Eclipse by Stephenie Meyer

[kelby_lake]

This book reaches new levels of dross. It descends into a farcical love triangle and the action is tres boring. And it is the size of a brick.

Jacob could have been a good character were Meyer detatched enough to make him a threat to Bella and Eddy's relationship but it's essentially wish-fulfillment. Badly written at that.

[ArunSaxena]

well i dont mind reading voluminous novels provided the narrative is intriguing. i like the story, its pretty good.

[Joreads]

It was far to long I agree with Kelby on that it needed a good edit. I still enjoyed it though

[*Classic*Charm*]

It was far to long I agree with Kelby on that it needed a good edit. I still enjoyed it though

Sadly, all her books could use a good edit. The split infinitives everywhere were really bothering me (yep, I'm the grammar police;)).

But I really enjoyed it too.