Results 1 to 3 of 3

Thread: Would anyone be so kind as to give me their opinion on my first short story?...thanks

  1. #1
    Registered User
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Posts
    7

    Would anyone be so kind as to give me their opinion on my first short story?...thanks

    IN THE SHADOW OF THE SHAFT

    My life is meandering to a sad and definite close. As I sit here in my favourite armchair the rain dances on the windowsill. I know every rotten crevice in its frame. I should, for I sit here every day looking through this opaque window, memories flooding back like some overburdened river ready to burst it’s banks. These memories are perpetually haunting, forever in black and white……..just like that fateful day.
    We grew up as neighbours. My late father was a miner, as were most of the men in this community. His father was a miner also, a true gentleman, who delighted in the joys of being with his family. However, we all knew about the dangers of working in the mines, but that is all we had. Food and clothing were necessities of life; thus the risks had to be put to one side.
    As I sit here today alone I reflect on the neighbourly community which once existed here. Doors were always open, everyone had a smile on their face, and although life was hard, it was always full of vitality. Now those happy times seem to be lost forever, as I sit here with my doors firmly bolted, with the advice of the local, “Neighbourhood Watch”, providing a timely counterpoint to those by gone days.
    We married in 1932, happy days indeed! The whole community came together. It was such a simple affair, but we were so looking forward to being together, raising a family and spending the rest of our lives together. The sun shone so brightly on that day, I was so happy. All we wanted was to be together forever.
    We lived with my brother and his family, unable to afford a place of our own to start with, but we were determined to find somewhere to raise a family. He loved his garden, and when we moved into this house he was joyous, the garden was his Eden. For it had enough space to grow endless amounts of vegetables and flowers. He spent many an hour in his garden, for it was his pride and joy. It was a real community affair; the produce was shared amongst family and friends. We were so happy.
    Happiness always ends though. My mourning days will never cease, how could they? A story requires a full stop to signify closure. Only eleven bodies were recovered, the earth has yet to yield the remaining corpses. My gravestone has yet to be inscribed, like a blank canvas waiting for the artist to make his first tentative stroke. Thus, I have to sit here year after year, imagining what kind of stone I would like. I must have drafted his obituary in my mind a thousand times, but it never seemed right without his body to accompany it.
    Pat, Rose, Margaret and Lillian visit the same nightmare as myself. They understand what it is like. I feel bitter, no I don’t, I just feel empty. Most people grieve for their dead, and that time is definite in most cases. However, in this instance this process is an infinite one. I know he is dead, trapped beneath that very thing that brought food to our table, put clothes on our backs, and kept us warm in the most desperate of Winter frosts.
    We never had any aspirations when we were younger. We didn’t hanker after materialistic possessions. We were just happy and contented with our lot. We loved each other dearly, and that love kept us warm and protected us through the hard times, and believe me, we did live through some very difficult days.
    We shared a dream, that of having a family. We tried and tried…. if only he knew. I wish I could have told him, he would have been so proud. But how could I? I only discovered the news two weeks later. I cried with joy and sorrow. It was both the proudest and saddest day of my life.
    George jnr.was born, in the shadow of the shaft. I was sure his father was there to witness the event. I felt a presence at the birth, a glow, as if he was a guardian angel protecting me from the ills of the world.
    I was a single mother bringing up a child, and I found it my duty to ensure that I did it to the very best of my ability. Thus, I made a decision I had to work. It wasn’t easy, but everyone in the community rallied around to help. I wanted my late husband to be proud of me, I know I always felt proud in his presence.
    I vowed from a very early time that George jnr would never go down the mines. I encouraged him to broaden his horizons. It was difficult, as family traditions are hard to sever. He was like his father, proud and strong, and he told me that he wanted me to feel proud of him whatever career path he decided to follow. I was a proud mother and wife; my family was always at the centre of my world.
    He decided to embrace a trade, joinery was his chosen mode of work. His apprenticeship was with, “Evans & Co.”, in the town, where he worked hard just like his father. He had the same proud air and elegance of his late father…I wish he could be here now as I think he would be looking at his son the same way I do, with such feelings of pride.
    George was a good son. He never brought trouble to the door. I doted on him and I knew he felt the same way. However, I knew he bore a heavy heart, to not know your father must be a heavy burden for any child. He was insatiable in his quest for knowledge about his father; he wanted to know every minute detail about him. I suppose I would have felt the same way if I was in his position, but how could I be sure? I wanted the best for him, and that meant being over protective, a motherly trait he resented
    The fever took him, not me. I am still here, yet the two most precious people in my life have passed away. I have a gravestone for my son, a temple at which I regularly visit. It tugs at my heart- strings when I visit, but I do find comfort in talking. He is there, and he listens to me, my comfort amongst this sea of troubles.
    The fire in the grate has been reduced to a flicker, it’s life force almost extinguished, mirroring my sad story. The warmth, which once penetrated my life, has now diminished, and I have resigned myself to my fate. I have been lucky, I have lived a full life, my memories being constant companions in the shadow of the shaft.

