What happens to Ismene?

[Literary_Cat]

The Oedipus Trilogy was my serious summer read, but I found myself quite alarmed when I reached the end of Antigone. My question is: What happens to Ismene, Antigone's sister?

At the end of Oedipus Rex, Antigone and Ismene are brought out to bid their father Oedipus fare well; in Oedipus at Colonnus, Ismene plays a rather important role in beseeching the gods to allow her father to live uncursed on holy ground; and of course in Antigone, Ismene acts as a foil to her noble and stubborn sister. But after she attempts to share responsibility with Antigone for burying her brother Polynices, she disappears. What happens to her? (Does she die?)

Sophocles seems to ignore her fate completely--and I find this unsettling. Can anyone help?

[bluevictim]

Originally Posted by Literary_Cat

The Oedipus Trilogy was my serious summer read, but I found myself quite alarmed when I reached the end of Antigone. My question is: What happens to Ismene, Antigone's sister?
...
Sophocles seems to ignore her fate completely--and I find this unsettling. Can anyone help?

This is an interesting question. Evidently, there was some story about Ismene getting involved in a love affair that led to her death, but I don't think Sophocles really intended for his audience to have this in mind. In fact, it seems that he might have transformed this story into Antigone's fatal love affair with Haimon.

What is more interesting, perhaps, is that the open-ended-ness of Ismene's fate had such an unsettling and disturbing effect. I wonder if this has to do with the practice of reading the three plays together as a single unit, in the order Oedipus Rex, Oedipus at Colonnus, and then Antigone. This is quite different than the way Sophocles intended for the plays to be received -- as three separate live performances. In fact, Antigone was produced first, then, probably more than a decade later, Oedipus Rex, and then, a few decades after that (after Sophocles had already died, in fact), Oedipus at Colonnus.

If Antigone is taken by itself, the focus is so intense on the conflict between Creon and Antigone that I suppose many audiences are willing to accept the ambiguity of Ismene's fate, just as most audiences don't find it unsettling that the fate of Juliet's nurse is left open-ended in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet. Similarly with Oedipus Rex and Oedipus at Colonnus, in which the two sisters play even smaller roles.

I suppose that when all three plays are read together as a single entity, on the other hand, Ismene's importance could be accidentally amplified by her repeated presence. In addition, someone who reads all three plays together as a single entity might be more apt to read it in the way one would read a novel like Les Miserables, expecting all the major characters to come to some kind of resolution in the end. Perhaps this is partly responsible for the unsettling feeling.

[Literary_Cat]

Ah--as a student of the novel, I see where my fault originated. Perhaps I shall tell her story some day. Thank you for your response, bluevictim.

[bluevictim]

Originally Posted by Literary_Cat

Perhaps I shall tell her story some day.

A similar impulse may have inspired Sophocles to write Antigone. Prior to Sophocles, there was little mention of the daughters of Oedipus.

Thank you for your response, bluevictim.

You're welcome.

[andave_ya]

Originally Posted by bluevictim

I suppose that when all three plays are read together as a single entity, on the other hand, Ismene's importance could be accidentally amplified by her repeated presence. In addition, someone who reads all three plays together as a single entity might be more apt to read it in the way one would read a novel like Les Miserables, expecting all the major characters to come to some kind of resolution in the end. Perhaps this is partly responsible for the unsettling feeling.

Ohh, that's really interesting, thanks for posting. I too wondered what happened to Ismene -- I just finished the Theban Plays and I read them as a single entity so yes, I suppose I was expecting a resolution for all the main characters. Thanks for clarifying on that.