I don't really know how to vote because we had both in the house. I loved lego (especially the huge pieces) to build things, but Playmobil was pretty good. The two sets that I remember vividly are the Cowboy and Indian set and the Knights. I LOVED their wine goblets. I always liked that the "wine" inside the goblets were different colors based on what they were drinking. Do they even have those in the sets anymore?
I LOVED THESE!!!! In fact, I had all 3 of those in the picture. I had the house, barn and zoo, too. The zoo was great.