characters

[jackyboy]

How would you guys compare the characters: catherine-heathcliff and catherine-edgar :confused:

[mir]

wait, do you mean what kind of person catherine was like with heathcliff and what she was like with edgar linton?

[kate.ernshaw]

Catherine once said: "Nelly I AM Heathcliff!" so I think this is enough and you understand what I mean. I really think that her marriage to Edgar was one gig mistake. Maybe if some things were different(for eg. if H. didint hear Cathy saying that she cant marry him or the one when Nely didnt give Heathcliff's letter to Cathy but hid it somewhere.....)....