questions: A Study in Scarlet
i have a few questions. these are:
1) is it really true that there were no tests for identifying dried blood before holmes' test?
2) which year did holmes and watson meet? was it 1881?
3) holmes is ignorant about the Copernican theory and the composition of the solar system because according to holmes, "If we went round the moon it would not make a pennyworth of difference to me or to my work.”
but he mentions Euclid's propositions ("His conclusions were as infallible as so many propositions of Euclid"). does it make any difference to him or his work whether Euclid's propositions were infallible or not? (by the way, he also mentions Euclid's fifth proposition in The Sign of Four)
4) holmes says that a man's height can be calculated from the length of his stride. i am really interested to know the relationship between a man's height and the length of his stride. can anyone help?
5) why did holmes give an advertisement about the ring before he knew whether it was mentioned in the evning papers or not?
6) in chapter 6 (Tobias Gregson Shows What He Can Do), watson wrote that gregson came up the stairs three steps at a time and burst into their sitting room. how did he know that it was "three steps at a time" if he only heard his footsteps? he didn't even know the total number of steps in the staircase.
7) why did Hope leave the pills in stangerson's room?
8) why did Hope went as a cabman to 221B Baker Street when he knew that his accomplice (who went to retrieve the ring) was followed by a man from that same house?
9) what does the following mean:
“Populus me sibilat, at mihi plaudo
Ipse domi simul ac nummos contemplar in arca.”
Answers to your questions
When Gregson went up 3 stairs at a time he was in a hurry. This fact would not only cause the loudness of each step to be magnified, but in doing so, there would be less footfalls heard to achieve the top step. Try it sometime with a witness to determine what you are doing without seeing you. By the way, the steps are wooden and would give an additional sound and vibration to the house. I lived in a 4-story Victorian home and could tell when someone took the stairs 2 or 3 at a time. Gregson is tall to be able to take 3 steps at once.
A tall man will usually have a longer stride since his legs are longer, unless there is some abnormality in his physical makeup, such as inheriting an extremely long torso and short legs. There are a few of these types out there. This usually happeńs when the mother is 4' 10'' AND the father is 6' 5'' in my grandparents case.
I read a book in 1966 which I believe was titled, "The Real Sherlock Holmes" and was based on the medical professor A. Conan Doyle based his Sherlock Holmes character. In it, were described many of the things, such as fingerprints and blood reagent test that were not used as evidence at the time by the police force, but that were eventually use due to the Sherlock Holmes stories. If you read the early history of J. Edgar Hoover (FBI) fingerprints were not widely used in America in the early 1920's until he came upon two black men who were not related but were identical in everyway but their age and fingerprints.