened. Good Luck

gothic
11-06-2007, 03:29 AM
Naya,this is so INSPIRING!!! as I said before,that this story is only the beggining of my short story writing,so there ought to be a lot of mistakes.and also the fact that I posted it as soon as it was born,could be given as an excuse for my silly mistakes. as for the format,I was so overcome with the strange feeling that had taken over my mind for those few days,that I barely thought about any formatting.actually,it was a total raw piece of work.

I'm so glad that despite all my mistakes you appreciated the story.thanks for understanding the substance of the story,which only few seemed to be able to make out,of course for my flaws and blemishes,I must admit.

But I'm so happy!:) :p :D

Pretty^Athens
11-06-2007, 09:03 AM
Hello gothic. :) See? I told u I can find u here! I'm not THAT stupid yet! ;)

Well, I am by no means a good critic. But I often cant resist commenting on people's posts. To this one, I'll say only this- It brought out a weird sensation in me(positively speaking), somehow inexplicable. I cant really tell whether this affected me the way it did just because I'm familiar to the sentiments mentioned(or rather, hinted) in this story, but I'd say I like it. Quite much.

Nice start.

hi symphony. if you cant resist commenting on the members' posts as you say, why don't you check out the poems and short stories i've posted? i'de love to hear (or read) your opinion ;)


Gothic i love your stpry it's very impressive and lovely. Write on!

gothic
11-06-2007, 01:01 PM
Thanks Athens. I think if you really wanted sym to read your writings,it would be better if you PMed her.I don't think replying my thread could do much about it.

Pretty^Athens
11-06-2007, 01:11 PM
Thanks Athens. I think if you really wanted sym to read your writings,it would be better if you PMed her.I don't think replying my thread could do much about it.

yeah well... may be. i'de appresiate it if you read my writings and review them for me :)

gothic
11-07-2007, 06:34 AM
I will, athens,I will.:)

Captain Pike
11-07-2007, 10:07 PM
I was confused by the seemingly changing point of view. At one point you are using I statements. The story begins in the first person, one boy speaking of his friend, trying to get him to participate in the singing. Then later, you seem to be narrating what is happening with the boy and his father in their home. This latter seems to be omniscient, which works well, but seems incongruous with the first-person beginning.

Also, maybe is an old English written rule, I'm not sure of this, I always start a new paragraph when a difference person begins to speak. This uses up pages, to be sure, but it gives the reader an additional reference which is helpful when understanding complicated dialogue and action.

Sorry for my broken English, my voice interpretation file program is not working very well

gothic
11-08-2007, 01:07 PM
well Pike,you've complained about something I haven't thought of before,niether anyone else mentioned before. I guess that's not much of a problem.I'd read stories of this pattern and I didn't feel bothered by that.may be this doesn't work in the same way for everybody.

Captain Pike
01-27-2008, 12:12 AM
I can't even imagine writing a story in another language! In a language other than my own, even! I hoped you wouldn't be hurt by my well-intended-comment. Please flog me back with your truth about something of mine.

With appreciation,_P.

1n50mn14
01-28-2008, 01:30 AM
I'm having a really difficult time reading this due to the way that the dialogue is spaced. It's hard to follow.
I am, however, enjoying the plot very much so.