UTC Student
02-06-2003, 02:00 AM
I feel really sorry for your students then, because they are missing out on one of the greatest works of literature to come out of America. If this book doesn't excite you, then you are reading it completely wrong. Melville is doing so much with the philosophy and history, and perfectly weaves it into the main narrative. Melville's genius lies in his ability to take an example from whale hunting, relate it to some abstract idea, and then tie it into the narrative. The philosophy is just as important as the action, and the history is just as important as the philosophy. Remove one single component (which the movie does) and you do not have the same masterpiece. One of the joys of reading a book like Moby Dick is playing the literary games that the novel offers, and the movie doesn't give you any of that. Our society is too action dependent, and it is a tragedy to hear that another great novel has been sacrificed in the classroom to a movie. There is no replacement for such learning experiences as Moby Dick has to offer. <br>