PDA

View Full Version : please, we needs constructive criticism



Triskele
12-28-2006, 01:40 AM
hey y'all, this is a freewrite in progress, so i need some help as for improvements, i don't know what to do, but it just doesn't feel done... ya know.

Portland
Wet, its always wet. the cool air paves the street with diamonds when the sun shines down. Fading slowly to black with the heat of the day. Telephone poles once plain, brown, sticky with tar, have been encased in flashes of neon flyers lighting the streets. Despite the obvious chill the boy wears his layered shirts that hang loosely over his feminine jeans. This the result of desperation for someone to hug his slender hips, because no one else will. He walks, ear buds in his ears… music wafts behind as he shuffles down to the coffee shop up the street. Small, liberal, independent, addictive… representing everything he tries to stand for. He takes his usual seat. Alone, isolated, cornered in his opinions, and lights up, moping, in some permanent state of melancholy and rebellion. He rants on, mock opinions derived from rumor, each sentence flavored with obscenity. “ Down with the man… he’s keeping me down”, he says, so cliché its sickening. Vocal masses lack mind to speak. The cigarette smoke swirls then dissipates. The cold wet air weighs down his poison. He cherishes what he doesn’t understand, strives for conformity…to the strange, the odd, the new. He finds his comfort in being different, but in his abnormality he is tossed and turned in the current of society… swimming, drowning, going against the current, thrown violently into the latest trend. This is his loss, he is fake, his soul lies in his search for harsh reality, in trying to be everybody else, he loves himself, as he tries to be different, he is the same… as are we all. So stop deterring form normality, and float with the current until you find yourself…alone… in company with the world.

Riesa
12-28-2006, 01:58 AM
hi, Triskele. on first read, the only thing I noticed was "cold wet air." I think you could drop cold and then wet air would become more powerful. otherwise, I liked it. sounds real, a quiet tirade. :thumbs_up

Triskele
12-28-2006, 02:10 AM
hey y'all, this is a freewrite in progress, so i need some help as for improvements, i don't know what to do, but it just doesn't feel done... ya know.

Portland
Wet, its always wet. the cool air paves the street with diamonds when the sun shines down. Fading slowly to black with the heat of the day. Telephone poles once plain, brown, sticky with tar, have been encased in flashes of neon flyers lighting the streets. Despite the obvious chill the boy wears his layered shirts that hang loosely over his feminine jeans. This the result of desperation for someone to hug his slender hips, because no one else will. He walks, ear buds in his ears… music wafts behind as he shuffles down to the coffee shop up the street. Small, liberal, independent, addictive… representing everything he tries to stand for. He takes his usual seat. Alone, isolated, cornered in his opinions, and lights up, moping, in some permanent state of melancholy and rebellion. He rants on, mock opinions derived from rumor, each sentence flavored with obscenity. “ Down with the man… he’s keeping me down”, he says, so cliché its sickening. Vocal masses lack mind to speak. The cigarette smoke swirls then dissipates. The wet air weighs down his poison. He cherishes what he doesn’t understand, strives for conformity…to the strange, the odd, the new. He finds his comfort in being different, but in his abnormality he is tossed and turned in the current of society… swimming, drowning, going against the current, thrown violently into the latest trend. This is his loss, he is fake, his soul lies in his search for harsh reality, in trying to be everybody else, he loves himself, as he tries to be different, he is the same… as are we all. So stop deterring form normality, and float with the current until you find yourself…alone… in company with the world.

i like the change, thanks, heres a slightly revised version

Riesa
12-28-2006, 02:20 AM
I really like
Small, liberal, independent, addictive



on second read this:


He walks, ear buds in his ears… music wafts behind as he shuffles down to the coffee shop up the street.


seemed a little unnecessary. but it might just be me. second opinions anyone?

Triskele
12-28-2006, 02:27 AM
i see what you mean, it is a bit awkward, but i need something to transition from the landscape to the coffee shop/the boy, and walking down the street seemed a nice idea to me. any ideas.

Riesa
12-28-2006, 02:37 AM
maybe...

he takes his usual seat at his usual coffee shop?

transition accomplished, but with a weary sigh instead of giving away too much??

Triskele
12-28-2006, 07:39 PM
hmm... i like the idea, weary repitition but i think the wording is still a bit abrupt.

His crippled spine shows through as a slouches to his usual seat, jarring music echoes his dark thoughts.

perhaps?

Riesa
12-29-2006, 01:01 AM
ok. it might be a bit too descriptive. which is good! god knows I'm guilty of it. the thing is, I like the weariness evoked in the whole piece. it works for me. I wouldn't have got crippled from your earlier image of feminine jeans hugging him. so that adds a layer. but is it necessary? he seems crippled enough mentally to me. hmm. jarring music echoes his dark? thoughts... maybe jarring isn't right here. his dark thoughts echo in blue notes richocheting around the coffee shop? :lol: okay, that's terrible. but...jarring means hyper, discombobulated, dark means slow, deep and sad...again, at least to me.

Triskele
12-30-2006, 11:41 PM
i hear what you mean about jarring verse dark, and my intent would be to draw somewhat of a connection between the two, perhaps a middle ground of sorts... i agree on the crippled part... perhaps "his humped spine"... that sounds sort of crippled to, i like the idea of the spine/slouching, makes for a bit of motion without a verb... hmmm...