story with holes ---9(???)

[Nightshade]

Well I miss this game and the last one never did get solved sooo...

A man is found dead wit an empty cloth suitcase.

[smilingtearz]

we're suposed to solve these?

[Themis]

We're supposed to ask question which Night can answer with yes or no. And eventually, yes, we're supposed to solve this.

[smilingtearz]

ohh, alright..
well so was a weapon found near the dead body?

[kathycf]

A man is found dead wit an empty cloth suitcase.

I will infer that the suitcase is significant since it is mentioned in some detail...
Is the suitcase the man's?

(leaving me to wonder, what was in it before the man died???? Also making me wonder if the man was murdered or died of natural causes):eek:

[AimusSage]

aahhhh, I just exerted my brain on some silly riddle, I'll get back to it :)

[Nightshade]

well so was a weapon found near the dead body
no.

Is the suitcase the man's?
yes and yet no:D

(leaving me to wonder, what was in it before the man died???? Also making me wonder if the man was murdered or died of natural causes
thee your on the right track :D

[kathycf]

no.

yes and yet no:D

thee your on the right track :D

Did the man steal the suitcase?

[Themis]

Night, are you perhaps mistaking Kathy for me? ;)

I'm on no track at all, so ...

Was the man slayn by the suitcase? (As in: did it fall on him? Did someone strike him with it?)

[RJbibliophil]

Does the man have any enemies who happen to be suitcases?

@Themis, I really like your new avy! it is so cute!

[kathycf]

Did the man have a heart attack due extreme fear because of an incipient attack by a suitcase?

[Nightshade]

Did the man steal the suitcase?
No


Night, are you perhaps mistaking Kathy for me ayayayayaya ! not again....sorry but why am I doing itt anybody care to explain? especially as I rember seeing your new avy and saying wow that is a nice one :rolleyes:

Night, are you perhaps mistaking Kathy for me? no he was not killed by the suitcase. Nor are his enimies suitcases and lastly no it wasnt a heartattack brought on by said suitcases.

Have you lot been reading terry pratchett??

[smilingtearz]

did someone kill him by hitting him on the head with the suitcase?

[Nightshade]

did someone kill him by hitting him on the head with the suitcase?
No but sort of the right area.

[smilingtearz]

was he hit with whatever was in the suitcase?

[Nightshade]

Yes!!


:lol:
good morning btw :wave:

[smilingtearz]

uh.. good afternoon :D

Was it something "precious"??

[Nightshade]

y--yess
you ned to be more exact :brow: :p

[smilingtearz]

Obviously the "theif" wanted whatever was in the suitcase.. he threatened the man and took the "object" and hit the man with the same...

is the object a "single" object?(or is it a collection of things? .. like a bag full of diamonds or something?"

[Nightshade]

Obviously the "theif" wanted whatever was in the suitcase.. he threatened the man and took the "object" and hit the man with the same...

I resent that its not that obvious and anyway your not quite right.


is the object a "single" object?(or is it a collection of things? .. like a bag full of diamonds or something?"

Canth answer that yes or no questions only http://www.cosgan.de/images/midi/frech/c020.gif

got to run now bye :wave:

[smilingtearz]

oh don't go!!

uhmm.. was it a "single" object??.. now you can answer it

[ShoutGrace]

Were the thief and the man related?

[Themis]

Have you lot been reading terry pratchett??

Actually, yes. :D

Hm.
Did the man hit himself with whatever was in the suitcase?
Was there even a second person involved?

[kathycf]

I don't care what nightshade says, I still think the suitcase did it!!

;) :lol: ;)

[papayahed]

Did the man have cloths on?
Was the man murdered?
Did the man know his murderer (if there was one)?
Is there anything in the suitcase?
Is there music playing?
Did the man know he was going to die?

[papayahed]

Night???????????????

[RJbibliophil]

Did the man want to die?

[papayahed]

Now that you're back Nightie, let's go!!!!!!!!!!

[kathycf]

Yes, I have been wondering what the solution was...

[papayahed]

Night??????

[RJbibliophil]

Night????

MIAs must be found

[papayahed]

Night????

MIAs must be found

I got a PM a few days ago saying she was back...

[Nightshade]

Err was it a few days ago :blush: :redface: sorry got out of the habit of computer time now errr right so do you want to continue or do youjust want the solution.??

[Nightshade]

Did the man have cloths on?
desions desions.... YES!


Was the man murdered?
yes

Did the man know his murderer (if there was one)?
welll in a way

Is there anything in the suitcase?
yes ( its a clue)

Is there music playing?
Yes!

Did the man know he was going to die?
In the last few seconds yes

[papayahed]

Did the murdered use whatever is in the suitcase to kill DG?
Is the music relevent?
Did anybody witness the murder?
Is it obvious that the DG is dead?
Was he stabbed? Shot?
Was the DG bloody?
Was DG going on a trip, hence the suitcase?

[Nightshade]

Did the murdered use whatever is in the suitcase to kill DG?
oh irony of ironies he did ( but not alone)

Is the music relevent?
not really but somthing else that can be heard is

Did anybody witness the murder?
yup

Is it obvious that the DG is dead? ummm pretty much

Was he stabbed? Shot?
nope

Was the DG bloody?
yep

Was DG going on a trip, hence the suitcase?
yep

I am begining to get the feeling that this death has changed somewhat since It started. I think we might be in need of a summing up right about now.

[Nightshade]

DG
Man
whereing clothes ( not that it really counts)

is realtivley near an empty cloth bag.

was going on a trip.

Didnt particually want to die but didnt exactly get much say in the matter.
____________________________________________

Bag
Plain ordinary carpet/ sports type bag.
IT did not EAT or otherwise kill DG
he was not killed by the suitcase in any way.
He was going on a trip hence the bag.
_____________________________________________
What was in the bag
Was valuable to him.
Was used to hit him on the head
( didnt actually kill him)
Is relevant to the story.
It was a single object

You need some more on the place and the object and the MOTIVE :D
:wave:

[kathycf]

Was the killer of DG someone previously known to the deceased? Is this how they knew the contents of the bag, and why they needed the object badly enough to kill for it?

[RJbibliophil]

Was the purpose of the murder to acquire the object?
To get the object out of DG's posession?

[Nightshade]

Was the purpose of the murder to acquire the object?
no

To get the object out of DG's posession?
not really

Was the killer of DG someone previously known to the deceased? yes
Is this how they knew the contents of the bag, and why they needed the object badly enough to kill for it?
No

:D

[RJbibliophil]

was the object in the bag merely a mean to kill DG?
did the murderer care about the object?
did the murderer take the object with him/her?
was the object left at the scene of the murder?
was a concussion involved in the death?

[papayahed]

was the Murderer related to the DG?
Was there only 1 object in the suitcase?
was the DG going on a plane? train? automobile?
Was it Night when the murder occured? Daytime?
Was the murder an accident?
Was the object something that is normally found in a suitcase? ie travel stuff
Did the DG put the object in the suitcase? murderer?

[Nightshade]

was the object in the bag merely a mean to kill DG?
no

did the murderer care about the object?
not really

did the murderer take the object with him/her?
yep

was the object left at the scene of the murder?
nope

was a concussion involved in the death?
sort of

was the Murderer related to the DG? no

Was there only 1 object in the suitcase? yes

was the DG going on a plane? train? automobile?
no yes no

Was it Night when the murder occured? Daytime?
errr yes no

Was the murder an accident?
hardly likly to be murder then is it?? no

Was the object something that is normally found in a suitcase? ie travel stuff
nope
Did the DG put the object in the suitcase? murderer?
DG

:D

[papayahed]

Wait just a ding dang moment, how can the murderer take the object if it's still i the suitcase??

Did the murder occur at a train station?
Was the object in the suitcase bloody?
Was the object a household appliance? weapon?

[Nightshade]

Hey the suit case is empty!!!

Yupp at th train station

ANd no it wasnt a housuold object and sinec it was used to kill someone doesnt that MAKE it a weapon but ordinarly no it would not be considered a weapon!

:D

[papayahed]

ohhh, my bad.

Was the object a sports equipment?
Was the DG murdered to protect others?
as the murder a random act of violence?
Was the man waiting for a train? was he on the train platform?
Did the murderer get on a train after the crime?

[Nightshade]

Was the object a sports equipment?
no

Was the DG murdered to protect others?
no the revers in fact

as the murder a random act of violence?
no

Was the man waiting for a train?yes
was he on the train platform?
are we talking before r after he became the dead guy?



Did the murderer get on a train after the crime?
no

[papayahed]

Was the DG going to hijack the train? or otherwise do harm to the train or others?
Did more then one person have a hand in killing DG?
was the DG killed somewhere else and moved to his present location?
is his present location on the train platform?
Did someone make an annoucment over the loudspeaker to stop the DG?

[Nightshade]

Was the DG going to hijack the train?
no

or otherwise do harm to the train or others?
no

Did more then one person have a hand in killing DG?
no

was the DG killed somewhere else and moved to his present location?
no

is his present location on the train platform?
not ON no

Did someone make an annoucment over the loudspeaker to stop the DG?
no

[papayahed]

Was the DG under the train?
Was the DG pushed under the train?
Was the loudspeaker announcing the arrival of the train?
Was the murderer related to the DG?
Did the Murderer think that whatever was in the bag was valuable?
Did the murderer escape the scene of the crime?

[papayahed]

????????????????

[Nightshade]

Ooops sorry Papayhed, missed it:blush:

Was the DG under the train?
yes

Was the DG pushed under the train?
yes

Was the loudspeaker announcing the arrival of the train?
errrr Im not sure I se how its relevant.

Was the murderer related to the DG?
nope

Did the Murderer think that whatever was in the bag was valuable?
not particually

Did the murderer escape the scene of the crime?no he didnt need to.

:D

[papayahed]

Did more then 1 person push DG under the train?
Was the object in the bag a train ticket?

[Nightshade]

At last!!!


Did more then 1 person push DG under the train? no

Was the object in the bag a train ticket?
and no



:D":D:D:D