Log in

View Full Version : college essay 2



ssjandu
11-07-2006, 10:19 PM
well i'm trying to write a college essay. same thing posted as before, but it was a different subject and i think people weren't reading all the way down to the actual essay. here it is so far:

“You don't know how lucky you are.” It is usually my dad who utters these words, typically as a warning (and more often than not, with his index finger pointed directly at my face). For the most part, I usually just cast the words aside with the casual “Yeah, yeah. Aren't we all.” But there is, however, the rare occasion on which I actually ponder these words and delve into a thought about what it would be like without all of the abilities and interests that I have.
“So,” I hear. “Why are you so lucky? What makes you luckier than all the rest of the people on this planet?” I spin around and, lo and behold, I am staring myself in the face. Struggling to find an answer, I finally reply with a half deflated “I don't know.” “What,” comes the retort, “you don't know? Well who would know?” Again, I reply with the unsure “I don't know.” “Well,” he says, “I think that it's time we found out. Maybe you should get to know yourself before you write that college essay that you've been planning. How can you expect to tell other people about yourself when you don't even know yourself?” The thought had been looming in the back of my mind. College applications.
“So you're getting ready for college. I think it's time you got to know yourself. Let me begin.” It felt a bit awkward talking to myself, but after a while, it began to seem almost normal. “I am a Sikh from India,” he chimed in simply. “Right,” I continued, “but I was born here in Baltimore.” He gave me a look that told me that I had the right idea. “The cool thing about that is that you're not completely one culture. You've assimilated, but you've held on to your own religion. You speak – how many – three languages?” “Yeah,” I reply, “but there's more to me than just that.” “Do tell,” he says. This was beginning to feel so normal that it felt weird. Nonetheless, I replied, “Well, I have lots of interests.” “Like what?” he asks. “Well we're talking about college, right? The thing that I want to major in, biology, isn't simply an interest. It's a passion. In fact, I love science in general. Most of the classes that I took this year are science and they pertain to the career that I want to pursue: neurosurgery.”
“So you like science,” he replies. “What kinds of classes are you taking?” “Right now, I'm taking AP Biology, AP Psychology, and Honors Anatomy and Physiology. Last year, I took Paramedic Biology.” He nods his approval. “So what are some of the scientific things that you do outside of school?” I respond, “I volunteer at Johns Hopkins Medical Center and have shadowed doctors there and witnessed several surgeries. I am also one of only eighteen students in the Baltimore area selected to work at the National Aquarium in Baltimore to do a program called 'Aquarium on Wheels.'” “Really?” he asked. “So what do you do there?” I reply, “I educate children about conserving the environment,” I respond. Again, he nods his approval.
“Next subject,” he continues. “What kinds of things do you do after school?” I reply, “I was a member of the Class of 2007 Senate. I was also involved in our school's 2006 play 'Big Rock at Candy Mountain.' I was also in the Classical Guitar Club.”

--end

personally, i think it's horrible so far. criticism/suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

cuppajoe_9
11-08-2006, 01:25 AM
Honestly, if that's all the information they want out of this I'd just wrap it up in a few more sentences. I really can't see you not getting in, that's a pretty impressive resumé.

Vada Dagon
11-08-2006, 05:57 AM
I responded to your first post - All I have to say here is Ditto!

SummerSolstice
11-09-2006, 08:30 PM
The problem, perhaps, though, is that it DOES feel like a resume... don't you have to submit that, too? I did. Something like it, anyway, with my background, and community service, and qualificationish stuff, and all that jazz.

What it really sounds like is an interview, and you'll probably have one of those, too. From what I've heard and seen, what they want is more of a qualitative description of yourself, not a quantitative description. They want opinions and anecdotes and viewpoints, not lists. For instance, since I want to write for kids, my essay described how I started out in my love of reading by paging through pictureless books as a baby, staring at the printed words. Then I described the children's books I grew up with, the classic adult books I eventually learned to read and love, and my eventual return to the stories of my childhood as I realized that they were my real passion. From my reading I moved on to my writing, and from my writing to my eagerness to attend college and better my writing.

If you're getting to know someone, I really doubt you both start naming off the classes you take and the organizations you're part of. That's not "who you are." The premise is good--"why are you so lucky?" It actually sounds like an entrance essay prompt itself! You just kind of get away from that. You should definitely expand on your passion for your field--to the point, even, where it becomes the majority of your essay! Loving and being good at that stuff is DEFINITELY lucky, both for you, and the rest of the world! If it really does fire you up, you should have plenty to say about why! Get that down on paper, and I'd WANT to read it, not have to be paid like your readers will. (No offense intended. :D) It's my favorite thing about humanity: that every single thing on earth is the all-consuming passion of SOMEONE, SOMEWHERE.

(If I sound like a self-proclaimed expert, I don't mean to... it's just that I had to jump through more hoops than most people since I was homeschooled, and then more again when I applied for scholarships, so I got an exhausting quantity of experience.)

holograph
11-09-2006, 08:56 PM
im also app to college and am in the process of writing my essay. maybe we can talk! :) i like the concept for it. but make it more personal and less interview-like. think about it, you're going to put all that crap down anyway in the extra currics section, etc. try to maybe pick on of those things and elaborate. but good job so far.

oh, and i can definitely relate. i am a belarussian-born new yorker. i eat borshcht and bagels with cream cheese ;). and i plan to be a naturopath/medical doctor. heh.