Search:

Type: Posts; User: stanley2; Keyword(s):

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds; generated 32 minute(s) ago.

  1. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: During the play within the play in MND we have: ...

    During the play within the play in MND we have: "The best in this kind are but shadows; and the worst are no worse, if imagination amend them," and Hippolyta's reply, "It must be your imagination...
  2. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: In post #192, you mention "original context." I...

    In post #192, you mention "original context." I noted that the phrase "merry sport" is found in Act 1, scene 3. Therefore, why did Shakespeare put it there? I've been suggesting that context is...
  3. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: The truth. Here in the Chicago area we've had...

    The truth. Here in the Chicago area we've had Roman Catholic holy man Cardinal Supich performing on Sunday mornings on television for a half hour. If you type in "the who, live at leeds, tommy, go...
  4. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: A great while ago, Professor Parrott wrote that...

    A great while ago, Professor Parrott wrote that the Sonnets were mostly written "somewhere between 1594 and 1598; some, it may be, later." This is exactly the period when MND, R&J and MV were...
  5. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: And thanks, Danik, for pointing the way back to...

    And thanks, Danik, for pointing the way back to Portia: "Tarry a little, there is something else"(MV4.1.302). Or, as Professor Mahon put it: "Again, the most effective readings, of whatever...
  6. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: We may both be in the ballpark, so to speak,...

    We may both be in the ballpark, so to speak, regarding Antonio: "Two loves I have of comfort and despair, / Which like two spirits do suggest me still: / The better angel is a man right fair, / The...
  7. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: And

    I caught a performance of the 1994 Goodman Theatre production in Chicago. One critic wrote: "At it's best a fascinating mess." The actor playing Antonio was excellent, however. At one point there...
  8. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: Ok

    I'll try to do so. I remember your comment as it is part of a very fine discussion of the Sonnets and pointed the way back to AS YOU LIKE IT. Your comment(#172) here that Antonio is saying that...
  9. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: MV andAYL

    And Danik, one of your comments in kev67's Sonnet thread(5/13/2019) might remind one that "The lunatic, the lover, and the poet are / Are of imagination all compact" (MND5.1.7-8). Lancelet the clown...
  10. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: The "strange nature" of the suit

    In his book THE AGE OF SHAKESPEARE, Professor Kermode wrote of the trial or court scene: "The trial is folklore, and the judgment comes from a folklore lawyer, but the issues are real enough." ...
  11. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: oops

    The line in KING LEAR from Kent is actually a bit later, Act 1 scene 4. Now, one comment earlier in this thread, "The arrogance(and stupidity) of the man is staggering.........What a twit!" might...
  12. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: There are three lines in KING LEAR that I like to...

    There are three lines in KING LEAR that I like to recall. In the first scene, Kent says to Lear: "This is not altogether fool, my lord." Gloucester's last line is "And that's true too." In the...
  13. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: More linguistic connections

    In the first scene of MV we find: "I pray you, good Bassanio, let me know it, / And if it stand as you yourself still do, / Within the eye of honor, be assured / My purse, my person, my extremest...
  14. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: The main conflict

    In Act 5, scene 3 of R&J, Romeo and Count Paris are both grieving the reported death of Juliet. They confront each other and Romeo kills Paris. In MV, we find Shylock and Antonio in confrontation. ...
  15. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: More Regarding Professor Wilson

    Wilson's book is in a library miles away. I believe he simply wrote that comparison is "interesting" and both plays have tragical and comical elements. He also wrote that he found Shakespeare's...
  16. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: One thing at a time

    One minute subject at a time. Professor Thomas Parrott wrote that MV is "a romantic comedy, almost a fairy tale, rendered credible by the poet's art." In her book, THE FRIENDLY SHAKESPEARE, Norrie...
  17. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: Eminent scholar J. Dover Wilson recommended...

    Eminent scholar J. Dover Wilson recommended comparing MV and ROMEO AND JULIET in his book SHAKESPEARE'S HAPPY COMEDIES. The passage before us corresponds to a passage in R&J. Juliet's line, "all...
  18. Replies
    197
    Views
    69,938

    Poll: Furthermore

    In Act 3,scene 3 we have Solanio's "I am sure the Duke / Will never grant this forfeiture to hold," and Antonio's reply: "The Duke cannot deny the course of law, / For the commodity that strangers...
  19. Replies
    74
    Views
    10,146

    And Shakespeare, I think, allows the reader to...

    And Shakespeare, I think, allows the reader to cautiously infer the poet. The epilogue at the end of THE TEMPEST may be regarded both as the character Prospero's entreaty and the author himself...
  20. Replies
    74
    Views
    10,146

    Along with his or her comments on Sonnet 50, G.R....

    Along with his or her comments on Sonnet 50, G.R. Ledger(the one with the flowers) included Sonnet 49 from Sir Philip Sidney's series, another fine horse poem! He or she noted that the first line of...
  21. Replies
    74
    Views
    10,146

    And one might quote Professor Greenblatt again: ...

    And one might quote Professor Greenblatt again: "the sonnets are a thrilling, deeply convincing staging of the poet;s inner life, an intimate performance.........and the sonnets are a cunning...
  22. Replies
    74
    Views
    10,146

    On reading back the narrative, or as Professor...

    On reading back the narrative, or as Professor Greenblatt put it: "Is it the truth or a piece of flattering rhetoric?" Online is a nice commentary( the one with the white flowers) where we find on...
  23. Replies
    74
    Views
    10,146

    The excerpt from R3(posted by P.B.) and the...

    The excerpt from R3(posted by P.B.) and the "wand'ring bark"(posted by kev67) might recall John Barth's Short Story NIGHT-SEA JOURNEY. There is a nice critique online noting several allusions in the...
  24. Replies
    74
    Views
    10,146

    Professor Bate goes on: "TWELFTH NIGHT is highly...

    Professor Bate goes on: "TWELFTH NIGHT is highly relevant here. Of all Shakespeare's plays, it is closest to the sonnets in it's anatomy of what Meres called 'the perplexities of love'...........If...
  25. Replies
    74
    Views
    10,146

    A quote from Professor Bate is in order: "As...

    A quote from Professor Bate is in order: "As Shakespeare stitched together multiple sources to make his plays, so the collection called Shakespeare's Sonnets stitches together multiple poems with...
Results 1 to 25 of 94
Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4