  2. #2
    an ambitious heart romantic novel's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Location
    in his heart
    Posts
    73
    Hi...ans welcome here


    I will read it ..and provide you with my feedback sooon

    see you soon..

    P.S. The most important thing is that you try and let what inside comes out...No matter what other thinks...my philosophy
    Love is an un tamed force. When we try to control it, it desrtoys us. When we try to imprison it, it enslaves us. When we try to understand it, it leaves us feeling lost and confused

  3. #3
    nothing lasts forever maraki16's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Location
    greece, athens
    Posts
    405
    Blog Entries
    18
    dear friend,
    first of all, congratulations for writing your first short story-everyone deserves to be congratulated for his first attempt(well, i don't know if this is the very first thing you write but anyway).i really liked the introduction of the story, the first paragraph. i like this melancholic style, i find it really touching.the picture of the dancing rain and the bursting memories...it gives me the impression of someone trying to declare his despair, but at the same time your narrator seems to be perfectly calm;frozen but moved at the same time; with a magnificent dignity...this is the picture that is drawn in my mind line after line.to tell you the truth though, because since you ask for opinions it means that you are ready to accept critique as a meansof improvement,i did not find the fourth paragraph really interesting, as well as some parts of the other paragraphs. not that the were not good. what i want to say is that they did not have something...really special, like a breath-taking(i know this is an exaggeration but i hope you will excuse me for using this particular word. i just like it!doesn't it sound nice?'breath-taking'...it inspires me) metaphor or description of a picture.you know, this would be perfectly ok if you had written something longer, but just think about your story being printed:would it be one page long or so?since we are talking about something so short in length, don't you think that it would be nice to capture the reader from the first to the last line? to leave him breathless and give him the satisfaction of having read something so short in lenght, but so full in meaning and decorated with figures of speech and sentiment?
    well, i nevertheless have to admit that the last two paragraphs were great.again, i can imagine her being so still, articulating her thoughts so calmly that is so shocking it could make me want to cry. watching a woman talking about the miseries of her life, yet considering herself lucky, though looking at the fire and sitting in her armchair all alone. i have no more words to say about that, i find it really nice. i won't say it is perfect because art is never perfect. and this might not be a masterpiece, but it is a great start. at least what i can see is that you can write really moving things if you want to.
    it was a pleasure reading your short story dear reader34. thank you. oh!and keep on good work. i am waiting forward for your next story, or poem, or whatever...

Similar Threads

  1. Searching for Holocaust short story
    By richards1052 in forum General Literature
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 09-27-2014, 06:52 PM
  2. Poe Short Story Discussion Group
    By Dark Muse in forum Poe, Edgar Allan
    Replies: 231
    Last Post: 06-12-2010, 01:21 AM
  3. A short story by Mosimo
    By mosimo in forum Short Story Sharing
    Replies: 8
    Last Post: 10-19-2008, 07:08 PM
  4. trying to find a british short story I've red
    By chris21 in forum General Literature
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 02-02-2008, 04:28 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •