I'd like to open a thread devoted to the discussion and debate of Marlowe and Goethe's renditions of the story of Faust.
I am aware, this debate is age old, but I find it scintillating nonetheless and I'm sure I'm not the only one. Hence, I've started this thread for all those that wish to engage in structured discussion about both the texts' merits and faults. And for the slightly more daring, I invite you to share which of the two you favor.
Personally, I found much more depth Marlowe's Faust. His insight into the characters of Dr. Faustus and Mephistopheles surpassed Goethe's I believe. I found Goethe's Mephistopheles almost limp and impotent, and his Faust didn't do justice to the character's torturous plight.
I must add that I cannot read German, hence I've based my statements on a translation. I could not shake the feeling I missed out on Goethe's poetical brilliance due to my inability to read German, but unfortunately this is obviously immutable.
Debate away!